Sophie K.
Yelp
The one and absolutely most important thing that you need to know about Topalabamba, is this:
QUESO FUNDIDO.
It would be sensible to end my review here, however I will continue.
What you need to know about Topalabamba (other than Queso Fundido), is that the idea behind the dishes is sharing - the majority of dishes comes in three's or four's so you order many little dishes and love life while you're eating. Seeing as I am usually here with my amigo Carolyn E. and her Marathon Guy, there are lots of plates and lots of sharing. It's great. So far, everytime I have been there, I have ordered the frozen strawberry margarita, which is great - you can definitely taste the alcohol.
For the dishes that we (I) have tried are: Chicken Tinga, Barbacoa Beef (messy eat!), Pork Pibil Tacos. They are all delicious. One of them is quite spicy, but I don't remember which one. The Black Bean, Cactus and Smoked Green Chilli Quesadilla, which is DELICIOUS (hurray for cactus, who knew?!). I am also pretty sure that Carolyn E. and I have had the Homemade Chorizo and Melted Spicy Cheese toastada, which if I remember having it was absolutely incredible. The Mexican cheese - although doused in coriander/cilantro (die, devil span, die!) was a wonderful addition. We've also had a Chimichanga (difficult to divide between 3 people, but delicious anyways; stuffed with shredded chicken, if I am not mistaken), and a chicken tinga burrito (again - difficult to split, but delicious nonetheless!
The churros look and smell like heaven, but I have yet to try them. Be aware that the Toasted Salsa Brava is spicy! Delicious but spicy. The only thing that I do not like about Topalabamba is the Guac, it's a poor excuse for guac. It's just too smooth and I do not trust it.
However, the actual star of Topalabamba is the Classic Queso Fundido. Melted cheese in a bowl, smoking hot (temperature wise) with peppers and chorizo bits in it, and tortilla chips (some of them over salted) to dip and scoop it all up with. My mouth is watering just from thinking about it. IT IS DELICIOUS. This is the equivalent of the cheeseballs at Porter and Rye (boo!) that people rave about: only because of the Queso Fundido should you come here. If you haven't been here, go and have it. If you have been to Topalabamba and haven't had the Queso Fundido, then shame on you! (unless you're lactose intolerant or allergic to cheese, perfection and happiness), otherwise FOR SHAME! - the pictures do not do this perfection justice. Just order it.
Lastly, I should say that I love this place. Not only is the Queso Fundido good (FOR SHAME!), the staff super friendly, the décor super awesome, but the music is just the best. According to the waiter, it gets old, but I don't believe him. How can Latin music that makes you want to break out in Shakira-esque dance moves and salsa get old?
No, I love it. Everything. (Next time I want the taquitos, and more Queso Fundido).