Rich S.
Yelp
We arrived around 7pm on a Friday, and found a space right in front. There's plenty more parking in the large well-lit lot 120-feet up Oella Av. The restaurant was pretty busy, and the bar was nearly full, but we were able to walk to one of a good number of available 2-seat and 4-seat tables. A number of people wound down dinner through 8pm, so more tables and front-door-parking kept opening up.
It's a casual retro interior with dark wood and exposed brick, true to the building's 1833 origin. It's darkly lit and welcoming in a homey way. Nice people, many from nearby towns. The lunch-dinner menu is casual, from sandwiches to a variety of mains. It's average-priced, not expensive, and the servings are very generous. We had a hot Chicken Riggie linguini with artichokes, and a cold over-stuffed shrimp-salad sandwich on a hoagie roll with fries. They were both fresh and flavorful. The fries, since you asked, were piping hot, lightly crisp, and perfectly soft inside. We were served without a long wait, and the floor staff was constantly attentive.
Throughout dinner, the crowd was mostly middle-age and older. The bar side nearest the door seemed like mostly regulars. But surprise, they have restarted their Friday 9pm karaoke, and by then a younger crowd really filled the place along with the regulars. This was "Christmas in July", with some fun decorating and several themed songs, some by decades-long regulars! You have to see nattily-dressed Mike, well-known for his spins and kicks! And you havent lived until you've heard Tim's bawdy version of The Night Before Christmas :-). Singers ranged from could-be-pros to I-just-love-to-sing. The best part was that the great crowd joined in boisterously with the singing, and applauded every performance. It's probably the most fun karaoke I've been to! We faded out around 11pm, and it was still going strong.
It's a great casual restaurant, and a really fun Friday evening out!