The Pie Pizzeria - Underground

This ended up being a disappointment. It came well recommended & was in a cool location but the pizza wasn't good. I preferred the Thai but no one else liked it at all and the only person who liked the All Meat pizza was my SiL. To make matters worse, we drove half an hour to get to it and the parking was hellacious. I had to drop everyone off & then walk half a mile back to the restaurant. That is what it is but there was no pay-off with great pizza. The crust was kind of doughy and for my family, the crust is the most important part of the entire production. It has to be crispy, but chewy. It just tasted low-grade. The toppings were OK, but not great and the red sauce was really bad. It tasted very much like cheap sauce from a can. I guess the people of Salt Lake just don't understand what good pizza is based on the recommendations from locals and the Yelp reviews. I get it, I'm from Seattle originally and during my 40+ years living there, we had exactly 2 consistently good spots beyond one off, high end stuff from Tom Douglas that you had to go downtown for that was incredible but in no way standard pizza. I live in Las Vegas now and you can't throw a rock without hitting a great spot down here. We had like 4 of the top-100 pizza spots in the US a couple of years ago & apparently, the closer you get to NV, the better the pies get because there were spots in Cedar City & hurricane, UT that made the list as well. As for this spot, if it comes to smash or pass, it's pass for my family. There was so little meat on the chef salad, I had a hard time finding it so that was abfail as well

Sometimes a long wait while it’s busy-but always worth it! The photos speak for themself. The cheeseburger pizza with pickles is a gem of pizza flavors! We order often, and are never disappointed!

I love The Pie- I have been going here for about 2 decades now. My favorite is the Mountain of Meat pizza. (So good) One thing I have noticed though is how much the prices have gone up which I can understand but I do think it is a bit much. Pizza was delicious as usual! 🤤 Salad not so much, you really don't get enough ingredients for the size of the salad. (Used to be stuffed full now it's the bare minimum for the salad anyway) besides that though I do recommend this place.

Hidden gem! In such an amazing location and the environment is very exciting and gives you that New York feel! I’ve gone here with my kids since they were little and it’s awesome to see it hasn’t changed. Love all the drawings on the wall and the cool pictures they have hanging.

Not impressed… After already being disgruntled by the complicated parking instructions because I somehow ended up at the entirely different property for to-go orders only, (in which I was violating anyway) the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza was a greasy sloppy mess. I did not think the pizza would more closely resemble a lasagna. Cheese and toppings fell off every slice? and it was just dripping with liquid. Unfortunate that a pizzeria requires you to use a fork and knife to enjoy the food. Cheese Pizza was fine, but I do not know how you could possibly mess up a cheese pizza. If you have time to go north, definitely try Lucky Slice (which is what I’m used to being a Syracuse resident). Overall a much better product and atmosphere. Cheaper, for bigger slices with thinner crust too.

The best damn pizza in the West. Tons toppings and they don’t short you whatsoever on the cheese. Come here each time I visit family in SLC, UT.

So I’ve been to the pie many times and up til recently I would rate it 4-5 stars no problem. Tonight when we went we ordered the Buffalo Chicken Ranch pizza, which we have ordered regularly and never received it so greasy. I never have complained and am the type to avoid making complaints but in this case we asked the person who took our order if they would take it back or remake it and they said “that’s just how that pizza is” and refused to work with us. In the past this pizza was not literally soggy from grease. We did not even finish a slice each and left the pizza at our table. Based on the service the past two visits we have made I unfortunately would not recommend the pie.

Virtually all the tables were cluttered and not cleared throughout the entire restaurant. Staff could seem to care less about the fact there was no place to sit and no bus trays or trash receptacles to clear it on your own. We cleared the table shown by moving all our dishes to another table that had not been serviced. Not likely to go back, even though the pizza was excellent.