The New York Bakery Boys

Ordered a 2ft Hero half Italian and Half American style. We were very disappointed because it had no red peppers, short on the meats and it was simply not made with Love. It just wasn’t a NY style hero to have for our Super Bowl gathering! Sorry….

The New Yorker breakfast sandwich was a total win. The asiago bagel was perfectly toasted and cheesy, packed with a huge, fluffy egg layer and melty cheese. The crispy bacon bits added the perfect crunch. Super filling, super delicious, definitely worth trying.

I walked in and stood for free as they were making what looked like pick up sandwiches. Nobody offered to help. I ain't to the bathroom and then printed magnets in the cool machine and went back to counter where i still wasnt greeted... finally a girl turned sind said good morning then turned back adding to work on sandwiches... eventuality a gentleman came to get my order. 6 bagels $9.99 not a bad price. The area looks beautiful 😍 I'm going the bagels are the hype

A real treat in the heart of Celebration Fl. Plenty of seats inside and out for you to enjoy your fresh made bagels or subs. The staff is amazing and the taste is authentic NY! I’ll be back often.

Always a great experience; very friendly knowledgeable folks that care, delicious bagels and breakfast sandwiches at a very reasonable price. Cozy ambiance. What else needed for a joyful breakfast…? Thanks guys!

Absolutely loved this place! New York Bakery Boys in Celebration instantly brought me back home to NYC. The food, the atmosphere, even the smell when you walk in—everything reminded me of the classic New York bakeries I grew up with. I ordered breakfast and it was amazing. Fresh, flavorful, and done exactly the way a real NYC spot would do it. The staff was friendly, the service was quick, and you can really feel the pride they put into their food. If you’re craving a true New York taste in Florida, this is the place. Highly recommend!

I was on a 5 day vacation with my family we discovered this place 3 days too late in our trip because we visited 2 days in a row for breakfast. Delicious 😋 I recommend The New Yorker with bacon, egg, american cheese and I added cream cheese on a asiago bagel . My sister loved the cream cheese with lox . We definitely will visit again on our next trip to Orlando . Fast friendly staff .

Nice New York type deli, food was very good NY deli food. Food would have received a 5 star but I was missing an item I ordered. I did not check bag until I was back in room. Sorry no pictures of food. I couldn't wait to try it, I will next time, sandwich was full of meat and good flavor! I will be back!

This is a true 5 review. My husband had emergency surgery while we were on vacation and we ended up in Celebration. I had scoped out New York Bakery Boys as a good option for breakfast or lunch (not hard to beat hospital food). The only challenge is the location. Because it's in downtown Celebration, parking is not easy. My map took me about a 4-minute walk away, but I think you can get closer. The main roads are blocked off to cars, it Bakery Boys isn't. Staff were so friendly and kind! (Maybe not authentic New Yorkers lol.) There were lots of fun snacks from Japan and China and then some items from Italy. I got a New York Classic breakfast sandwich, which was a fried egg, American cheese and meat of my choice (I chose bacon) and I chose the garlic bagel (highly recommend). It was $8.99. I am not exaggerating when I say this was the best breakfast bagel sandwich I've ever had! And I'm a breakfast bagel sandwich aficionado. The bagel made it so flavorful with the crunchy garlic. The American cheese was a surprise joy. Definitely come here for breakfast!

Really great find. I'm sure if you're looking for reviews on a bagel place in Florida you've been in the same boat I was - everything sucks, it's flavorless or the bagel comes from Sysco. Not here. Everything was so good and fresh, one of the best ham, egg and cheese bagels I've found here. They put an appropriate amount of cream cheese, the eggs are fresh not just frozen patties tossed in the microwave and the ham was seared a bit. I also got a caramel iced coffee, nothing to write home about but the coffee didn't taste burnt or acidic so a win is a win. I got the mini cannoli as well, nice crispy shell and solid filling. It tasted a bit stale so maybe they can look into different storage for them but all in all a nice treat. They lose a star just for service, many people were chatting behind the counter and ignoring me for a solid few minutes before someone came over. They were friendly in our interactions but not a great introduction!

Had a delicious PORK ROLL egg and cheese on a jalapeño cheddar bagel at this shop. We were driving around looking for breakfast and stumbled upon this cute small town area in Celebration. Walked in and everyone was super nice I loved the vibe it reminded of my last visit in Jersey. After I ordered at the front my order was ready pretty quickly. I decided to sit outside while the weather was still nice and I have to say I really enjoyed my food it was so good and the pork roll was nice and crispy. Definitely would stop here again. Also they have a magnet kiosk that you can print photos right from your phone which I was amazed by I ended up getting five of them for a good price. It's the perfect souvenir.

Such a yummy find. I have a hard time with bagels in Florida being from NY. This spot is definitely worthy of a good bagel. And the cream cheese is delicious too. I tried the special tricolor (rainbow) cookie cream cheese and WOW. There was bits of cookie in it. So unique and it's rare to find rainbow cookies down in FL. It's a nice little bagel deli, with good breakfast and lunch options. The service was quick, they had plenty of seating and overall it was a good spot to grab a quick and inexpensive meal.

Delicious bagels. We asked for cheddar cheese in our bagels but they came with American. That may have ruined our experience given the 4 vs 5 stars - next time I'd skip the cheese if they really don't have cheddar. The bagels themselves are great and all the ingredients are good except the cheese. It's a corner shop in the heart of Celebration - everything is so beautiful in celebration it's hard not to have an exceptional ambiance

Was the sandwich good? Yes. But holy F... 17 dollars! It wasn't a large portion either it was just a normal size with a small pickle as a side and no drink. 17 bucks for that? No way I'll come back! Insane!

Loving this spot! Enough so that we came 2 days in a row! The ambiance is very casual.. it's basically a specialty market and sandwhich shop / bakery. The market pricing is a bit expensive.. but if you're in the Celebration downtown area it's definitely more convenient to walk over here and pickup a few essentials than it is to run to a grocery store. Also they have some interesting NY finds that you don't see in grocery stores here.. like the selection of Oreos is pretty incredible! The sandwiches here are delicious and filling and there's a big range of options. My kids had the sliders and hot dog and those are very reasonably priced and a nice portion. We came back in the morning for bagels with cream cheese. Theres a sign to explain the cream cheese.. I thought it was a joke, but apparently it's not. I thought I liked a lot of cream cheese but they give such an absurd amount that we had to take half of it off.. now we know for next time. My daughter ordered a cinnamon roll.. it was good but no icing which she was very bummed about. The staff here are very pleasant as well, which is a definite bonus.

Great selection of delicious bagels and other bakers goods. I enjoyed a refreshingly tasty iced latte while visiting the area on a sunny Saturday afternoon. Staff was friendly and courteous. Interior and outdoor seating area is clean and comfortable.

Cool spot! Stopped in to see what offerings they had and it was a nice variety! There were some people sitting inside and eating and there are seats outside as well. Nice environment. I had already ate lunch but couldn't leave without grabbing some items. Some are baked in house and some are delivered daily and still fresh. Left with some muffins for the morning. The service was awesome. Two guys working and they were friendly and helpful and had a ton of recommendations. Genuine interactions too!

The New York Bakery Boys delivers an authentic New York deli feel with all the classic flavors you'd expect. The bagels are fresh, hearty, and packed with staple New York tastes that hit the spot every time. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making the experience even better. With reasonable prices for the quality and portions, it's a great go-to spot for a true New York-style bite.

This place was amazing so I'm gonna keep it short and sweet! What a great find while with family and friends enjoying a night out. A very comforting place to have a filling and satisfying sandwich after all the crappy hotel food. The bagel sandwich is the deal of the century, huge & delicious. Great variety and super friendly staff. Will definitely come again when in the area and try something new !!

To say this place is authentic is an understatement. Great bagels and subs made with Boarhead meats. Step through the door and you'll think you're in NY!

The New York Bakery Boys are in downtown Celebration!! This is a quality company with decent prices and great food. I'm glad to see they keep a cafe and mini grocery store aspect to this space. This is a great spot for a grab and go meal.

Bagels and food were solid Coffee was not good Three of us ordered lattes and there was an inch tall layer of syrup on the bottom of our drinks, and pile of coffee grounds in our drink So maybe stay away from the espresso at this place.

New York bakery is the best place to ever be in this location in Celebration, since sweet escapes left. Their sandwiches are amazing. I had Copy Katz hot pastrami with spicy mustard and Swiss cheese. Literally one of the best I've had and we lived in New Jersey and New York. Closest thing to a New York deli you can get in Florida. All the other stuff is amazing as well. Prices are right and the service is great.

I have only tried a muffin here, it was really good! Very very sweet and could only eat a few bites. The smell inside the store is very strong and personally off putting. I was hesitating over a lunch sandwich but nothing really beats a Publix sub. Staff was friendly.

The food is delicious, the service was awkward, walked in and no one was in line, two employees were behind the counter carrying on a conversation (not work related) and they did not even acknowledge us. Once they finally did and we ordered then things got better as their food was wonderful. I had an everything bagel with chive cream-cheese. They have bottled drinks for sale.

This is a cute stop for delicious bagels in Celebration. Generous 'schmear' of cream cheese. Loved the foreign Oreos too!

very disappointing experience. ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a kaiser roll, opened the sandwich and took a bite to a stale roll but was told that "the rolls are just like that" however they never have been in the past. after eating about 1/3 of the sandwich, i realized there wasn't even cheese on it. so i took it back and was told that they could not remake the sandwich because i ate some of it, so they gave me a slice of toast with an egg and a slice of cheese on top as a replacement. as someone who also works in food service, it was shocking to be denied a proper correction after a mistake made on their end but unfortunately because i didn't inspect the sandwich to make sure the cheese i ordered was on there that was not the case. will not be returning. customer service was abysmal.

I ordered from here at first on Uber Eats to my Airbnb when I was staying near Disney. I loved it so much that we went to the store the next day on a Sunday. First off, the location is in this cute little town that looks like a Disney setup, and they had a nice market outside on the street. We went inside, and I ordered the cheese, egg, and turkey sausage on an everything bagel (I got the same thing from my delivery). The sandwich was so good, and just what I needed for breakfast. I love how soft and toasted the bagel is. They give you a fair amount of food for the price. I also got a chicken Caesar wrap to go eat later. That was delicious too. As someone from up north, the food tasted very authentic to NYC! I will definitely return.

Cutest little breakfast gem in the heart of Celebration, Orlando! I stumbled upon The New York Bakery Boys this morning and I'm so glad I did. Tucked away in the charming town of Celebration, this cozy deli-style spot instantly won me over the moment I stepped in the door. I was warmly greeted right away, you can just feel the friendly, local vibe in the air. The shop is small, with a handful of indoor and outdoor seats, and a self-serve coffee setup that adds to the relaxed, homey feel. I ordered an Asiago cheese bagel with eggs, Swiss cheese, and tomato -- and oh my goodness, the bagel was so soft and flavorful. Absolute perfection. While I waited, I couldn't help but notice the young woman working the counter, she knew so many of the customers by name and even had their usual orders ready without them saying a word. It was like watching a Hallmark movie unfold in real life! Whether you're a local or just visiting, do yourself a favor: stop by Celebration and grab a bagel from this spot. It's charming, delicious, and full of heart.

This second location in the area is a great addition to downtown Celebration. It offers many of the same delicious bagels and goodies as their other location just a couple miles away off 192 near the Nike outlet and Wendy's. The service was friendly and efficient. We walked in past the many people seated outdoors and indoors. We waited only a moment to order and our food was served within 10 minutes. You could immediately see their attention to quality was evident in the several people overlooking orders. One of the owners checked on us as we were waiting. Despite just opening, it already had the feel of a neighborhood favorite spot. It seemed very no frills but full of charm and energy. We ordered bagels with egg and cheese, and picked up some beverages from the display. We also took home some assorted bagels. Everything was fresh and tasty. Parking can be found on the surrounding streets, as well as behind the post office next door.

Fantastic bagel sandwiches and snacks of all kinds. Great coffee and drinks. Service is top notch. Most highly recommended!!

Came in on a Saturday morning- We ended up waiting about 25 minutes for our bagels. Not great, but I guess it's what you have to expect on a weekend morning. The menu has a variety of bagels and flavored cream cheeses. Everything we got was delicious and we enjoyed eating our bagels on a bench near the lake across the street.

Great option for fresh bagel sandwiches in the Orlando area! It's rare that i'm over in Celebration but was in the area this morning and looking for a new spot to try. New York Bakery Boys didn't disappoint! It was pretty busy so we did have to wait around 15-20 for our bagels and coffee but there was plenty of seating inside and outside so it wasn't a problem. The bagels themselves and the ingredients were fresh and the price wasn't too bad with a Lox bagel coming in at around $12 and a chicken, egg and cheese bagel at around $9. They also offered hot coffee and espresso drinks! Will definitely be back next time i'm in Celebration.

New York Bakery Boys Lived Up To The Hype. Bagels Are Baked Fresh Daily, The Hungry man Breakfast Bagel Was Probably The Best I've Ever Had! Nova Lox Bagel was Phenomenal As Well, and The Italian Hero Sub Was The Winner.. So Good, I Forgot To Take A Picture. Well Done, Will Be Back!

Their Rueben is barely okay due to dry corn beef. Culver's Rueben is SO SO SO MUCH BETTER. Pickle was good. Daughter really enjoyed her BLT.

Bagels are delicious, best asiago I've had in Orlando! It's a lovely, peaceful little joint to sit and hang out in. On a chilly day I recommend a hot cocoa!

Gonna rate a 3 because there's a lot of room for improvement. The place was very busy, and considering we received our food in a timely manner, staff was still attentive and hustling hard to serve all, but the place had no clear flow and no one could tell where to go, who had ordered and who was on what line, overall very disorganized. 2nd area in need of improvement would be presentation of food, after seeing their instagram the sandwiches were skimpy and the bacon egg and cheese had no bacon, we had to go ask and they gave us a bag of bacon. Not sure if would revisit.

Really great authentic New York bagels and breakfast wraps. Haven't tried anything else but everything seems very fresh and delicious. Very kind staff as well! Will definitely be back

The chicken ceaser wrap was amazing! Such a cute shop with a little grocery section and plenty of food/dessert options. Izzy took great care of me and I will be back.

Friendly staff. Food was delicious. Reminds me of home, New York Deli's. Nice quiet place.

Awesome! Visiting from Out of town (used to live nearby) and hadn't been to Celebration in years. We didn't want resort food and came over here - Wow! So glad we did! Fresh NY style bagels in a fun, cozy atmosphere. Service was great and fast despite a bit of a longer line. Fresh, fresh, fresh! They cooked my husband's angel literally in front of us because they had run out of the kind he wanted. We did a bagel w chive cream cheese and one of their bagel breakfast sandwiches. Run, don't walk if you want fresh breakfast or lunch!

Looks, and tastes like home, but a bit pricier. We have long been needing a corner store deli shop and many places have tried in this same spot but all of them just... sucked? Until now.

Everything is fantastic...drinks, food and service, especially Nosaiba, who is always so cheerful, greeting me by name with a huge smile....awesome place!

Pleasant experience, excellent atmosphere, excellent bagels. Great service, Highly recommend!!!!

Fantastic bagels. Generous amount of high quality cream cheese. Had an egg, sausage and cheese on an Asiago bagel-wonderful. We will continue to keep coming back

This place is complete chaos. It was full of a mob of people with no direction about how or where to order. Waited in a line for 20minutes only to have a man walk up and cut a line of 10 people to pay for some cookies with no regard to those around him. Once we got to a register we were told it was a 40 minute wait for food. We left with nothing after wasting half of an hour of our time. We'll never come here again.

My sandwich was awesome - good selection for breakfast sandwiches too. - coming back to get some bagels

got food delivered and it was not good. bagels were not warm and too much butter and cream cheese were on them. bacon was cold and hash brown was soggy. this was not the delivery drivers fault because it was only a 4 min drive. the only good thing was the prepackaged orange juice. definitely does not taste like a new york bagel.

Certainly not a NY bagel. Their cinnamon raisin bagel tasted nothing like cinnamon raisin. They have NY prices but not the taste.