J. B.
Yelp
Oh how the mighty have fallen. To preface, my wife and I were married here a few years back, so I have extremely fond memories of the property, the staff, the food, and the rooms. Our experience over Valentine's Day was so horrendous that I don't know that we'll be back, at least not until we hear that things turn back around.
Upon checking in, I thought the front desk wasn't super friendly, but who cares right - all you need is your keys. But in retrospect, after all the other mishaps (see below), it was more clear that the problem is insidious.
After arriving to our room, we found an open container of yogurt in the mini-fridge. Now this is kind of gross in general, especially given its dairy, but during the times of Covid - it irked me even further. Additionally, the pump in the back of the toilet wasn't filling the tank, and therefore would not fully flush. For the rest of our trip, my wife and I had to manually hold the pump chain up to fill the tank, so our toilet would flush. To make matters worse, after getting out of the shower, I went to put a bathrobe on, but it had dried blood all over the shoulder (it was in the closet in its dry cleaning plastic wrap). I called housekeeping immediately, but they didn't even offer an apology. I had to demand that they bring me a clean/fresh one, and they acted as if it was some giant inconvenience to them.
Also, I feel as if a resort of this supposed caliber should have amazing food, which simply wasn't the case any longer, at least not at Frost Bar. I wrote about that separately here:
https://www.yelp.com/biz/ocean-terrace-brewster?hrid=qsxYNAPXABEB_TKyyNCTVA&utm_campaign=www_review_share_popup&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=(direct)
Shame. I even tried to connect with them directly, before writing this review, to no avail.