Wish Willy Bar & Grill

Wish Willy Bar & Grill is one of those places that captures everything good about Caye Caulker—laid-back vibes, unreal food, and that feeling like you’re just hanging in a friend’s backyard. Most nights, the sun’s going down, the grill’s fired up, reggae is rolling through the air, and Maurice is behind the scenes working his magic. Grab a seat at one of the long picnic tables for a family-style setup, or tuck into one of the covered spots if it looks like rain. Drinks are self-serve—just keep your empties and square up after your meal, island-style. The food? Chicken, fish, and lobster are all top-tier. If you’re lucky (or plan ahead), ask for the hummus plate—trust me, it’s something special. Portions are perfect, flavors are incredible, and the backyard vibe makes every bite better. Maurice is a legend. Usually busy cooking, but if the pace slows down, take the chance to chat—and don’t forget to say hi to the dogs! We kept coming back for the chill atmosphere, the consistently amazing food, and prices that feel more than fair (around $25 BZD per plate). Just ask if you’re unsure—Maurice will let you know what’s up. A true island gem worth revisiting again and again.

The barracuda curry here was amazing!! This restaurant is literally in Willy’s backyard and has communal benches. Bring/wear bug repellent though because we were getting bit like crazy!

Must go place, would recommend going early around 6-6.30 to ensure you get some food cos whatever chef gets that day is getting cooked up on the bbq and when its gone, its gone! family style bench seating was nice so chatted to lots of other customers too We went twice while on caye caulker and got the bbq chicken and fish (barracuda) both so delicious! Help yourself to drinks in the cooler and pay cash only for everything you had at the end

I always recommend this place for dinner. Mr. Wish Willy is very friendly and welcoming. We love the island vibe of his restaurant as well as the delicious food he prepares. Everything tastes fresh and home made and he gives plenty of portions. His food is packed with flavor and you never leave disappointed. The restaurant is always filled with people and there is never a slow moment with him because everyone loves his dishes and his personality. If there is absolutely anywhere you should try on the island it’s his food. Please make sure you have the opportunity to give it a try when you visit you won’t regret it!

The lobster is superb, best I’ve ever had. Willy’s approach is unique, and we loved it! Great guy who likes to have a chat. Definitely a great place if you’re in for a cool experience, but come with the right expectations: it’s not a fancy dine in restaurant. Food’s a bit on the expensive side, but the food on Caye Caulker is expensive to begin with so it’s priced well.

I’d go back to Wish Willy every single day if I could. willy presents you with an opportunity to escape your life for an hour and immerse yourself in the island lifestyle. His food is cooked to perfection and seasoned beautifully! GO TO WISH WILLYS!!!!!

Best meal on the island! Don’t expect a fancy restaurant or a quick meal… it’s more about the experience of a local backyard BBQ with some of the most deliciously seasoned simple food you could desire. You’ll grab a drink from the cooler and Maurice will get to you when he has time to let you know what he is grilling that day. And whatever he is grilling, you’re going to love it!

Absolutely delicious local food served up in a casual and cozy setting. Loved it !! So delicious and fresh