Rob P.
Yelp
Boy did I luck out!  I had just flown in with my girlfriend from Las Vegas, and my uncle left a company party at 40 Westt to come pick me up.  When he asked if we were hungry, he threw us in the car and brought us back to meet his coworkers.
We were just in time to order our meals, and what followed was a wonderful four course meal.  First we each had an appetizer... mine was some sort of seafood plate including shrimp, octopus, and calamari.  My girlfriend's plate was tuna tar tar.  Next up was an insalata caprese salad, which was one of the best I've ever had.
The main course was next, in which we both enjoyed a nice big filet mignon.  The sides were to share for the table, and we sampled the mashed potatoes and sauteed spinach.  The french fries were outstanding, though, but I think that's just cuz fries are good EVERYWHERE in Montreal.
After that, we found room for the dessert trio they put in front of us, which had a lemon cake (good), some ice cream (better), and some sort of chocolate lava cake (best, delicious, and any other positive adjectives you can think of).
Throughout our meal we enjoyed a jazz band that did decent covers of current songs, too.  Atmosphere was good, service was good, and food was outstanding.  Here's to more good meals while visiting Montreal...