Mylon P.
Yelp
Order: Tamarind juice, Palatino Arepa, Peanut Putter and Jealous (pork, peanut butter and jelly)
Price: $23
Positives: The flavor of the food was fantastic, the staff was super friendly, the price really wasn't very high for what you were getting.
Negatives: They run out of stuff early (rum cake french toast, boooooo), they are very busy and wait times could get crazy
tldr: Toast was one of our favorite restaurants on the island. While it's one of the busier places we went it's well worth your time to figure out a way to get in. You won't regret it. Also get the rum cake french toast
Toast had been high on our list of places to visit before we ever arrived in Saint Croix. It got fantastic reviews, it had pictures of delicious looking food, and it served rum cake french toast. Who doesn't want to eat at a place that serves rum cake french toast?!?! Unfortunately during our first visit they had already run out of it. So our first lesson was to get there early, which we did the second time we went back. And spoilers, the rum cake french toast is freaking amazing.
Toast is this small restaurant tucked away off one of the main streets in Christiansted. Despite being a little off the path it was packed every single time we went. And if you've never been before, the crowded interior and potential line out the door, may turn you away from eating there. DON'T LEAVE, it is absolutely worth the wait, and it probably won't be as long as you think. Toast was definitely one of the top three places we ate while we were in St. Croix.
While Toast is predominantly a breakfast spot that's not the only thing they do. While they have a lot of amazing breakfast items they also had a wide selection of arepas and sandwiches. In our case we got a sandwich with pulled pork, peanut butter, and jelly....and damn, it was phenomenal. Toast seems to put its "spin" on a lot of its dishes too. Things that are fairly simply with one little change that makes it pop. The quality of their ingredients stands out too. Everything we had (both times we went) were on point! Every time we walked out the door we were talking about how good it was.
Toast does run out of things, just like everyone on the island, and they are super busy but it is absolutely worth your time to make at least one trip here while you're in St. Croix. You will get an absolutely delicious meal at a reasonable price and you will most certainly discuss coming back if you have time. Oh and if they haven't sold out you owe it to yourself to at least try the rum cake french toast.