The Secret Stash

First, the place is managed and staffed perfectly. Well done by management. Second, the kitchen is amazing and put out perfect food. (Give them a tip! Plus you get a bell rung when you do.) Third, the waitress we had was amazing and so efficient. Fourth, last, and most important, one of the best pizzas! We are coming back just to get the pizza again. Did a BYO with pepperoni, mushroom, onion, and jalapeño and it was perfect! Just amazing! Wings were spot on and salad good too. And drinks were awesome with full bar.

Worth the drive in my opinion! The food was good! I LOVED how crispy & moist the wings were & NO BREADING!!! BEST wings I've had in a long time. The pizza was super thin in the middle not good enough to support the toppings. But it was still a good pizza. Our server was on top of everything! Awesome service, food & environment very up beat!

Jenny was an excellent server. I think she might be able to recite details of the menu in her sleep. She was that thorough and delightful as well. I’m not a fan of pizza but she convinced me to try theirs by describing the crust. It was excellent. I had the pesto one with chicken. I was there with a couple friends from California. They enjoyed their pizzas equally as well as did I.

Secret Stash pizza was awesome! We had a great waiter (pink), who was super helpful, friendly, informative, and upbeat. The wings were amazing (dip them in the sauce!!), and the Texas pizza was epic. Great dinner. (It gets busy, so be ready to wait, or try and call ahead).

Excellent pizza. Be sure to try the Amber beer. The decorations in here are very interesting and eclectic. If you’re in the area, I highly recommend stopping by for at least one meal. If you’re not hungry, at least stop and try one of their beers. They have several locally made beers.

Wonderful atmosphere & amazing food. We were not going to stop, but a local told us it was the best pizza, so we had to try it. We split a salad & a pizza & it was enough for the 2 of us. The Burrata salad was so light & yummy. The Melty Mancuso pizza with added prosciutto was not your normal pizza. Their crust was nice & thin, and the topping were delicious!

Today, we stopped and had lunch. It was a great atmosphere, and the side patio was awesome. Our server fit right into the vibe. She was great and very friendly. All that said, the Food was the was the star of the show. We got the garlic bread and the " Bouty Call" Pizza. It was amazing and lived up to its description. I will definitely stop again and have no doubt it will be note worthy again. Thank you for the experience.

Not so secret pizza place thats a must visit when in town for the Grand Traverse or any other event or reason to visit! Amazing vibe, service and food! So many options - we did the fig and a thai style pizza. Regardless of your pizza choice start with the crack fries - you wont regret it!

The place was packed, and now I know why. amazing pizza and great service. loved the gluten free crust.

We passed by the 'Stash every time we've been to the 'Butte, but this time we decided to stop in, and I'm glad we did! Seeking an eclectic ambiance with treasures from around the world? Check! Want laid-back and companionable service? Got that too! Looking for crust that's off the hook and loaded with whatever you're craving? Then have a seat at the SecretStash! We were there on a weekday and there was no line, so my wife & I were seated immediately. It's a BIG place, so even if there's a line, a good chance you'll be seated quickly. It took us a while to decide, but we ordered individual pizzas, a Texas Biggie for me and a Notorious Fig + Arugal for my wife. We had an appetizer too, but I've forgotten what it was; the 2 pies took a while to make, so the app and beers kept us occupied while we admired the decor. The Biggie did not disappoint; I was in hog heaven, as they say. My wife thought that the fig was okay, and personally, the added arugula didn't help. Still, the crust of both pies was perfectly irregular and crisp, just as it should be. I'm salivating as I think about stopping by next season!

We were there over the weekend 25-27th of July 2025. They were extremely busy the 25th, for dinner, seated us at a table with other people we didn't know. It was a little awkward but we made the best of it. We ordered several appetizers, and a few drinks that came at a decent time when the waitress remembered what she was doing. ( maybe a little to much Colorado grass). We ordered pizza right away when we sat down because she said it was taking longer. Boy she wasn't kidding we waited over an hour for 1- pizza which was good when it showed up( not worth the wait). Luckily we weren't in a hurry and had a good time. We went back for lunch on Sunday when they first opened and sat out side again. Had a much better waitress who was awesome!!! We ordered the crack fries and a couple of pizza's which came out really fast. The fries were delicious and the pizzas too!! It's worth stopping in if you're in the area, I would try to stay away from there when things are really busy unless you have time for a 2- hour dinner!!

While driving down the main street in Crested Butte, The Secret Stash Pizzeria looked like the happening place to be! If there is ever a time to overload on some carbs it's in Crested Butte. Tons of outdoor activities that burn lots of calories! Everyone is hiking, biking, or skiing here. We sat outside and brought our dog with us. They had water bowls under the tables for the dogs. We also had our kids with us, and they do have a kid's menu too, plenty of highchairs. We got the Texas biggin pizza and garlic bread. We all really liked this pizza! The crust that they make is very good. The garlic bread was classic exactly what you expect! I love that they have menu that shows what all their specialty pizzas look like. I also really liked about this place is the very unique decor for a pizza place, very worldly, it added to the character of the place. They've got plenty of seating both inside and outside. A great place for everyone!

They were packed and yet the servers were so attentive! We got a couple pizzas to share along with some wings and garlic bread and everything was 10/10 - including service! The spicy weis and the artichoke Parmesan pizza was so so good - I did not think this place to be in my top 5 pizzas restaurants in Colorado! Highly recommend you try the pizza out here if you're in crested butte! Oh they have a very pet friendly outdoor seating section - something for my next visit here with my pup!

Excellent service, and the BEST pizza I have had outside of NY/CT. I consider myself something of a pizza snob because of growing up in CT, and I'm often homesick for it living in Colorado. My friends that were visiting from out of state proclaimed "they can never have pizza again because it will never be as good as Secret Stash". Loved the vibes of the decor and was pleasantly surprised there was no wait during peak lunch on a Saturday during a holiday weekend. We were so happy with the pizza, we forgot to take a pic of the whole pie.

What a great atmosphere from the minute we walked in service was awesome and pizza was DELICIOUS! Not a huge beer list but decent and the red ale hit the spot. Definitely recommend!!

Wow! What good food! What good vibes! We got two pizzas and pickle spears and that was more than enough for four people. The hand made pizzas were amazing and really one of a kind. The pickles were good too! We got there at 4 ish and it was a good time just before it got busy, the pizza cane out about 30 minutes after ordering and we were warned of a bit of a wait by our waitress. The price was a little high but you're paying for the experience of the restaurant and also the amazing food. The vibes were great! Look at the pictures for reference.

Woman-owned, operated by some of the most experienced in the biz and it shows - hands-down the best pizza I've had all year, will put the icing on your cake when visiting Crested Butte so get up & go get you some! The Notorious FIG is award-winning and may bring more notoriety to the restaurant: tangy bleu and Asiago contrast with sweet Mission figs quartered for texture, while prosciutto and truffle add savory, earthy, hearty notes atop crisped and chewy crust. It's a pizza party in my mouth! Perfection with a crisp Coca-Cola. Returned for lunch and tried the Rupee - crisp market greens with a rainbow of shredded carrots, cucumber, cherry tomato, cranberries, and seasoned pepitas. The housemade vinaigrette is balanced between warmth and cutting acidity - fresh bites! Driz & Ema were very cool spending time & taking great care with service - a rare but deeply appreciated quality in a tourist town.

We came here for lunch and the service was great, friendly and helpful staff. Food was relatively quick to come considering how busy it was. The store is cool and lots of decorations to look at and merch to buy. I thought the Texas biggin pizza was average but the gluten free hamptons pizza is to die for. Get it!!

Great Pizza spot for out of town folks. The food was good. We ordered chicken wings and Asher's pizza. It was great!! I will come back next time in town.

We enjoyed the Stash Wings (menu states they've been #1 in the area since 2002 and I can believe it), and the Spicy Wais 16" pizza. Both were delish! The service was great and the joint def has funky vibes. It's filled with items the owner has collected from India and Thailand. They even have a rickshaw custom made for them. We went when they opened at 11:30am (Yelp lists opening time as 11am so beware), so it wasn't busy yet.

Secret Stash is where it's at! Came here on a Friday night with my husband at prime dinner time and despite it being busy, were seated right away. Lively spot with a really unique and fun ambiance; so many things to look at - that weren't a television! Truly an A+ with vibe. Decent drink menu with many cocktails and a good selection of beers with some wines to choose from. I would have liked to see more NA options beyond slushies; a warm concocted booze-free beverage would have been much appreciated. We started with the fried pickle spears which were the best fried pickles I've ever had. Perfectly crispy with great flavor. Would highly recommend. For pizza, we had a large Spicy Wais. I can't say it was our favorite pizza - too garlicky for my husband and I was not a fan on the whole cherry tomatoes (hello hot liquid bombs) but it was baked well and the crust is as top notch. Would like to try a different combo next time as a redemption. On the whole, a great neighborhood pizzeria that if I lived in the area, would be a go-to.

If you're in Crested Butte, do not sleep on this place! Our fave during our time here. Amazing service, cool vibes, and phenomenal food! And they are open all season long! Our favorite was the pinhead pesto with chicken! Loved their cheesy garlic bread and their crack fries!

Tasty pizza. Nice crust. Plenty of fresh toppings. Busy place. Fresh toppings. Fun atmosphere.

We had a great time here! We came here on a Saturday evening after skiing. We took the bus into town so we didn't have to worry about parking but very close to the bus stop. We were able to put our name in around 6pm for 9 people and it was about an hour wait. Once our table was ready we were led downstairs to a very fun large couch table. It was a nice place to hang out and talk with everyone. The atmosphere was very fun. We ordered many pizzas for the group and ordered the fries. The waiter had lots of good recommendations. I loved the crack fries. The sauce that came with them was great. I am definitely glad we got them. We ordered the notorious FIG, where's the beef, and the hamptons. I loved all the different specialty pizzas and they were all delicious. Overall splitting it was a great deal and we had pizza to take home. Would definitely come back!

A must if you're visiting Crested Butte. We dined here twice for dinner because the food was so good. Our servers were lovely both times and very accommodating to my specific diet. 10/10 no notes the vibes are great.

Arrived on a Tuesday evening and the place was busy. It appears to be a popular place. They have indoor and outdoor seating; however, we opted for bar seating since it was immediate. Note: it does get very busy. It has a pub like feel with vintage elegance, casual bar seating and eclectic details for a great casual night out. We ordered The Hamptons: arugula, Parmesan shavings and prosciutto. The lemon pepper on crust made it salty; however, overall, it was great. All of the other pizzas looked delicious as well. A def revisit in the future to try the other pizzas!

Insane wait times for takeou. The pizza is really good. I've ordered takeout twice on two different trips to CB. Both times the takeout wait is insane. Their ordering system told me 30 min. I arrived in 30 minutes and waited an additional 45-50 minutes. I'm sure it's not easy to deal with the onrush of visitors especially during the flower festival, but an hour and a quarter for 2 pizzas around 2:30pm? I'll probably steer clear next time I'm in town. It's a shame because the pizza is very good.

Great friendly atmosphere and amazing pizzas. This is a must for anyone coming to Crested Butte. I recommend sitting on the couches below deck. But the bar can be fun too and the bartenders are very welcoming. We had the prosciutto and arugula pizza which you my surprise came with a center lemon. I lived in Italy for 4 years, and never got this pizza either a lemon but do sprinkle some juice on top and it really workes. The Pesto one is great too. Overall a great experience.

What can I say that hasn't already been said. This place and legendary and lives up to the hype. If you're in CB it would be a crime to not stop by.

Fantastic mountain pies. Great service and lots of menu options. Nothing better than grabbing a pitcher and pie under the umbrellas out front.

Came here on recommendation that it would be a cool place to take the kids and have some great pizza. The pizza was not great, it seemed more like assembly-line-dominos-style-Sysco crap, incredibly overpriced. But hey, pizza is pizza I guess. The service was nonexistent, and although my kids are well behaved, the staff seemed to regard them as a nuisance for just existing. The seemingly senior staff were apathetic and/or intently focused on another patron who was apparently much more important than my little self. The ambience screams... well something. Early Moroccan bordello? I would recommend to order delivery from here instead, if you're in need of pizza in Crested Butte.

Was surprised how much I liked this pizza. Got the mozzarella sticks too naturally and the slushes were like candy. Would go again if I was in crested butte

Reviews sold it, but then we went in and the sheer number of people eating there told the rest of the story. They are easily feeding more people for dinner (at least this Sunday night we went) than any other restaurant in Crested Butte. It has two levels and we sat downstairs on one of their couches. It was super cool. The place was eclectic and had a total Colorado vibe. Our waiter wore a kilt and was the nicest person. We ordered the Thai speciality with tofu and a regular with pineapple and bacon. Both were excellent. I'd say the Thai needed some fresh cilantro on top or some sriracha or something but otherwise was delicious. They have so many pizzas to try; it was hard to pick one. Fun environment and there was an accident on our pizza (toppings were combined when we wanted the separated and they not only made us a new one, but let us keep the messed up one. Hardly a mess up when you get BOGO. Accidental BOGO, but so nice of them to let us keep it, especially because it was so specific to our interests. Would definitely return and try more of those specialty pizzas.

Came in on a Monday with ton of open seating and room at the bar. Bartenders were super friendly, they had the game on TVs, and just fun vibes. Pizza was really good, the Spicy Wais really was SPICY. I particularly love a good thick crust. I was able to finish most of it and took home the leftovers. At $25 for a 12 inch, it's on the pricier side for sure so it feels more like it's a special pizza night out rather than carryout for a crowd.

DEEEEEELICIOUS! One of the best pizza crusts ever. We had the Meatball Pie and the sauce is so good and the roasted garlic put it over the top! Ellie, our server, was so personable and made our experience so good.

Fantastic pizza place! We ordered a pizza we customized ourselves and also got a 12 inch Hamptons. The Hamptons crust is to die for. Lemon pepper crust?! Why can't all pizzas have this?! For our custom pizza we did regular pizza sauce and it was so flavorful- I love a good fast food generic pizza place, but Secret Stash has them all beat by a mile!

Delicious fresh pizza in a fun, funky atmosphere! Amazing crust, fresh flavorful toppings. Secret stash was a big family favorite--we ate there twice in a 4 day visit (once dine-in, once carry-out). The pizzas are SO GOOD. Ive had a million caprese / margherita pizzas, but this one takes the win. It has an amazing crust, delicious pickled onions, and the perfect sweet-acidic balsamic vinegar. The sort of disco-mystic-Hindi vibe of the restaurant is fun. It's like it was inspired by India and decorated by a drag queen, in the best possible way. Maximalist pizza parlor. Extra points for the suspended rickshaw. It does get busy at night, but our experience eating there for lunch was great. It surprisingly wasn't crowded at all. You can order online as well.

Love this spot. I'm a fan of the fig but my fiance loves the meat one. A quick and easy meal after a day of exploring

I used to love this place, but the last 3 times I have come into to sit at the bar, I have felt invisible. The young girls are more busy flirting with the guys or putting glasses away than to wait on a single customer. Tonight I decided to leave after waiting for 10 minutes to be seen and went across the street to Ryce, where a vibrant bar and super attentive bartender "Wen" not only seemed happy to see me, but instantly connected and noticed everything and everyone at his bar. I'm assuming Secret Stash is too popular to really care about service anymore. Who needs greasy fattening pizza anyhow.

The pizza was delicious, the atmosphere was great!! Our waiter was also very attentive! I highly recommend eating here!!

We were on a 3 generational trip to crested butte. The food (wings, salads and fig pizza) was all 5 star. Service was exceptional with Jules as our server. She was able to anticipate all of our 4 and 6 yr olds needs. Ambiance was perfect, outside on the patio.

We loved it here! Everyone was so friendly, service was great, and food was SO good! We will definitely be back...maybe even for a second time this trip

We went in due to the reviews. We stood at the hostess station operated by a bunch of teenagers that completely ignored us for 15 minutes while they socialized. We finally walked over to the manager and asked to place our order to go. Food was alright nothing note worthy. Service was horrible. Food was overpriced. Gobs of teenage workers there for social time, not really interested in working.

It's pricey but SO worth it! This is a must every winter and summer we are in CB. The atmosphere is great, staff are really fun and if you like drinks, the margs are amazing.

We came back 1 year later and the burrata salad and pizza were just as delicious as before! We did a BYO pizza this time with red sauce, sausage mushroom and spinach. So good!

I ordered from Secret Stash Pizzeria and was pleasantly surprised by the unique offerings they had. I tried their fried ravioli. The crispy exterior gave way to a flavorful and creamy filling. I also couldn't resist trying their signature drink, the Butterfly Effect, which featured butterfly pea tea and a beautiful purple hue. I snagged a cool T-shirt from them for just five bucks. It was a steal considering the quality and design.

One of the three best pizzas I have ever had, the Notorious F.I.G. Managed a pizza place 30 years ago and have always been a hard reviewer on pizza joints. Give this my highest recommendation.

Secret Stash is a good place to go if you're in Crested Butte. Beware - it is very popular so the line can get long. The food was tasty but the pizzas take about 1 hour to make so don't come starving. A lot of fun drink options and good apps to pass the time while you wait for your 'za. The servers were friendly but not fantastic. The inside has a great aesthetic and there are some outdoor tables as well.

I hate that I waited so long to review. I apologize for the lack of deets, but ultimately, it was f'n fantastic. Great service & quality Pizza! We usually go for a red sauce where pizza is involved, but we found the notorious fg intriguing. Boy was it memorable!

We ordered the spicy wais pizza and it was absolutely amazing. We did order it with vegan pepperoni and they do have a wide variety of vegan options. Our server and the service was amazing. The bar has a very cool and hip vibe!

Amazing ambience and food, and positive transparent business practices for living wages. We come here every year.

Incredible pizza! In my opinion, the crust was the best part. They have a lot of variety and great salad and app offerings as well. The margaritas were also very tasty and refreshing!

Excellent customer service; all waitstaff were super attentive, engaged, and seemed to really love their jobs! Our waiter Ben C was great! Amazing pizza options, including vegan and gluten-free options. Tons of topping choices Pizza came out to the table in a timely fashion, and it was delicious! Could do without the spontaneous bell ringing - quite jarring when not expecting it. Other than that, it was a very enjoyable experience during our visit.

The pizza was AMAZING! Where's the Beef was top tier for me. Such great flavor. Also enjoyed You're Driving Me Caprese and the Spicy Wais. The decor was super cool and fun, great atmosphere!

Great service and excellent tasting food. Wide variety of options in this quiet little ski town. The decorations were Hindu which makes me believe the owners loved the Indian culture. I loved their crack wings with their crack sauce and our waitress brought us more without us even asking. To the left of where we were sitting were $1000 tip banners that the owners matched if anyone was feeling super generous! They also had a gift shop which we got a shirt and sticker from since you got a discount on the shirt if you purchased a pizza.

Stash is a real gem - incredible pizza, great service, and a warm, cozy atmosphere. The pizza is the star here though the staff makes every meal special. On our most recent visit, we arrived 20 minutes before closing but the manager came over and told us to relax and enjoy ourselves. No visit to Crested is complete without dining at Stash! We highly recommend this local landmark!

Fun atmosphere and great food and spot-on service. We ordered the Mac Daddy and the caprese pizza (forgot the name) and burrata salad. Each was terrific. Would highly recommend.