830leow
Google
The stay was great in many ways, except there was one fatal problem -- the onsen (public hot bath) was broken.||The room was great. We know what a room with Japanese futons means, so it perfectly met our expectations. The food was great. In the dinner, the beef main course was perfectly executed, and the "salmon wellington" was a delightful surprise. The breakfast was full of Japanese small dishes too. The portion size was pretty good too. While I can't say all ingredients were ultra premium, it was very reasonable.||But the onsen was broken, and I think it was fatal. I think it is fair to say the onsen is the single biggest reason for staying in a onsen ryokan. When it is broken, they really has the obligation to compensate profoundly, in my opinion. But they didn't.||They did not send me an email to proactively notify me about the situation. They only tell me so when I actually arrived for check-in, even so, they just said "although the hot bath is broken, the shower in your room is ok". But hey, of course I wanted to use the onsen in an onsen ryokan! Their attitude was like they just shrugged their shoulders. No compensation whatsoever. And the verbal notification at checkin was all they "offered". There were no apologies whatsoever afterwards throughout our stay. They even dare to continue charging me the Onsan Tax (JPY 150 per adult) even there were no onsen!||Two staff members were a middle-aged couple, which I believe are the boss and wife of the probably family-owned onsen ryokan. They were there thoughtout our stay, from checkin, to meals, to checkout. I did not argue about the broken onsen, figured I needed a stay anyway, and arguing wouldn't be of any use anyway. It was the woman who checked me out, and there were no sorry on her face when she dared to charge me the onsen tax.||Oh by the way, I said the couple were there all the time, right? I really had a feeling of us being watched.||One more thing. We went for sightseeing after checkout, so needed to store our bags. When we returned, we found our bags just placed in the lobby, they were not locked whatsoever, and there were no staff. Anyone could have just taken our bags away! We just took our bags and left, no one noticed.||Everything above points to one thing. While the service was "nicely executed", in their hearts all they wanted was just getting the business completed. They wanted our money, and that's it. They otherwise had no interest in meeting our needs. This is still true when they couldn't even deliver the onsen!||The room rate (with 2 meals) was not cheap. The town Kiso-Fukushima is a small town, and there are few options along the Kiso Valley or Nakasendo, unless we head all the way back to the big cities of Nagoya or Matsumoto. We chose to stay there only because we wanted to spend a few days for a more in-depth experience of a Nakasendo-themed trip, including an onsen, like a traveller in the past. We didn't mind the price, but they ought to deliver! An onsen ryokan without an onsen, even if it was "just" "temporarily" broken, is unforgivable. I know things happens, but I think it is fair to say they must compensate profoundly, which they certainly didn't. It was never in their mind, they just wanted our business.||This alone already worth them a 1-star. I'm giving it 2-stars only because they otherwise delivered other elements of an onsen ryokan, but even so, it was only at the execution level. I otherwise question their service attitude.