Greg W.
Yelp
We were at Olde Heritage during the Sunday NFL afternoon games during "leaf peeping" season. These two factors mean it is going to be BUSY. However, we didn't anticipate how badly it would impact our dining experience.
The food, pricing, and atmosphere was superb. The reason for the 3 stars and not higher was due to the service we received during our visit. It took us over 20m to be seated, which was understandable given the leaf peepers and NFL rush. However, what I cannot look away from was the lack of attentiveness of the staff or the understaffing for such a busy time of the year, especially on an NFL Sunday.
The initial wait when we were seated was over 10 minutes, which wasn't out of the ordinary given how busy the servers were. However, we were frequently asking and requesting things multiple times before we actually got them: beers, refills, ranch/sauce for the wings/carrots/celery, ketchup for fries, etc.
I would be willing to give the place another shot given the food was very well done and it was reasonably priced. I'm not sure if this kind of experience is out of the norm or business as usual... but it was enough to leave a less-than-ideal taste in our mouths despite being on a very relaxed vacation. If you are looking for a place that serves higher quality or "dolled-up" tavern/bar food, this is your place. However, depending on when you go I would be wary of the potential for a long wait and/or a less than attentive server if they are understaffed or have too many tables to cover.