Three Bites Bakery

Three Bites Bakery was an easy choice for our wedding cake. Years ago we had a valentine's pastry box delivered to our apartment and were hooked. It was so incredible to get to make new memories with their sweet treats on our big day. We had a two-tier vintage style grapefruit and ginger cake and multiple sheet cakes for our guests. Their day-of delivery and set up was seamless. We had so many comments from the guests about how delicious it was. We are so looking forward to enjoying our frozen top tier next year to celebrate our anniversary. Thank you Three Bites team!

My husband and I tried wedding cake samples from a few different bakeries in Columbus and Three Bites Bakery was by far our favorite! All of the flavors we tried were delicious but our favorites were lemon and pistachio honey for summer. We decided to do a three tiered lemon cake and a couple sheet cakes of the pistachio honey for our wedding count of 180 guests. It was perfect. The cake was beautiful with flowers provided by our florist and it tasted so good! The delivery was seamless and we couldn’t have asked for a better wedding cake! The communication was also great. 10/10 recommend.

Three Bites Bakery is the BOMB. We’re loyal customers and have been frequenting since they opened in their prior location. We love supporting a small, local woman-owned business. And the pastries are the best in Columbus! I always have to get a bombolone everytime I go. But we love the rotating features alongside their core staples. And I’ve ordered a birthday cake from them as well and it was also amazing (they do need advance notice on custom cakes, so plan ahead, but sometimes they have some available in-store or can make a simple cake faster). I also work in the wedding industry and have had many happy clients order their wedding cakes and desserts for their receptions. And now that they’re in their newest location on Broad St, there’s excellent coffee and bubble tea available from Little Cat Boba. So happy this bakery exists, we are so lucky to have them here in Columbus!

The ube-coconut concoction was great! It went well with our Filipino-themed wedding in Ohio. I can’t find this anywhere else in the Midwest if I’m exaggerating. They are responsive via email and I was able to sort it out even last minute. Our guests devoured them so we can’t really continue with the wedding tradition of eating your leftover cake every anniversary. My only constructive criticism is that they didn’t have the right box for a two-tier cake. The top part didn’t have a cover and the only support is the base. My sister had to hug the cake, pray and annoyingly remind the driver to not press the brakes too hard for the whole 40 mins. car ride. I am unsure as to why this is not provided since I’ve seen a couple of two-tier cakes in this google review. Did everybody just hug their cake and pray it makes it to the wedding?

Such a charming place! We walked by, peeked in the windows, and were compelled to go in and enjoy some baked goods and a hot drink. Immediately, we sensed the vibe of the two different owners and settled in on some quite different and interesting flavors. We ate in the little Cafe area and enjoyed our fare and an interesting chat with the owner. Perfect! We will be back.

This is my second experience with pastries here. The biko is the sweetest biko I have ever tried, and there are pieces of hard glutinous rice throughout. With the biko itself being overly sweet, the sweetened coconut on top did not help. The cake slice I got was dry and couldn’t distinguish a clear flavor profile. Both desserts were tasted at room temperature so not sure what happened with the texture.

I visited Three Bites Bakery and treated myself to a flat white paired with a Nutella-filled cornetto. The pastry had a unique tanginess that surprisingly complemented the rich Nutella inside, while the coffee hit the mark perfectly. The service was impeccable, and the overall atmosphere is both cute and cozy. I’ll definitely be coming back!

We’ve been going to Isa for a while, so when we started planning our wedding, she was honestly our first and only choice. Yes, her pastries are out of this world and I could wax poetic on them - specifically the sweet potato one, look if you know you know - but this review is for the absolute masterpiece of a wedding cake that she put together for us. Because we’re long standing customers, we actually ended up doing both the spring/summer and the fall/winter tasting boxes. There is no wrong answer here, every single cake she makes is delicious, but we ended up going with the pretty traditional almond raspberry with the raspberry jam. It’s sweet, it’s decadent, and it was a huge hit with our guests. And god, just look at it! So beautiful! 100% worth it, choose Isa and Three Bites for all your pastry and cake needs!