Trattoria Da Papù

Great place, super fast and friendly service. (Splashed some pasta sauce on my white top and they even provided a stain remover!) Lovely bustling ambience and delicious food. The pistachio tiramisu is not to be missed! Highly recommend.

Excellent food, top quality two nights in a row. Staff work very hard, was fast to sit down, glad the hotel recommended them. Raw tuna dishes delicious.

Couldn't get in the first night so booked for the following night. Recommended by mainland friends. The food was ok. A little raw for me however it's seemed to be a hit here. Atmosphere and and staff were really friendly.

Beyond disappointed. First red flag was the food coming out 5 mins after ordering. The calamari fritty was worse than the frozen ones you find at the grocery store, and at 20euro a plate, it's basically criminal- dry, bland, I imagine a Car tyre has a similar taste and texture - pure rubber. The tuna steak was also overcooked, barely warm, and again very bland. From price, to quality, the entire experience was horrible. DO NOT EAT HERE!

Perfect dinner. Among the best crudu plates we had all trip. Great service and staff. Generous portions.

I wouldn't recommend this place. Food was average and expensive. I ate at other restaurants with similar price or cheaper price and the food was way better. Service was quick.

Completely full Tuesday night in September. Time is a problem here. 5 mins to get water and another 20 to have our orders taken, plus another 30 mins to get the bill (save yourself the time and go inside to pay by card). The antipasti were very good, however, primi basil pasta was -heavily- salted with too much oil. Not many gamberi on the other pasta. Overall, nothing special just okay. Wouldn't visit again.

Excellent food and suitably priced for the island (never forget you’re in Favignana!). My wife had two starter (in photo) while I had the pasta Tonnara. Everything was extremely delicious. Booking is a must or you will be left waiting for at least a couple of hours. Was so good we returned the following evening! Shoutout to the staff who despite being extremely busy was extremely professional.