The Sandwich Shop Staten Island

OMG 😋 Talk about a sandwich.. Man listen I just ordered a Philly cheese from them with regular fries . Went home and me and my son's enjoyed this juicy, hot savory delight.. fries were and added bonus very light and tasty .10/10 recommend 💯❤️❤️❤️🙋🏾‍♀️

Tried this spot for the first time . The flavor of the sandwich was actually pretty solid, the meat was well-seasoned and the cheese sauce had a nice kick. But the execution? Not great. The bun was completely soaked through with sauce, making the whole thing a soggy mess. It was so wet that the juices leaked straight through the paper and foil, which made it nearly impossible to eat without a disaster. Honestly, the texture ruined what could’ve been a great first impression. Will give it another try though, for now it's 2 out of 5

HIGHLY HIGHLY RECCOMENDED. If I could give them 10 Stars I absolutely would. What a great small local business with an unbelievable menu and incredible sandwiches. Everything here is good. The crispy chicken is my number #1 favorite, but right behind that is the Chicago style italian steak sandwhich.... go look at the menu, you'll find yourself at the front counter in no time. Super clean place, good ingredients, and really nice staff running the place

Absolutely amazing food! This my new go to spot for lunch and dinner. The salads are superb, all the ingredients are always fresh, everything is homemade and it tastes it!!! I just ordered the Cobb and Caesar salads- ABSOLUTELY PERFECT! So far everything that I’ve had is top quality. Also, a HUGE shoutout for ALWAYS fulfilling requests on orders!!! You guys are the best. P.S- BEST FRIES EVER and that chicken sandwich is killer!!

So grateful this place is in Great Kills. breakfast 10/10. fried eggs w hash is out of this world. Their Mac is out of control. Sandwich Shop is your go-to for comfort food. everything served w huge butter texas toast. and always has ESPN on

Really great sandwiches and the nicest people! Really enjoyed it. We had the Chicago-style Italian Steak Sandwich and the Corned Beef Sandwich. Yum! Homemade potato salad, deliciously tangy, rounded out the meal.

I order my food for delivery . I couldnt decide which sandwich because they all look amazing . I ordered lynns reuben and ss poutine fries. The sandwich was warm, but it was not a small sandwich and it was packed with meat and the fries had a gravy on it and cheese . It was so good

Awesome sandwich shop the food is great here everything is cooked to order...great atmosphere and awesome staff. I love small family businesses and definitely support this place. I always know where to come to for some great tasting food. Thank u 😀👍🇺🇲

I never give 5 stars but I now I understand why this place is called "THE Sandwich Shop" - it is because it is the best sandwich shop on Staten Island by far.

I did a quick search and saw that their cuban and Philly cheese steak were one of their popular sandwiches so I decided to give them both a try. The store was very spacious with a few tables and seats. Ordering the sandwiches went smoothly. So the Philly was pretty decent, I would order it again. But I was not fond of the cuban. We thought the meat was a bit on the dryer side and also it's lacking some flavor. So i would skip the cuban next tome and I probably need to try more of their sandwiches.

Omg cheesesteak was the best even better than mine except for the hero bread they got to do something about it all I can say there is no better cheesesteak anywhere

Went in today around 415 to pick up 4 sandwiches. 2 chicken sandwiches, po boy and a Philly with no onions. I picked up the order and drove home. Took a bite out of my Philly and it had onions. Had to drive back to the store. Hey! Crap happens. When I went in and gave it back I wasn't told sorry. Nobody cared. I was given a new sandwich. Nothing for my time. Just F off. The new one was so washed in cheese it was not edible. I was grossed out. Normally I love that sandwich but I won't go back. Will also file complaints on other sites. Very poor customer servic

Food is amazing prices are great literally every sandwich I've had from there is soo good I just want to order all of them I never can make up my mind since they are all so delicious!! Also potato salad is banging !!

Service is always welcoming whether you're going in or placing an order!! Nice place inside 2 tables 2 chairs flat screen Now the sandwiches are 10/10, always fat, and will have you rolling down the block after eating one

I was charged one dollar for a single Costco brand chocolate chip cookie. My sandwich was a greasy gross mess with one onion. I wouldn't call them clowns because a circus is more difficult than making a sandwich more like crooks pretending to be chefs. Fellas make the sandwich grab A onion one onion cut it then add it. How about you grab a couple of cookies for a full dollar you couldn't figure out to bake it's really not hard. Next time you see onions on the order just add the onions. It's okay if it's an extra 0.15 cents making a sandwich is very easy.

Visited on a Wednesday afternoon great chopped cheese and great service! I'll be back to try other sandwiches.

Every sandwich tastes great and I mean everything I ever ordered. Way better than Anthony's in same neighborhood. Ordering and pickup is quick and easy. Even their bacon egg and cheese somehow tasted better than any I ever had. Only advice I have is to add a daily special or weekly special for something different.

Okay here we are... We have a place with good food but horrible customer service. Got my food OPENED through Grubhub. As I personally know, it' is the restaurant's responsibility to assure the food is sanitary & CLOSED. It is as if you were to order a burger @ a drive through & they hand it to you with no wrapping basically. Would you want it ??? Kindly called them & explained how unsanitary and inedible it was, asked them to resend it. They did - EXACTLY as it was the time before. Completely OPENED! So, customer down. Bc people have no common sense or courtesy for others. And, GROSS!!!

It's so hard to find a good sandwich shop, but the sandwich shop checks off all the boxes I've been looking for. I tried the breakfast but will definitely be back for lunch. Their breakfast burrito is hands down one of the tastiest I ever had. I also got the waffles sandwich and it was delicious too. This place is really the best kept secret. Staff is friendly and service is fast, will definitely come back.

I used to love this place I tried to order from this place 3 times at 630 pm they closes at 7 pm and they told me they will not take the order that's fine will take my business else where

I ordered a sandwich and the hero was very launch it was filled with Brazil and sun-dried tomatoes it was very tasty I would order again from here and Recommended to eat here or take out will get delivered

Let me start by saying I'm a tough customer. I'm used to the old school Brooklyn shops that don't really exist anymore. This place is a 10 out of 10 not just the quality of the food which is amazing but the way they make you feel. "Nothing" is a problem, you want extra bacon, "no problem" you want a custom salad? No Problem. Add that with the freshness and quality of the food and you have a Home Run. Hands down best Bacon Egg and anything on Staten Island. $7 with a Water or coffee included. Rueben's, Philly Cheesesteak best ever. The owner a Michelin trained chef is the one you see when you place your order and he takes the time to make you wanna come back. I just wish they were open till 10 or 11pm but that part of the charm I guess. I just had the Corned Beef sandwich and Mac n Cheese on the side. I challenge you to find a better Mac N Cheese anywhere. I'll end by saying the prices are great for what you get. I really hope they will be around along time.

You are the Sandwich Shop. Every sandwich you make should be incredible. Facebook people rave about the food like it's life changing. Yelp reviews are all positive that service is great. Someone takes the order and someone cooks it. Cmon! Sorry to be that unhappy person but the Cheesesteak was disappointing. When i held the wrapped sandwich in my hand, I knew it was light. Good taste and all but not enough substance. Jody's on Forest Avenue beats this any day. G knows cheesesteaks as well. The Sandwich Shop should make the best sandwiches on Staten Island. Based off this experience it doesn't

Ordered for the first time today, fantastic! Sandwiches are huge split half's with the misses so we can try each others. I got the chopped cheese and she got fried cutlet with broccoli, rob and provolone. The Mac salad was excellent! The bread is amazing. Will be going back for more!

Love this place. It's a little out of the way but it's definitely a gem. So far, every sandwich I've ordered has been amazing. Love their cookies, that are made on premises. It's not very big, has a couple of tables & they always have the sports channel on. The place is very clean. They have tons of orders, especially during breakfast & lunch time. Sometimes it could take them up to 45 minutes to have your order ready. But I feel like it's worth the wait.

I've had different sandwiches here and have all been good. The crunchy chicken sandwich, Reuben, Cubano and tuna fish salad were all fresh and delicious! I recommend them for sure!

Ran in for a quick sandwich to go for lunch and ordered the tuna which came on a Portuguese roll. Great sized portion for the price. Lots of options for hot and cold sandwiches along with a range of drinks - soda, Snapple, Arizona, Joe's Iced Tea, Coffee, etc. and Hal's chips to pair with your sandwich as well. Ordering at the counter was very easy and quick. Clean shop. Good spot to stop in and grab a bite.

This place is great when you're hungry, don't want to cook, and don't wanna spend a ton of money. I've ordered a few different sandwhiches and they are all pretty good. My favorites are the cheesesteaks (beef and chicken), the Cuban, and the crabby fries with cheese sauce. Delivery is usually pretty fast. Friendly staff. Solid sandwich shop

The sandwiches are on the small side but they are delicious. I love their Reuben....the sandwich is buttered and grilled, the slaw is thick cut, fresh, and not sauerkraut, but good house made slaw! The Corned beef isn't on par with Katz's but it's tender, buttery and better than the stuff you get at typical diners. I also recommend the Boss Man. It reminds me of the pork sandwiches in Philadelphia, the sandwich capital of the world. The pork is juicy, the bread is good, the broccoli rabe is fresh and the long hot peppers give s a spicy kick. Great sandwich joint, the sandwiches are not as big as some of those Italian hero places in Bay Ridge Brooklyn, and just as pricey. But they are still very well made.

You'd think by the name it was just another sandwich place.....you'd be wrong, and stupid. Here it was, Christmas eve day and I get to be the sacrificial moron to go out and buy everything my wife forgot. It was a shoot me in the face with an aardvark moment. While I'm out being murdered by every jackass Staten Island has to offer I suddenly got hungry. Enter the guys at the Sandwich Shop. I did some review reading and made my order online. First off- the Reuben reviews are legit. Awesome sandwich. It had just the right amount of everything, and the bread was amazing. My mom (visiting from Florida) is super pissed at me right now. Took one bite of the sandwich and slapped the s**t out of her. Seriously, my sister felt it from Arizona. Second- you can't impress my wife. Its just not possible. She wanted the fish sandwich and when I asked her how it was I got "its really good. The onions are great.". To her that's basically jumping up and down like a little boy who just saw his first porn magazine. Every single one of the guys working in that shop talked to me like we went way back, they were happy to be there and made me feel like we were all old friends. Order here with confidence.

The best subs and sandwiches you'll ever have favs are chopped cheese sub and the cheesesteak is incredible.

Great sandwiches! I had the Ruben and my husband had the New York Chopped Cheese. They were huge and delicious! The place was super busy with carry out and some sort of delivery which they say is free. I will be back!

Really good sandwiches and friendly service. I got the fried chicken sandwich and added bacon to it. It was very crispy and the lemon aioli was very flavorful.

Without exception the best sandwich on the Island, if not ever. I've been everywhere man and this joint just prepares food how it should be. What really seals deal for me the personal customer service, the gentleman at the counter is perhaps the epitome of what customer service should be. Knows my name, what I like, etc... Good stuff!

Good products and well made food. I had high expectations for this place being that a friend of a friend owns it and let me say this, it did satisfy my expectations. Everything I ordered was made exactly how I asked meaning crispy bacon and provolone. Poutine was delicious and the mac&cheese was top notch. You can literally be satisfied off the portion on the side items. I also enjoyed that they have a exotic pop fridge. Meaning their hip to what's going on.

Super good stuff. Got the fat sandwich, very tasty well balanced flavors. It's tough to put fries on a sandwich but they nailed it! Poutine was good, could have been more evenly salted or used some gravy imo. All in all delicious food, fair pricing, awesome staff. Thanks guys, we'll be back. - Billy + Kate

The sandwiches from the Sandwich Shop are Delicious! Big portions, good quality meat, and great prices! Totally worth trying! The grub of the grubs!!!

Food is amazing! Sandwiches and salads. Best Cobb salad I have had in awhile. Their homemade ranch dressing is the best!

Best sandwiches ever !!! Everything is fresh & delicious . Always quick & easy to order . I've recommended this place to everyone

Wonderful addition to the neighborhood! Great unique selection of sandwiches. I've tried a few and they have all been delicious. Service is also friendly and I've never had an issue with an order.

I was trying to find a new spot and this place came on my feed so decided to check it out. After ordering online, I didn't receive a confirmation or any details in regard to my order. I called and the girl was a bit of condescending when I asked for details. I wasn't expecting my order then and there, just an ETA or some verification that my order was confirmed. The food came after an hour wait, it was a 1/5, would not eat there again. Oh, I got my email confirmation for my order, 4 days later.

Gotta get the French dip roast beef sandwich...it is delicious! Gotta have the au jour w/ it.

Fabulous Reuben, chicken & broccoli rabe, & house cut fries. Staff is excellent and accommodating. Small parking lot, but street parking across the street is plentiful . Will definitely be going back. This is strictly take out ( even if the asshole in city hall opened up indoor dining).

This is a nice addition to Great Kills. They offer traditional sandwiches with a twist. We love their breakfast menu and tend to order the hot sandwiches mainly for lunch or dinner when we do takeout. The Fat sandwich, well is exactly that and one of the favorites on this house. Their onion rings are amazing but I wish I was eating those hot straight out but with current covid restrictions, I'd suggest you heat them up a little more. The staff is very friendly. They are busy so calling ahead is sometimes difficult.

I order from here at least once a week! Everything is always perfect, the selection is vast, and the delivery is super quick. Also, extremely nice people to deal with.

Was looking for a sandwich shop in the area around 9 in the morning and stumbled upon this gem. It may not look like much from the outside but boy do they have amazing sandwiches. Their breakfast burrito is an 11/10, packed with flavor and I couldn't get enough of it. Will definitely be going back to try out their crabby fries and poutine

Absolutely delicious!! We had the Reuben and an order of Poutine. Best poutine I ever had. Fries were perfect and the beef in the brown gravy was so tender and unexpected. The sandwich itself was just delicious and plenty of filling. So happy to have been here today for the first time and look forward to trying many more of their sandwiches!

I ordered the Fried eggplant sandwich and I also order 50/50 onion rings and French fries. The sandwich was amazing, onion rings/fries were very oily.

Good food but they make me spend twenty five dollars to get a delivery 1.1 miles away kinda ridiculous if u ask me!!! Especially when i try ordering all the time

What a disappointment! From the disinterested girl at the counter, who could barely be bothered to look up from her phone, to the $14.00 barely filled, one slice of mozzarella sandwich, I don't get the hype. From all the reviews I was so looking forward to a "gourmet" overstuffed hero. It was really just a typical deli sandwich. Will not return.

Their sandwich's are delicious even the breakfast sandwich's. My niece loves their Mac and cheese and I especially like their crabby fries.

Ordered today for lunch. Arrived right on time, with food still hot. I ordered the chopped cheese, which was delicious and perfectly pressed. Other coworkers got a chicken sandwich, salads, tuna sandwich, fat sandwich, and Philly cheesesteak, all of which were good. They accidentally brought a cappuccino milkshake and let us keep it, which my friend said tasted perfect. Crabby fries were delicious, my one complaint was the cheese sauce wasn't even a full cup. I'll just have to ask for more next time!

Great fries and onion rings. Good sandwiches. The caprese sandwich had too many peppers but it was good when I removed some.

Omg what a Sandwich chip chesse like I was back in Bklyn Great Job only thing I would add is Mushrooms

First time trying this spot because I've heard good things from family and friends in the area and I wasn't disappointed. My fiancée and I ordered the chicken cheese steak hoagies and they were fantastic!! Big sandwiches loaded with all the ingredients listed and each bite was better than the last. Ordered take out and was ready within 10 minutes on a Saturday afternoon Definitely will be back to try the rest of the menu soon!

One word- AMAZING. The sandwiches are the most fresh, flavorful, and delicious. Not to mention the sides- $4 for Mac n cheese that's out of this world. Would order from here every day if I could!

This place truly has the best "gourmet" sandwiches. Only place that stands apart from the others...they actually have what I consider a real cheese steak. Try it on rye. It's amazing. All good eats there!