Two Cities Pizza Co.

Awesome decor to go along with great tasting pizza! We chose our favorite, New York style pizza over Chicago style. Next time we will try CS! We highly recommend the Main Street Meatballs! Our server was very helpful and the service was fast! We will definitely be back very soon!

The new larger large pie is BIG, like, really big. Love the proper thin crust you can fold. A proper NY pizza at 20” across, where the medium is now the original large. Delicious. My favorite pizza outside of NYC and it’s in my own Mason backyard! The garlic Parmesan fries are also delightfully crisp and tasty, and don’t sleep on their wings. Coca cola products ✔️(Coke is the only correct beverage with pizza). Dine in service is always friendly and polite, and takeout is low drama, but yes wait times will be longer on busy weekend nights because it’s one of the best pizzas in town.

Drove from Louisville Kentucky and was an absolute great experience from the moment we walked up. Every employee we encountered was super sweet. And the food was amazing, right down to the crispinesss of our delicious Chicago style pizza. Atmosphere very inviting. The weather was great so we sat outside

I’ve been looking forward to visiting this shop for a while, and it was worthwhile. Jake did a wonderful job hosting our table of three; he was attentive and ensured that we had everything that we needed. Loved the hybrid menu between New York style pizza and Chicago deep dish. I walked away partial to the New York style, but I encourage anyone to try the Chicago style here. Make sure to order a side of the house made ranch. Note: Two Cities allows you to order pies half-and-half; since it was my first time, it was a great way to try more of their product. Make sure to visit the bathroom before leaving. It transports you to a NYC subway station. Amazing concept.

This was absolutely the best pizza place we've ever been to! Fantastic atmosphere, top notch service and most of all the Chicago Deep Dish pizza was fantastic! The buttery crisp crust was delicious! Highly recommended for date night or just to watch a game!

From the moment we walked in, we were treated like royalty! This is no ordinary pizza place. Nestled in the 1930s art deco former city hall, and home to the nation's best restrooms (it is a real thing!), Two Cities had the best Chicago style pizza! We haven't tried the New York style yet but will be back soon to check it out! Don't skimp on the veggies either, the Waldorf salad was fresh, bright, and perfectly executed. A special treat was the donut holes for dessert! Special thank you to Kait and the whole team for making this such a fun day out!

By far, the best pizza I have had since I moved into this area. Really really good job! Both the deep dish Chicago style and the New York style are absolutely great! Crisp crust. Great sauces! The sauce on the Chicago style is different than the New York style. All good. The Chicago style sauce has some pretty good size hunks of tomatoes in it so if you don't like those they're pretty easy to pick off. Either way though, the sauce is spectacular!

Two of us stopped in for a bite while we were in town hitting up a nearby record store. It was a busy Saturday evening so we waited over 30 minutes to be seated, which we found reasonable. The weather was nice so we had a pleasant wait on benches outside. Great pizza options and such a cool location. We were happy to see a cauliflower crust available. We will be back when in this area again:)