Marie P.
Google
I was really looking forward to trying Via Cassia after reading so many great reviews. The space itself is beautiful—stylish with a great vibe—and our evening started off on a high note. We waited just about 5 minutes for our table to be cleaned, then were seated with a complimentary glass of prosecco, which was a lovely touch.
We started with cocktails. I had the Cosmo Italiano, which I didn’t care for, but my fiancé enjoyed The Tainted Lady, a mezcal-based drink. When we were ready to order, the waitress asked us to place everything at once, saying the kitchen would send out dishes in their suggested order.
First came the charcuterie board. It included three cheeses and three types of meat. The goat cheese stood out, but overall, it felt just okay—not bad, but not memorable either.
Next, both the white and red pasta dishes came out at the same time, which was a bit confusing since we were sharing plates. Naturally, we started with the cacio e pepe, which was absolutely phenomenal—perfectly balanced and one of the best I’ve ever had. Unfortunately, while we enjoyed that, the pomodoro pasta just sat. By the time we got to it, it was lukewarm and overcooked. The sauce was overly sweet, and we ended up not finishing it.
Then came a long wait—at least 25–30 minutes—with no update from the staff. We had no idea the steak was still coming until I asked if we could move on to dessert. The waitress then mentioned the steak was still on its way. I was honestly surprised. When it finally arrived, the skirt steak was actually very good and my fiancé enjoyed it, but it was served completely on its own. Had we known, we would’ve ordered something to go with it. Again, no communication.
For dessert, we had the panna cotta and the affogato. The affogato was excellent. The panna cotta, unfortunately, was way too soft and overly sour—definitely a miss.
One final detail that really disappointed me: we made our reservation through Resy and noted that we were celebrating my fiancé’s birthday. Not only did no one mention it, but there wasn’t even a basic acknowledgment like a candle or a “happy birthday.” It felt like a missed opportunity to make the night special.
There’s good potential here—the ambiance is beautiful and the cacio e pepe was truly a standout—but poor pacing, lack of communication, and missed details really affected the overall experience. In an area full of exciting and well-run spots, Via Cassia has some work to do if it wants to stand out.