Honest Y.
Yelp
I'd been eyeing My Loup for a while after hearing so many rave reviews, and finally got the chance to try it. I've been to Her Place Supper Club (from the same team), and while I loved the ambiance and service there, the food didn't quite stick with me. So I came into My Loup curious, but hopeful.
We had reservations at the bar, and our server/bartender was warm and welcoming.
We started with the Extra Sour Sourdough served with whipped butter, cornichons, and pearl onions. A simple dish, but it was done really well. The bread had that perfect chew with a satisfying tang. Solid start and definitely something I'd recommend.
Next up was the Yellowtail with Carrot and Orange. The flavor combo was bright and citrusy, but the yellowtail itself tasted a bit too fishy for me. The other ingredients tried to balance it out, but it didn't quite land, probably wouldn't order this one again.
The Maine Sea Urchin with Sweet Potato and Brioche came beautifully presented in a sea urchin shell. Flavor-wise, it was unique and well-balanced, though I was hoping for a bit more uni for the price. Still, it was interesting enough that I'd order it again.
Then came the Pastrami Beef Tartare on Latkes. Cool concept, and the flavors were decent, but as someone who holds beef tartare to a high standard, it didn't quite blow me away. Good, not great.
Green Garlic Escar Roll. This dish was highly recommended, so we were curious. It came out looking like a cinnamon roll, literally. We expected something lighter, maybe a puff pastry tart with a garlicky escargot center. Instead, it was doughy and dense, and the escargot inside lacked bold flavor. A creative idea, but the execution didn't quite land for us.
But the star of the night? The Bone-In Filet. Served with onions, sherry, and Birchrun Blue, this dish was everything I hoped for and more. Perfectly cooked, meltin your mouth texture, and that rich sauce tied it all together. The onions were a nice touch, and although the blue cheese wasn't totally my flavor profile so I didn't eat the cheese. We also had a side of fries and they were decent, just needed a bit more crunch, but dipping them into the steak sauce? Chef's kiss.
We skipped dessert this time, but I'd definitely come back, especially for that filet.
Overall: 4 out of 5 stars. Some dishes missed the mark, but the highlights made the visit worthwhile.