The Old Feed Mill

We made a reservation for late on a chilly cold January Saturday. We were the only people there but the staff treated us amazingly. Anna was a great server. The food was spectacular as expected. 1st class operation.

Absolutely incredible A+ restaurant. The Old Feed Mill is a historic landmark and an amazing beacon to the beautiful area. We were recommended by another local vendor to the area after visiting The House on the Rock. The atmosphere, customer service, and quality of food was unparalleled to any other restaurant. The Old Feed Mill is a local treasure and I highly recommend The Old Feed Mill to all. The strip steak is amazing. Bravo!!! 👏

Went here a while back — great food and an enjoyable atmosphere. They catered our wedding at Sugarland Barn and did a wonderful job. We come back every year and buy a white chocolate key lime cheesecake (our wedding cake) to celebrate our anniversary and they do a great job!

There was a buffet with several meat and vegetable options as well as salad and homemade rolls and 🏠 desserts. It was wonderful. The building is an old mill and very quaint with a gift shop with homemade home goods and jellies and jams. Atmosphere is fantastic, service excellent. Highly recommend The Old Feed Mill.

A Kats family favorite, fantastic food that is farm to table & the restaurant is built within an old feed mill. There's a gift shop & an upstairs area for private parties. Their meatloaf & beef stew dishes are the two that I'll always go back for, but don't forget about the dessert! 😋 Dutch Apple Pie or Cheesecake

I will start with the positive. The prime rib was the sauces with the cheese pies, especially the honey mustard were wonderful..... Now, for the extremely disappointing part, the menu claims that the prime rib is a 12oz portion.My wife ate less than a 1/4 of her serving and the remaining portion weighed 4.8oz. Needless to say, I consumed mine with ease. Won't likely return when we can get what we pay for much closer to home.

Warm, friendly atmosphere. Waitress was amazing, described everything wonderfully, checking to see how everything was several times, if we needed anything else. Even helped with the wine list, able to sample a couple before choosing a glass. A lot of choices and everything from scratch. The prices are on the higher side, but so worth it!!

My first time here and probably my last. They weren't that busy, only a few tables but so many mistakes. It took a few minutes for our server to take our order, drink, appetizers and main meal which came with soup. Warm bread was delivered and then finally our wine. Appetizers came and then finally our meal but, we never did get our soup. When we got our check, we asked for the soup that was never delivered and dessert to go. Got our dessert but the soup never came. I got home ready to enjoy my dessert and noticed mold on top. Sigh. Our meal was delicious, but not sure it made up for everything else that went wrong.