James A.
Yelp
Just a great place to have really good drink and bar food on Madison's Capitol Square, on a balmy Friday night.
We needed to find a place to eat and drink for the four of us and a dog, on our visit to Madison. There are quite a few restaurants with open air dining on the Square, so I suggested a place that none of us had gone before. When we got to the Tipsy Cow around 7, it was fairly busy but there were many open tables in the sidewalk dining area, so was confident that the wait wouldn't be too long. We were quoted 30 minutes for a table of 4 outside, and ended up only waiting 15. The restaurant uses an automated waitlist so can use the link sent to your phone to see where you are in line. The tables outside are spaced far enough apart to allow dogs to comfortably sit their owners.
We were brought menus and waters, and given time to peruse the two page menu. Most places in Madison have Spotted Cow Ale on tap, so we ordered two pints ($5 each which is a great price) and Loon Juice Hard Cider ($6). I haven't had any Spotted Cow for eight years, so that first big sip made me very, very happy and set the tone for the rest of the dinner.
The cheese curd appetizer ($10) was a must when first eating in Wisconsin, and didn't surprise. It came with two dipping sauces and had been made with fresh curds so was the right amount of chewy and stringey, with a good light batter. It's quite a bit better than what you can get at Culver's which is what people outside of Wisconsin are used to. We also got an asparagus app ($8), which came with 7 big pieces of asparagus that have been grilled over and drizzled with some light mayo dressing and black and white sesame seeds. My wife really liked it. My wife and future SiL ordered the Friday fish fry with Walleye ($16 each), which came with French fries, cole slaw, rye bread and two types of sauce. Both came with a very big piece of expertly battered, deep fried fish. It just puts other fish and chips meals outside of Wisconsin to shame. The fries were not great (probably the only thing not good in our meal), limp and greasy. But the cole slaw was fresh and zingey. My daughter got the 1X1 cheeseburger, using Knoche's beef ($10) and 3 year old cheddar with topped grilled onions. The bun was very soft (squishy), and she said she really enjoyed it. Knoche's was a local butcher shop that closed during the pandemic, but still provides very high quality meat to consumers and businesses. I also noticed that they use Nueske's smoked bacon, which my wife and I think is the best bacon out there. I got two shareable dishes: bowl of tipsy chili ($8) - excellent...I could eat two bowls of this with some bread and call it a very satisfying meal. Memphis Tots ($8) - never had this before, but it was a very popular dish with the table. It was great as -is (with a generous amount of the memphis dry rub seasoning), but also great dipped in the chili. It was very crispy, maybe even overly deep-fried, but it was great for us.
The total for the 4 of us was $96, before tip. We laughed since this meal would have cost at least $200 in California and wouldn't have been as good (don't order walleye anywhere outside of the Midwest). We got to enjoy summer eating outside in Madison. And because it was the right amount, we still had space to get the best ice cream at the nearby Memorial Union.