The Sagaponack

This stay was a gift for my boyfriend, and we both absolutely loved it. From the beautiful room décor to the surprise jacuzzi in our room, everything felt thoughtful and special. We also really appreciated the free snacks available in the main inn — such a nice touch that made the experience feel even more welcoming. The staff and people at the inn were incredibly kind and genuinely caring, which made us feel comfortable and well taken care of throughout our stay. The only small downside was some random loud sounds during the night, but we understand that comes with other guests being present. There is also no microwave so if you’re caught in a snow storm like we were and have things to warm up, you can’t :( Overall, it was a wonderful experience, and we would absolutely stay here again.

The Sagaponack hotel is a lovely place to stay if you are traveling to Eastern Long Island. Very clean, newly renovated with a choice of room layouts. There is an outstanding coffee machine available all day with a choice of creamers including milk, oat milk, half & half and more. I also enjoyed the various chips & cookies. Staff is friendly and beautifully maintains the environment.

Wow. Booked this for a quick Fall trip to the Hamptons. Loved it. Two rooms, spacious enough. Parking right next to the 2 suite building. Charming. Everything worked perfectly and was not super clean and nice looking. Short drives to local towns. Would I pay $1300/night during peak season? Hard pass. But for an overnight? Perfect below $300.

Absolutely fabulous stay. We stayed in the Bungalow and it was absolutely quaint. We had enough room for a pack n play for our baby and our dog. It was perfect that both rooms had a tv so our baby could watch her shows and we could watch ours. The backyard was a very nice touch for a night of relaxing. We appreciated the pool and all of the other hotel amenities. The front desk staff was very helpful and even offered a late check out since they were not tremendously busy that day with check-ins. We greatly appreciated this. Highly recommend this hotel!

This was a perfect stay in a cute cottage. It was super clean, with a comfortable bed, and a good shower. The room was quiet and everyone on staff was lovely. Sara was especially helpful and very sweet. The location was excellent - close to beautiful beaches and great restaurants. The swimming pool was a nice place to cool off in middle of July. We had everything we needed - snacks, coffee, a light breakfast. We stayed a few days to escape the city and spend time at the beach. We loved it!

The hotel is fine. It’s central as you can go to sag harbor and bridge Hampton but it’s definitely overpriced: 1) the rooms are barely remodeled from previous owner and somewhat dirty 2) WiFi is awful. We stayed in the winter and k half of our getaway was a staycation to watch movies. Except we couldn’t watch any movies. We called for service and we never got called back so we needed to call and check in. 3) our heat inthe middle of the night kept jacking up to 75 degrees, our room was sweltering despite having it set at 68. This happened 4x 4) the shades are very cheap. The room is bright due to lighting outside despite it being pitch black. I will not be staying here again. It’s overall FINE. Beds comfy, gets the job done, but not worth the price

Other than the bathroom being quite small, our room was wonderful - comfortable and very clean. Having snacks available in the Galley was great. Location was great in terms of accessing all the different areas of The Hamptons.

First time staying here and it appears the rooms were recently redone. Very nicely done and surprisingly very roomy. If you are an early riser like myself there are no coffee machines in the rooms and the office is open at 9am.

Stumbled upon this hotel and it was quite pleasant. Been busy so haven't been able to review till now. Staff was really friendly. and rooms were clean which is really important to me. It's a very quiet and serene place to unwind. I'm never really at the hotel because I like to explore the city but this place was really nice!

This used to be Wainscott Inn and then they renovated. Now its so much better! I love the new look and beds are really comfy! They are pet friendly too which is a plus. Will be back

Poor customer service. Visiting NYC on a biz trip with one day of meetings in the Hamptons. I thought my water broke prematurely & had to go to the hospital in NYC to ensure everything was okay. As a result, I cancelled 24 hours in advance, which triggered a 50% cancellation fee. I followed up the next day to see if perhaps they could make an exception with the fee & the answer was no. I spoke directly to the manager, Patty Snow, who let me know that they have a 14 day cancellation policy & no exceptions. I understand they are a business, but there was no consideration. This was not done in high season - plenty of rooms were available.

Dang - motels in the Hamptons is pricey, yo! Coming up to East Hampton for a girls getaway trip, just about everything around was booked up weeks out. Fortunately, we scored a room at the relatively well-located Wainscott Inn with two full beds. Unfortunately, on a weekend in August said room runs $300/night ... with a three night minimum. The main house is separate from the single story sets of rooms. Our pricey lil abode was miniature and cramped with a bathroom no bigger than a closet with a meager set of cheap shampoo/conditioner. I avoided touching the gnarly flammable bed covers as much as possible, though the beds themselves are pretty cozy. Since they offer seasonal rentals, the microwave and fridge make sense and add convenience. We opted for beach over swimming pool, but their set up is pretty decent, bare bones but squeaky clean. My favorite part of our stay was definitely the complimentary continental breakfast every day till 11am. Coffee, juices, muffins and a whole fabulous array of fruit served in a comfy main house living room with a large screen TV. The price you pay for relaxation!

Our family booked two cottages, and like most of the other guests on the weekend of September 24 to 26, 2021, we were in town for a wedding. By our first evening, the gruff and rude manager was the big story. When I asked him for another set of towels, he snarled that the cottage--with a queen sized bed and two twins--was not meant for three adults. But even if there had been children, he apparently didn't think they deserved towels. And no towel set was complete. First day there were no wash clothes. Second day there were no hand towels. When we had to request more toilet paper and some cups, the same manager greeted us by saying, "Whaddya want?" followed by, "What now?" When another guest, checking in, asked about food (the Inn having suspended that service during the panemic), the manager sneered, "Go a block up the road and pay $1,500 for the room. That's One, Five, Zero, Zero. They'll give you food." As for the cottage, the first time someone used the toilet, the handle broke off. The shower stall was the size of a person with no elbow room. Someone obese would be hard-pressed to fit in. And nowhere in the hotel were there amenities (like shower bars) for people with disabilities. One cottage had a full-size refrigerator with freezer (but no ice tray) and the other had something belonging in a college room. The best part of our stay was a walk along the beach...but be aware that during the high season (April 15 to September 15?) no parking is allowed if you don't have a permit.

The Wainscott Inn is the best kept secret in the Hampton's. In season, which is when we visited, the price per night is beyond fair. Conveniently located to East Hampton, Bridgehampton and Southampton. Jim and Steve whom are the Owner/Partners are the BEST!!! Beyond accomodating and helpful. Open with great suggestions for dining and other activities. We stayed in a cottage and it was perfect. first and foremost very clean. A cozy room with a kitchen counter of a sink, fridge and microwave. The bathrooms have a pedestel sink and stand up shower with great water pressure. So many hotel showers have horrible water pressure. Also, plenty of hot water. The hotel has an outside pool that is wonderful. Clean area, outside shower, lounge chairs and tables. Water temp was perfect. Weekends there is a Continental Breakfast and daily there are muffins, fruit and coffee in the front lobby. You will not go wrong with The Wainscott Inn. You will not be disappointed.

The ONLY positive aspect of the Wainscott Inn is its location.The rest is 100% negative starting with the bathroom.I don't recall a bathroom as bad as this one,even after numerous trips to Europe.It is not only tiny,but the worst shower you can have.No shower cap,i had to call to request one.The weekend breakfast is awful : bagels were not fresh at all.No service AT ALL,not even to check the pitiful buffet. Even the WIFI wasn't working. Do NOT stay there.I will never come back again ! It doesn't even deserve 1 star.

I was working in the Hamptons with a few other people. We stayed here and the room we were given was INFESTED WITH LARGE ANTS on both the walls and floor. They claimed they had wi-fi but from our room we could not access it because the signal was too poor. We also did not have cell phone reception. We got all these amenities for only $250/night ! We told a person at the front desk about the ants and we were told "There's nothing we can do." Clearly, this is all ridiculous and I don't recommend this place.

Do not stay here! It's an ok place to stay, but the worst customer service I've ever experienced. Checked out today (over an hour before checkout time) and wanted to lay by the pool for an hour or so before going back into the city. Was literally yelled at and chased out by the manager because we were told that since we checked out we had to leave immediately. Will never come back here again.

Thoroughly annoyed because when I booked the room live, I asked the reservationist about their cancellation policy and was not informed of the $100 cancellation fee! Found out when I needed to cancel and they guy on the phone gave me a devil may care attitude. Lost $100, it's in the fine print. Can't tell you about the rooms but feel like they have a little scam going with the fees.

Great location in the Hamptons, given convenience to multiple places. However, the service is poor, so don't expect much.

Sorry, but this place is a huge disappointment. The owners are really nice but you can tell they haven't put money into the hotel since the 80's. For a place charging $300.00 a night you would expect to at least be able to get on the Internet or make a phone call. Good luck. Horrible wifi(slower than dial up)and cell phone service is non existent. The rooms are pretty depressing, and there is no ambiance or style. The comforter on the bed is itchy, flammable polyester and the indoor/outdoor carpet is gross. Well hopefully a nice shower to relax in after a day at the beach right? Wrong. A heavy beige hospital shower curtain reveals a cramped plastic shower with a shower head that sprays a sharp, painful, hissing stream of water at you. Time for bed and nothing like falling asleep to the sound of cars whizzing by on the freeway. A nice touch is the paper band around the toilet indicating that it has been clean and sanitized. Too bad mine had dried urine and pubic hairs on the rim. The pool is okay, but it's just a pool. Nothing special. All in all this place is a joke. It could be really nice with some smart design, new furniture and some updated fixtures, linens, paint, etc. Obviously that's not on the owners list of priorities. Sorry Wainscott Inn. You blew it.