Tony's Pizzeria

Absolutely amazing pizza! The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The toppings were fresh and generous, and the sauce had great flavor without being too heavy. The staff was friendly and the service was quick. Definitely my new go-to pizza spot!

Amazing pizza and excellent service at Tony's Pizzeria! The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the cheese was just the right amount of gooey. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure we had everything we needed. The cozy atmosphere made it a great place to enjoy a casual meal with friends and family. Definitely one of the best pizza spots around—I’ll be coming back soon! Highly recommend to anyone craving authentic, delicious pizza.

Tony’s is your classic New Yorker pizzeria. It’s the best local spot for slices and pies. And you have to try their chicken rolls, so damn good. As a lifelong Greenpoint resident, I gotta say this is what pizza is supposed to taste like!

I highly recommend this place. Very good fresh and well-prepared pizzas. They serve you well with a lot of care. The atmosphere is nice.

Tony’s upped their game. Just ordered a regular pie and it’s 5x better than it used to be. Perfect flop, good ratios. Crust was spectacular! This used to be my go to spot, now it will be again.

Delicious neighborhood pizzeria with trendy toppings and friendly service. Definitely coming back!

What a fantastic local Italian spot! Sunday special is on-point - large cheese tasted great, wings were hot and tangy, and garlic knots nice and soft. Staff is all extremely friendly and efficient. They have some pretty creative slices and appz as well. Though they deliver, I would recommend stopping by and supporting your local business!

love me an old school ny pizzeria <333 i frequent on my lunch break and its a great consistent place, when i want to treat myself i get their chocolate cake. personally love the old counters, theres plenty of seating, and employees are nice!

[ENG] This review and my experience is only something you can experiment in person and when I say that I think the owner was so nice. he heated my slices for me as I'd order from TooGoodToGo app on iOS. His staff was not very knowledgeable of the app but he was and this is why I said Owner. But he was nice and even box my slice as hot slice. I'll will like for anyone of of you to please try Tony's here I'm from Vancouver B.C and it was delicious and I want to say thank you to the staff and Owner for such respect service and I'll try to come again before I depart from nyc [FR] Cette critique et mon expérience ne sont que quelque chose que vous pouvez expérimenter en personne et quand je dis cela, je pense que le propriétaire était si gentil. il a chauffé mes tranches pour moi alors que je commandais depuis l'application TooGoodToGo sur iOS. Son personnel ne connaissait pas très bien l'application, mais il l'était et c'est pourquoi j'ai dit propriétaire. Mais il était gentil et a même emballé ma tranche comme tranche chaude. J'aimerai que l'un d'entre vous essaie s'il vous plaît Tony est ici Je viens de Vancouver en Colombie-Britannique et c'était délicieux et je tiens à remercier le personnel et le propriétaire pour un tel respect service et j'essaierai de revenir avant mon départ de New York

Ordered delivery on a Saturday night from the Slice app and loved everything. Food arrived a tiny bit late but it was a Saturday night after all. I ordered a Greek salad and pasta bolognese with added mozzarella. It all arrived in a pizza box which I thought was cute and clever.

THE MOST DELICIOUS FOOD EVER!! I would give a million stars if I could. Fav thing to order: Chicken parm on a hero with vodka sauce and mozzarella! OUFF 10/10! There's NOTHING bad on the menu! It's insane! I order from here about 3x a month and it NEVER disappoint! I live in LIC so it takes a lil bit to get delivered but IT IS WORTH THE WAIT! ugh just mouth watering every time. And they always pick up the phone!

So I ordered delivery from this pizzeria on Seamless. What I didn't realize is that they are in Greenpoint, Brooklyn and I am in Astoria, Queens. If I had realized I would have immediately canceled the order. Two hours later my artichoke pizza arrived -- ice cold. The majority of the blame is on Seamless, but the restaurant should have canceled the order when they saw how far away the delivery address was from them. I will say the pizza did taste good, but would have been a hundred times better if it was hot. The delivery driver was also very pleasant. Lesson learned: always check the distance of the restaurant when ordering for delivery.

I ordered a pizza today for delivery and paid extra for toppings that were not put on. When I called politely asking Tony's to send me the correct order, the woman on the phone was extremely rude and aggressive. She went off on me saying it was not Tony's fault and she blamed Uber eats and the delivery driver for the error. She didn't try to help at all and then abruptly hung up on me. My partner heard the conversation too and was blown away by her disrespect. She made us feel very comfortable. I've noticed there have been other comments on Google about a rude lady working there, so I'm guessing it's the same person. She is unsuited for a position dealing with customers. This was some of the worst customer service I've gotten from a restaurant. Completely unprofessional and inexcusable.

At Tony's the every thing stuff crust is the best pizza. Thanks to Sal. You can create your own pizza and don't forget the rolls and dishes with there home made bread.

Food: 4/5 My local pizzeria didn't pick up their phone so I found this place on Yelp and decided to give it a try. Wow.. Great pizza! Ordered for delivery and was surprised at the result. Great sauce and perfect amount of cheese. A bit doughy but still very tasty! Delivery: 4/5 Took a bit long but I ordered through a third party. Arrived ok time but will try ordering directly from the establishment next time.

my go to pizzeria when Im in greenpoint. Used to come here after school for a snapple and a slice. Always made them pretty quick, and it was a great classic slice.

I think Tony's stands up well against all the NY standards and trendy pizza joints. Always perfectly cooked, saucy, cheesey, classic. I think the magic here is in the crust. It's the perfect combo of chewy and crispy and has a mild sweet kick to it. The sweetness of the crust matches well against their less sweet/more savory sauce. Always opt for the fresh pies (the slices don't compare). To me, Tony's is a perfect quintessential NY pie. Bonus: They also have some great pasta! Meatball Parm over linguine always hits or their awesome vodka sauce! Prices are also extremely reasonable!

Most pizza places are dirty, tables, chairs, floors... It is something that comes with the territory of inexpensive food. Yet I was charged as if I went to a fancy restaurant. I ordered Ziti with Française sauce, no chicken and a bottle of ginger ale. When the computer systems asks you if you want to tip it doesn't share the amount you paid so you can thoughtfully choose a tip amount. Just a mysterious percentage choice. When I looked at the receipt sent to my phone I noticed that they added a credit surcharge in addition to sales tax, they charge you like you ordered delivery from GrubHub. I ended up paying too much for a very small meal that tasted like it was just reheated. There are plenty of pizza and pasta places that you can go to in this neighborhood that won't charge you like you just ordered from GrubHub. I wish they had price transparency because if I had known I would have walked out. This is an experience that leaves me feeling bitter. I suggested Forma Pasta, they are cheaper for better quality and they are very clean!

This is a local pizza spot not too far from the Nassau Ave. Train Station. It's just ok. They had quite a few customers ordering while we were there which is why we went in but I think it was because it's the only pizza spot in the area. There were like five guys working there and some weren't wearing masks. A few who were handling our food had beards or long hair but didn't wear any hairnets which kind of grossed me out. They have an outdoor seating area on the street that they tried to make nice with lights and flowers which I appreciated. Except they also put garbage bags there too... And now finally on to the food. It wasn't that great. Everything comes with a side of marinara sauce that was on the sweeter side and pretty good. We got 6 garlic knots for $2 and they were on the doughy side. They had very little garlic or oil on it so we were pretty much eating bread. We ordered a slice of white pizza for $3.50 I think. The ricotta was pipped on which was a nice touch but it was very bland. We also got the penne ala vodka for $11 and it tasted like it came out of a jar. The texture of the sauce was very liquidy and the favor wasn't there at all. The buffalo chicken sliders on the garlic knots were the best things there and that's because it's hard to mess up buffalo sauce. The worst offender was the eggplant parm roll. It was disgusting that after one bite we were done. The eggplants were mushy and grey and it had these awful taste of the Italian bread crumbs you get from the supermarket. It was super intense and tasted like the Parmesan in the bread crumbs had gone bad. The breaded coating was also mushy so the texture was not it.

The pizza on my second trip was great. Garlic knots, both orders, burnt. No Grubhub $10 curbside discount either.... I guess I should have ordered elsewhere today.

Tony's pizzeria is the best pizzeria in the 'hood hands down for its variety of steaming fresh pies and delicious plates. The staff is always super friendly and accommodating... everyone from the counter folks to the delivery guys. I've been a frequent customer for over 2 years and have lately been ordering consistently due to being home constantly during the Covid pandemic. Having done both pickup/delivery, I was impressed with the level of cleanliness and precaution being taken during the pandemic. There is nothing greater than being able to trust that the place your food is being made is taking necessary precautions to make sure that their patrons are receiving quality food being made with utmost cleanliness. My usual go-to has become pies with various toppings... something to break the habit of eating the same food over and over. Order from here.... you won't regret it!

I've ordered from here 5 times on GrubHub. I've only received the order 2 times. The other 3 I never got my food and had to order from elsewhere. Even when I called, a surly voice would always say, "it's coming," and hang up. Not worth the wait or the hassle.

I have ordered from this place multiple times, & I always double check because their SAUCE IS SO GOOD. It has come in very clutch in times when I am sad & hungry, which tends to be a lot. I love this place!! Very VERY quick delivery as well. Photos by @carbiesanon

I ordered something in person and was charged $2 more than what it was listed on the board and on Uber eats.

Good pizza And I'm so happy that they delivery to my house. It's around 8-9 PM and pizza place around my house is already closed and another one is not delivery. So I look on Yelp and see this place is still open so I place an order. The pizza comes on time and it is delicious.

I'll make this review brief. The pizza passes the edible test. However, it was a bit pricey. Why does pizza have to be so expensive? (There is growing trend of decreases in prices around the City associated with the mass exodus of major businesses in New York City. Where is the next San Francisco you may ask? Anyways--I digress.)

OMG!!! This pizza is SO GOOD!!! That sauce on the margarita pizza is the best I've ever had - I wish they sold jars of it :) And the potato pie is superdelicious! Everyone is so friendly here & I love coming here! Highly recommend!!!

So we walked over from our hotel. Heard places for dinner on Nassau would be a good bet. After stepping into and out of three places I will refer to as "1,000 loud people have theirs-a chair!", my wife and I found Tony's Pizza and what a find! What great pizza!! The crust. ooOh the crust! I ordered the margarita pizza. My wife had the chicken pizza. Great pizza! Sit and talk. Go ahead. Try it. Just say No to ambience. People looking for ambience are still waiting in the street at midnight to get into what? Instead, walk into Tony's Pizza. Re-introduce yourself and friends to real fun. I actually witnessed 6, 30-somethings delighted with their world at Tony's! Try replicating that in a "1,000 loud people have theirs-a chair"kind of place. Tony's is the alter ego of chic and for this reason you'll love Tony's! Pull up a simple red chair. Fall in love with real people again. Meet Tony and the staff. Smash down the "That's Good Pizza" button. Say "Thanks Tony" and walk away with two new friends-Tony and his pizza.

Really great classic nyc pizza! Recommend if you are in that Greenpoint area. Inexpensive too!

The pizza was amazing with its delicious flavorful tomato sauce. Cheese was top notch quality. The only issue we had was we ordered pepperoni on the left half of the pizza and as you can see it clearly is on the top half.

Ate our slices too fast to take a picture! The service is friendly and the pizza is fresh. We got white sauce, margherita, and a pepperoni slice. They have a lot ready and a variety of options for toppings and crusts. 10/10 recommend this spot if you are ordering a whole pizza or just grabbing a late night snack on your way home!

Honestly had high hopes for this place but completely let down !!!!!!!!!!! I'd like to name this review "back of the fridge " Ordered a grilled chicken salad and garlic knots . Seems quick and easy out of any other pizza joint . But this place really botched it up. Lol my salad looked as if was pre packed into a container a week ago and left in the fridge . Lettuce was brown and rotten all around the sides (clear container ) The chicken was dry and freezing cold . Probably cooked a week ago during meal prep day . This is now what blows my mind !! They messed the garlic knots up hahah . The top of pile knots were fresh the lower ones were as hard as stones lol . Oh plus over 2 cups of watered down olive oil .. maybe to soften the aged garlic knots idk lol . how ? Really ? Cheep lazy? I Called to let them know . They guy didn't seem surprised by what I said . Offer my money back too Not looking for my money back like you offered. Please start just serving your community decent clean fresh food !! I'll come and try it again next week and adjust my review !! Thank you from a paying customer who you literally served a salad that was garbage

This place is great!! There aren't too many good delivery options in LIC, but this is one of my favs! My favorite items are the meatball hero, ham sub & the plain slice. Soooo good! The food always comes fast and hot. Very reasonably priced too! Give Tony's a try, you won't be disappointed!

Delivery time is on point food is super good. I just don't like the chicken roll with sausage and green thing there no peporoni , but tha chicken roll is so good. Tha chicken roll was really good and the macaroni thing i order was super delicious . overal i recommened this place 100%

This place has the best sliders, several friends and I work at Broadway stages down the block on tv/film and repeatedly go back for the Buffalo Chicken sliders even though we get free lunch everyday. Looking forward for lunch to be called in 30 min to pick some up. We always pick up a few extras to give out to coworkers and everyone raves about them.

Ordered the tri color pizza as my first order from Tony's. First off, order was ready quickly and the service was friendly and welcoming. The pizza was incredible! So well prepared and amazing flavors. Can't wait to try the rest of the menu!

This is my bestie's go-to neighborhood spot for pizza. If it's good enough for her, it's definitely good enough for me. We got half cheese and half mushroom, and some garlic knots for good measure. The pizza was made to order, fresh, and delicious.

Always a go to for me. Even though it's mostly a pizzeria they have a ton of pasta options, I always get manicotti, ziti, or raviolis. Super affordable and always reliable comfort food. They guys who work there as well as the delivery drivers are very friendly too. Happy to support a local during these times, hope they are doing well!

Walked in to see 3 out of 5 staff with their masks pulled under their chins chatting to each other. Turned to see another maskless staff member serving a customer... no thanks. Walked a couple blocks to Pizza Prince where they wear masks.

Cheese pizza with extra cheese, please! Food is great. Hot wings are too. Wish it had a little bit more sauce on them though...think about it, Tony! The delivery guy was really nice. Great service overall and will order again.

This pizza place have been in a Neighbor hood more than a 25 years. Best Greenpoint pizza in town.

My cheat day hot spot! One day a month I get to bask in the glory that is Tony's Pizza. I live a block away and literally have to force myself to avoid eye contact with the Tony's sign on my way home. Tony's hits the spot every time and guess what... cheat day is a comin babay!!

Literally the best pizza in Greenpoint. I don't know why we have never ordered from them before but now we definitely will. It's our new pizza order spot now. Quality toppings, not greasy at all. Yum!

After being home for so many days , and not working out or moving . I wanted pizza but was so mad about the carbs . I just took a virtual kickboxing class ,was hungry , and tried out cauliflower crust pizza . It's FUCKIN AMAZING taste just like pizza . stay safe & wash your hands .

Best Margherita Pizza in Greenpoint! All the food is great here but buy a whole pie for the best experience!

Yum! Ton'y Pizzeria did not disappoint my Thursday evening pizza craving. We ordered the tri color square (marinara sauce, vodka sauce, pesto sauce) pizza, which was absolutely delicious. Although this was one of the pricier pizza options, I definitely did not regret my decision. The delivery was fast and flawless and I was pleasantly surprised when it came earlier than anticipated. This pizza felt very authentic and fresh. I've never tried this tri color pizza in the past, but wow, it was so flavorful! I'll definitely be ordering again from here soon.

Tony's Pizzeria of Nassau Ave you are most certainly magnificent, I had a lovely experience here today. Excellent service, nice atmosphere. I am very happy that we had White Pizza, this was one of their best dishes, really flavorful and delicious. Let me not forget the servers, who were on top of their game and provided attentive service. Tony's Pizzeria of Nassau Ave: Got ta try it. Love it.

Great warm pizza always ready when you come in. Good variety of drinks with amazing toppings. Friendly workers, and a good view of the street while you eat, or you can watch the ball game.

I work next door to these guys, I came in and quickly was greeted. Asked what I wanted and I told them a regular slice, I have to give it up to them, the pizza was very delicious and tasty sauce. To you greenpointers who are looking for a real New York slice and not a pretty slice with no taste like these over the top pizza joints, this place is for you. I recommend this place highly

Pizza is pretty good but wow these were some of the worst mozzarella sticks we've ever had think Burger King bad sauce tasted like one of those bad jarred sauce. It's hit and miss some days are good you just gotta chance it

Wowie! This was the best pizza I have had in this area. Try the buffalo chicken and pineapple. Huge portion on the lathe, do keep that in mind. Fast enough service considering the distance...delivered with a smile! Loved it and I highly recommend.

Baldo's was always my favorite pizza joint. Now it's Tony's. Perfect slice and great customer service. I never left Greenpoint, and I saw every change this neighborhood went though. I am extremely happy Tony's is still on Nassau. There are a few pizza places still left from Greenpoint's old days, but Tony's is tops. I had them cater my job 2 years ago, and everyone asked where it came from. I made a great impression on my first few months at the job. Thank you Tony's!! Miss those days of buying a large pie at Baldos, and eating it with family at Winthrop Park... Now if I had a time machine to be transported back my life would be complete.

Live a few blocks away and had a horrible experience w delivery but Tony reached out and made it up to me which was really nice. My original order arrived late and cold with barely any toppings, said it was delivered a half hour before it showed up, and delivery guy made me come to his car after a prepaid $5 tip. Tony personally called me twice and apologized and offered a free pie which really impressed me (I work in restaurants so I appreciate good customer service) Took him up on his offer and the pizza arrived promptly, hot, and with ample toppings. The first pie was probably a fluke. Only grievance was the delivery guy called me and had me come outside again, I would have hoped he told his guys to deliver to the door after bringing it to his attention the first time. Great pizza otherwise but be prepared to meet the driver outside.

Love Tony's! Been going here for years after school or work, and I can always get a slice and snapple in less than 5 minutes. Quick service, good pizza. Good stuff.

Guys, remember BALDOs?! I kind of scoffed when another pizza place opened here, but I've stopped by here and gotten delivery a couple of times and honestly, I'm kicking myself for not giving them a chance sooner. One of the thinnest and best slices in Greenpoint. Not as thin as Paulie Gees slice shop, or Screamers, but for a more "authentic" Brooklyn pizza place, it's on point. I only get regular or white pizza, never any actual pasta, so apologies for my review being a bit limited but I felt like it was still necessary to leave it after Greenpoint became sorely missing in solid slice joints once Carmine's on Norman closed.

I ordered from Tony's through Seamless. It has a fantastic rating on it, but the fanfare seemed relatively muted on Yelp so I was eager to see why there was such a huge discrepancy between the two. Their Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza was just okay and the mozzarella sticks were very disappointing. I try to give delivery food the benefit of the doubt but it would have been better to eat microwaved frozen mozzarella sticks at the market. Overall, not likely to order again unless I had to, and definitely skip the mozzarella sticks.

Great food, amazing pizza and even better people. Delivery drivers are basically the fast and furious crew. Comes hot and delicious every time. highly recomended if your in the area or close enough for delivery.