4 Corners Pizzeria

Walked it to a random pizzeria, and low and behold amazing hospitality that made me feel like i was a long term neighborhood customer, even willing to have me taste a drink before i bought it (though doesnt regularly do so). Pizza was good, had a normal cheese and a grandma slice. Highly recommend.

Old school pizzaria! In this location since 1969. Always visit while in Pelham. In my opinion Sicilian slice stacks up with Sal's in Mamaroneck. Bring cash, you can't swipe or tap here, as I said old school and that's a compliment!

Yummy pizza, legendary location. I went on for a bite late night, greeted with warm welcome and had a 2 slice of pizza. It a bit old school of a spot, but c’mon the pizza and service and the options is what makes a USA spot a spot. Will definitely be back if I am passing by.

Chewy, thin crust, a little on the gummy side and a little bland in taste. Flavorful cheese has a bit more acidity than the usual pizza cheese. Kind of sparse on the sauce, and couldn't discern any particular flavor.

Ordered a grandma pizza through seamless from here. Pizza looked nothing like the picture. Almost no cheese at all. No basil at all. And soggy. First picture is what I got. Second picture is what they advertised. They didn’t even try. Won’t be going there again.

In my opinion this is currently the best pizza venue in town. Pizza is delicious made with good ingredients, service is great and staff friendly. It’s a small place and not suitable for a dinner date but perfectly fine for a quick lunch or dinner

Ordered twice recently here. First time I tried and wasn’t impressed. Sauce doesn’t taste fresh, just doesn’t taste all that good. The cheese quality is ok and dough isn’t all that bad but the sauce ruins it here for me. Just had their regular pizza. Some people say it’s good and even gave a second chance and still wasn’t that good.

Has always been one of my favorite pizzeria’s. I stop in frequently and always look forward to seeing their Great and friendly staff. Always fresh and delicious

Stopped by for a quick lunch and ordered the hot honey pepperoni Sicilian . I have no words to explain just how good this was but I've been craving it since . Do yourself the favor and stop by for a slice , you won't regret it . Cute little pizzeria in Pelham , small seating area . Friendly family environment.

Maybe I caught them on a bad day, the food here was very poor quality and lacked taste. I will give them another shot just to make sure it wasn't a fluke, but I'd suggest trying other pizza shops in Pelham. Four corners has gone down hill in the past few years and the quality of their food reflects it.

I've been coming here since I was a little boy, and I've never had a bad meal here! The pizza is delicious! The owner is super kind and friendly, if he notices you're eating alone he'll strike up a conversation with you. I recommend their pizza with peppers and onions

Solid chicken parm slice. The pizzaiolo is Italian I heard him speaking while I ate. So it's legit. It has the taste and appeal of a bronx pizzeria. The only negative was the pizza was floppy when I grabbed it and rolled it together end to end. Other than that, good slice. Next time I'll try the plain slice.

I just discovered this great place. Classic NY Style pizza slice. Small but charming pizzeria, really enjoyed the Grandma slice and Pepperoni pinwheel.

Let's start off with the claim that this is amazing pizza which is what i heard from a number of people in the area. Is it? No. Is it good? Sure. Is it the best pizza in area by far? I think so. This place gets 5 stars for a number of reasons. Semi sweet sauce, a dense crust (maybe too dense for me) and good quality mozz. Super friendly services, good prices, decor and overall vibe makes this an easy, solid 5 stars. While this is not going to be compared to Joe's in the city anytime soon, it's your typical slice joint in Brooklyn or Queens. It's the kind of place that you go to all the time and depend on. You know this slice will never let you down. You grow up with it and love it and nothing can replace it. I didn't grow up with it, and even I know it's a solid choice in all the pizza I've tried in Westchester and will now absolutely be my new go to spot for the foreseeable future. More than happy to travel for this one.

As a long time Westchester resident, I can say this is some of the best pizza in the county that I have had. Oh, and if you love white pizza with the ricotta, this is literally the best place to get it, rich and creamy, not dry and boring like other places. All the pizza is good and very affordable. True Italians run this joint so it's always bangin. Come try this place you won't regret.

Currently takeout only. Ordered Pepperoni Pizza, Grandmas Pizza, Meat Calzone and Sausage and Peppers Calzone through GrubHub. Wish they put a little more pepperoni on the pie and the basil was missing from the Grandmas, but still enjoy the slice. The calzones were good. Still one of our favorite places for pizza in the area.

Overall rating: A I love this place! It looks like your standard local neighborhood pizzeria and they happen to make really GOOD pizza! There are a few tables and chairs in here but most people do takeaway. My friend lives a block away and we get this from time to time. It's a small pizzeria that recognizes the locals who come in frequently. My friend and I were having game night and we ordered 2 large pizzas for pick up for our group. They said it would take 20 minutes. We got: -Large Veggie Pizza $23 (Toppings included onions, broccoli, spinach, and mushrooms): Veggie pizza is generally not my favorite but everyone else enjoyed it. It's a little bland for me. So I needed to add parmesan cheese and my trusty dried herb trio (garlic, oregano, and red pepper flakes). B -Large Pepperoni and Onion Pizza $23: This is my favorite combination and they didn't disappoint! This only needed a dash of parmesan. One person in our group managed to polish off HALF of this pizza overnight, despite complaining she didn't like onions! (Though she generously left 1.5 veggie slices behind!) There goes my pepperoni leftovers the next day! A+ I think the price difference between the small and large sizes is only $3! I usually just spring for the large since the difference is miniscule! Only thing I miss here are garlic knots (they only do garlic rolls). Great NYC pizza if you're in the area. Oh and guard your leftovers or else!

I had a delicious Sicilian slice with meatballs and a bit of extra cheese and I gotta admit I will be coming here for pizza and the service is great !

I have to admit, Four Corners Pizza was actually awesome. Clean, vibe is cool. I will certainly tell all my friends to try their Grandma Pie, it was simply unbelievable. Workers: excellent. Attentive and professional. Honestly, Four Corners Pizza is one of my favorite places!

The best pizza anywhere! I don't care if you agree or not just try it and judge for yourself. These guys have been cranking out fantastic pizza forever. Slice of 'roni? White pizza? White with dollops of red sauce? Sicilian? Whole pies made to order with any toppings. They do it all, with a smile and an excellent demeanor. (I fell in love here...slice with extra cheese, pepperoni and broccoli. Cannot beat it.) I could wax poetic about my long, LONG nights hanging at 4 corners as a youth tearing it up always. I've eaten a lot of good pizza, I've also eaten a lot of horrible pizza. (Ever heard of "party pizza" from RI?look it up.) Suffice to say I have been around and this is the place where I discovered how good pizza can be and the benchmark I judge every other pizza by. No where is pizza made with more tradition and care than this tiny slice of four corners.

Have been coming here for nearly 35 years. LOve the pizza, and especially love the meat calzones. Go weekly

New York Pizza at its finest! Ok, so it is in Pelham Manor, just north of the Bronx off of Boston Post Road, yet still authentic, old style NYC pizza flavor! Light, flavorful, crunchy crust just thick enough to hold the well-seasoned. sauce and perfect amount of cheese! As you hear the crunch of your first bite and carefully try to catch the delightful string of cheese, you will be transported back to the days of true New York City pizza!

I was in town staying the night at my sister's. No time for a big dinner, so how about some pizza? I asked my nephew for a recommendation.. and this was the joint. Not bad Pizza, but when I went into order it they suggested I take the pie that they put out for selling slices. It was near the end of the day and they were probably thinking that their pie was going to waste. They warmed it up for me, but I think, in retrospect, I should have held out for a fresh pie. We ate a few slices, put it away, and in the morning discovered my nephew and his friend had demolished the rest!

My favorite for a plain slice. Go to spot for a quick delicious slice fresh out of the oven. Been going here for over 20 years and never disappoints.

UPDATE: New owners, rotten attitudes and a miserable degradation in pizza quality take Four Corners from 5 stars to ONE. It's a sad day for a once proud institution. NEVER AGAIN. _________ I don't get what it is about 3 great reviews for this place that get filtered out. It seems almost political!! I read all three, and they're honest and authentic. Anyway, I grew up in New Rochelle, worked, lived and played all over NYC for over half my life. Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx (lived a stone's throw from Arthur Ave. for 3 years). Lived in Pelham, Live in Yonkers, and I know what pizza aught to be. In Westchester, Four Corners is IT. Villagio in Tuckahoe is pretty good, specifically for their specialty slices. Al' Antica in Scarsdale was pretty special... then changed owners. It is now merely good. Pizza Pizza in Mt. Vernon is good. For a plain slice (Neo or Sicil.), 4C is the best. I've been to every corner of the county, and there are some good, some not-so-good.... and some that deserve abject derision. 4C is the perfect slice. the cheese / sauce ratio is just right, the crust is the kind that only comes from 30+ years of experience, and the crew is no-nonsense. Went to Frank Pepe's on Central, based on good reviews; yuk. Went to Dunwoodie on Yonker's ave w/in the last 2 months, based on stellar reviews; just plain BAD. I'd rather have a Totino's Pizza Roll. Stick w/ 4C. There's a reason they've been around longer than my ol' dad.

Good Pelham pizza place and i was able to show a friend visiting from out of town good NY pizza. Quick, cheap, delicious. Four Corners is small, with a few tables, and a small selection, but they have quality pizza. I'm glad I stopped in. Will definitely return.

This place is not a normal pizzeria. The Sicilian pizza is never available because they seem to make a certain amount of them, once they run out...that's it....NO SICILIAN PIZZA. 2-3 Small bench tables for seating. Usually teenagers take up most of the space. Owners/workers not friendly...no personality, don't really interact with patron, take your order, leave. Pizza usually dry, way too much dough. The old gray haired man made awesome pizza, but he retired. The guys that are left made unimpressive pizza. Calzones UGH. All dough. Pass on this place especially if you like Sicilian pizza--their food is unreliable in taste and many times unavailable. Never heard of a pizza place running out of Sicilian pizza.

Totally unprofessional, not polite and they touch the pizza and money with the same hands... stay away !!!!

I grew up going to Prospect Hill and eating 1 slice and a drink for $1.25. Awesome back in the late 70's and early 80's and is still awesome now. I went back last night for the first time since 1984, and Joe was still running the place, but without hair.... Sadly his father passed away, but now his son runs the joint. I almost started crying when I ate a slice. Memories.

I must admit, this one star is strictly for the cleanliness of the operation. I never got a chance to consume the pizza. Here's why: the man at the counter (who also handles the money) handled my pizza with his bare hands with nails that looked at if he were at horticulturist and just dug into a bag of dirt. Missing was the use of a spatula that one might find in a Conventional pizza shop. Seeing the aforementioned, I paid for the pizza without a fuss, then walk outside and threw the pizza in the trash.

I ordered a grandma pie and it came without any cheese. What Italian pizza comes with no cheese? It was tomatoes on bread. Horrible

Best pizza ever. I stop in for pizza every time I'm in town. Friendly staff and the place is super clean. Can't wait to go back in 2 weeks.

1st off, this place was great back in the day when Joe owned it. 2nd, the new owner (of past few years) is a jerk. He was rude to me in front of my kids, rude to my baby sitter when she was there with my kids, and the owner curses even when kids are in the place. A real certifiable loser in my opinion. I heard he was trying to sell the place. PLEASE DO. YOU DO NOT BELONG IN THE RESTAURANT - CUSTOMER SERVICE BUSINESS. 3rd, this place is slightly more expensive than all the rest yet the food is not good. BLAND at best. 4th, if want decent to great pizza in this area, I'll list in ascending order: Villagios - wolf's lane / pelham Saccones (Washington ave / new rochelle) Marcellos - 5th ave / pelham Pelham pizza - 5th ave /pelham Modern pizza (hugenot ave / new rochelle) Do yourself a favor and don't even bother with this place.

One of the best pizza's in Westchester County area...I know the guys running the place for many years, they are some of the best people around...I sometimes go out of the way just to eat there or buy some pies...There Sicilians are excellent as well and worth trying... Prices are good and the food is great especially when it comes out fresh from the oven.

Eh, pizza was just okay. We ordered a large regular crust pie with pepperoni. Maybe it's not that great because we got it to go and it was warm, not piping hot, when we got home. Anyway, it was whatever. The guys working there were nice enough. Wasn't that busy. Prob won't go there again.

It's excellent pizza. Used to eat there several times a week but stopped over ten years ago (nothing to do with the restaurant). Went back last week- not only was the pizza still great but they remembered me.

Good old fashion pizza here. Loved it reminded me when I was a little kid and my mom would give me a dollar to go to a old fashion Italian pizzeria pizza tasted the same. The new pizza shops now can't compare.

Really good pizza! Sicilian was tasty and so was the veggie slice! Never been here before and I really enjoyed it. Only thing I don't like is no bathroom! However the pizza was definitely good!

I ordered a chicken roll and: 1. It was disgusting 2. It was burnt 3. It was like "Where is Waldo" - I had to search for the chicken and after eating the whole thing I realized there was one... yes ONE small piece of chicken in the whole thing that was the size of about 1/4 of a penny. 4. It was more expensive than any other pizza place I've been to and i've been to alot. In summary, this place is disgusting, expensive, you have a long wait with no one in the place and it's not worth the visit. I used to go here years ago when the old owners had it (for about 30 years) and it was great. The new owner obviously: 1. Doesn't know how to cook 2. Doesn't know how long to keep food in the oven. 3. And is obviously trying to rip everyone off with the high prices and lack of meat and other ingredients. Sad to say "STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE!!!" If I could give zero stars I would.

When I was a child, the regular slices I could compare to a slice of heaven. They kind of lost their spark over the years. ...Butttt, it's still more amazing than most village pizza joints around that area! I definitely recommend you check it out if your in the area and if your gf or wife isn't in the mood you have NO.1 Chinese right next store if she's in a "My Cousin Vinny" mood and hassling you about what to feed her in a small village suburb of NYC. I can honestly say the pizza in this town can top most of what Manhattan can offer you as well! So stop in and have a slice and forgedaboud-it. :P

Each time I visit, I feel more and more at home. Nicest staff members which I think are owners. This being said, there is a great quality put into the pizza and calzones (personal favorite). Thanks guys, your efforts are appreciated.

If I could I would give this place no stars but we have to give at least one to leave a review! I went in with my husband last nite around 9pm or so on 9/6/2019, he's Italian and I'm hispanic. I felt a very strange vibe when we walked in both the old man behind the counter and the young lady who was putting together pizza boxes in the front looked at us like we had 10 heads! My husband asked for a meatball wedge and I asked for a slice and the older man's response was just flat out nasty!! He told us they don't make meatball wedges which is fine it's the WAY he said it!! I felt their was a bit of racism attached to this whole experience! This guy doesn't belong in the restaurant/ customer service business!! We walked out and bought NOTHING! Why buy from a pizza place that has such a rude person behind the counter...when you can go to Pelham Road and walk into Pizza Center which has MUCH BETTER PIZZA in my opinion and an amazing, welcoming staff and owners!! I will never set foot in Four Corners Pizza again!!! I also have a You Tube channel with over 15 thousand subscribers and I will be sharing this information with them all!

I am lucky to say I've grown up eating this pizza since I was a little kinderlux. It's the best pizza around, enough said.

The owner here is so nice! The pizza is very good, much better than many you'll find around. It's a no- frills place, but we like it!

Very passable pizza I would not go out of my way for this pizza but if you re stuck in Pelham and need a speedy bite i would recommend it. On the other hand the price is right at $2.50 a slice 5 bucks feeds you lunch.

We drive all the way from Fleetwood in Mt.Vernon to Four Corners Pizza in Pelham, the Pizza is delicious, authentic flavor with a nice crisp crust! Excellent customer service!

"A Little Pizza Heaven" This pizzeria is ALWAYS consistent, they have the best regular and Sicilian pizza. Whenever we eat there, we have one pie to stay and one to go. The Sicilian pies freeze perfectly. I used to live nearby and I moved up to northern westchester county where the pizza is terrible. Whenever I am down county, I bring a pie back home with me. This place has a new owner as of a couple of years, but it hasn't missed a beat!!!

4 Corners: Get ready for the NY style pizza you have been waiting for. I LOVE this pizzeria. From the kind staff to the family feel it is your spot for pizza if your in the Bronx-Westchester area. Let me start with the flaws. Now if this was a sheer review about food this pizza would be close to a 5/5 BUT it is about the entire restaurant so I must add some flaws. It is located along a busy road it's a B-I-T-C-H to pull into (Still worth it;) ) and it is quite small. If it had a larger space with maybe a better system of pay it would be a 5/5 in my eyes. Now to the positives; The Food!! This place is simply amazing. Although not many slices to chose from they cook each to perfection whether it be a spinach, Chicken, white, or simply regular. (If your looking for a pizzeria with fancy shamncy pizza your in the wrong place pal). Biting into a slice is like delving into pizza heaven. Along with delicious Italian ice to top off your meal. So if your looking for Bronx/NY style pizza stop by 4 Corners to fulfill your needs. La Felle

Our Friday night tradition for the last 38 years has been to go to "Four Corners Pizza". Even though they changed owners recently, their pizza has remained consistently delicious; crunchy/slightly firm bottom & just the right amount of cheese to tomato sauce ratio. Joe, the new owner, has added new food items to their menu, i.e., Grandma Pie, Pepperoni Pinwheels & fresh salads. For my family & myself these new items just makes Joe's "Four Corners Pizza" a complete & gratifying meal experience.

Best place for a regular slice, period. Anyone who says otherwise is probably from the sticks and grew up on Domino's. Don't mess around with toppings - 4 Corners is all about the regular slice.

I really love Joe - the owner. If he could clone himself, the place would get 5 stars and I would eat there every day. I have to say though that (sorry Joe - I love you like family) the staff are ignorant and arrogant people. They talk to each other while 10 people wait in line at the counter. They continually burn their pizza and the sauce has gone down hill. All I have left are my memories of what a great place it USED to be. Very sad.

This place has been a Pelham Manor staple for more then 40 years. The pizza is great. There is no need for gimmicky food here. Come on by and grab a slice. In the summer the Italian ice will hit the spot.

This is not the place to go if you want a grand menu filled with a multitude of Italian dishes. But if you want a really solid slice of NY pizza, Four Corners is the way to go. Brian commented specifically on the delicious simplicity of the sauce. It's cash only and there are only three booths, so I might suggest taking it to go.

I'm sure the people here are very nice and that the community appreciates a Mom and Pop pizza place in their neighborhood but the pizza here are pretty bad. I tried the regular pepperoni slices and there was virtually no sauce and the flavor wasn't good at all. The place is pretty tiny and had one booth and there were only a couple options for things they had available to reheat for you (though I'm sure they would have made anything you wanted from their menu if you wanted to wait). Maybe a fresh pizza would have been better? Sorry but this place was just a miss.

Wife grew up down the street...tells me place has gone downhill for years now...had a slice and am convinced that wife had a great point

We went here on someone else's recommendation and won't be back because there are SO many other options. Life is too short for lackluster pizza. I asked the guy behind the counter what was on the "Special" - it was listed on the menu board above the counter - and HE DIDN'T KNOW! We ordered 2 pizzas that they made-to-order. Nothing special, a bit pricey for what we got.

Amazing pizza!! My family started going there when they opened 40+ years ago. We now live in CT and still make the trip to have a great pie. CT pizza will never compare to New York. Joe and tony are great guys