Elaine W.
Yelp
My husband and I stayed here for the first leg of our honeymoon. To be fair, I can't say much about value because he used his points (even the Internet was included due to a promotion), but the experience was fantastic for mainly 3 reasons: (1) location, (2) casual luxury; and (3) the hotel gym (it was that good).
The location was ideal - beautiful and relatively central. I found it easy to get to everything I planned to see on melbourne. The area is metropolitan and busy, which I liked, but if you're looking for something out of the way, this isn't it.
The hotel is somewhat luxurious (beautiful view, comfortable bedding, numerous amenities), but relaxed enough to avoid the stuffy, restricted feel that is often associated with hotel luxury.
Speaking of hotel amenities, the hotel gym is be best I've ever seen. Short of having a staff and classes, it couldn't be any better. The equipment is relatively new (no dinosaurs here) and everything is kept clean. All the basics are there and more (ellipticals, bikes, treadmills, rowing machine, free weights, machine weights, exercise balls, medicine balls, bosu balls ...). There's also a pool, a steam room and a sauna. Weston takes fitness very seriously.
It's also worth noting that the staff (concierge, front desk people, housekeeper) were fantastic and exceptionally friendly.