Nile Dee
Google
I just want to qualify my 3-star rating for the food. It is purely based on a personal preference. The food was actually quite tasty but I personally just didn't like the way it was prepared. We ordered the ragu, pesto and carbonara. The ragu was fine - rigatoni and ragu was tasty and cooked as expected. For the pesto, it was done more as a basil emulsion and the pine nuts were scattered in whole across the dish. It resulted in a dish where the pasta sat in a thinnish runny sauce - while it tasted ok, I didn't like the mouth-feel. I prefer my pesto in the more traditional method - where the pesto is more like a oil-based paste with the pine nuts crushed through it. For the carbonara, again it tasted ok, but something about how it felt more like an oily emulsion, rather than having a silky yolky dressing in the spaghetti.
I reiterate that it's purely personal preference that's behind this rating and review. The final point is regarding the pricing - I felt it was a bit on the high side for a casual suburban eatery - $30 for the pesto and low $32 for the ragu and carbonara. The portion sizing was very generous though, but perhaps because I didn't enjoy the way the dishes were cooked, it did feel more steep for me for my experience.
Otherwise, the setting was beautiful (rustic, old school) and service very good. The place is obviously a local institution in Northcote and has its loyal following, so all the best to the owner and staff. Hope this review reads as being honest and constructive, and not critical and destructive - I fully own it as being based on personal preference as opposed to an actual issue with the food itself.