Dennis C.
Yelp
Hello Shucky, my old friend.
I've come to dine with you again.
A.W. Shucks Raw Bar & Grill first opened in 2005, tucked away behind the intersection of Colonial Avenue and 22nd Street, after new owners spent months remodeling an older former seafood restaurant in its same space.
It is adjacent to the Coast DIY Bar, an art and craft workshop and studio. On the opposite side is a row of businesses that includes the Catnip Cat Cafe. A large parking lot is provided.
We go back a long way. I made my first visit during their opening week and immediately became a regular customer. It also become my favorite drinking spot.
A series of life detours then led me away from the local bar and dining scene for several years. I finally got back into the game when I joined Yelp in 2013.
My original review was written in 2015, before I even had a cell phone. When I looked over that review and saw its lack of photos, I decided an update was well overdue.
A.W. Shucks announced last month (November, 2020) that they were reopening for lunch on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. This updated review is based upon four recent lunch time visits.
As a COVID era precaution, they took my temperature during each of my visits. Two outdoor tables, spaced well apart for social distancing, are now provided.
I ate inside their enclosed patio area during each of my visits and ordered the following:
JAMBALAYA: Shrimp and Andouille Sausage Served in a Savory Creole Sauce with Rice Pilaf and topped with a Fresh Catfish Filet.
Their Jambalaya remains as one of the best I have ever enjoyed. In fact, it tasted even better than I remembered.
The shrimp were large, plump, and delicious. The Andouille Sausage was tender and flavorful.
The Creole sauce was knockout delicious and combined beautifully with the rice pilaf. It was seasoned superbly with a nice spicy and peppery kick.
The piece de resistance was the blackened fish filet, which nearly covered the entire diameter of my plate.
It was fresh, delicious, and literally melted in my mouth. The blackened coating was tasty and well executed. My Rating: 5-Plus Stars.
SHRIMP-N-GRITS: Shrimp Sauteed with Garlic, Cajun Sausage, and Onion in a Savory Creole Sauce over Grits.
This was a lunch time special addition, one that is larger in portion size than the version listed in the "Bait" (Appetizers) section of their menu.
Once again, the shrimp were plump and juicy, and the sausage was tender and flavorful. The sauce delivered its deliciously spicy and peppery kick.
If I could make one adjustment, I would add a greater portion of grits to provide a larger bed for the shrimp and other ingredients. My Rating: 4.5 Stars.
SEARED TUNA: Served with Soy, Wasabi, and Pickled Ginger.
Listed in the "Bait" (Appetizers) section of their menu, the flavors of this one did not sing to me as sweetly as the others. Some of the tuna slices were a bit on the dry side.
Fortunately, the soy, wasabi, and pickled ginger came to the rescue to perk up their flavors. My Rating: 3.5 Stars.
BLACKENED FLOUNDER WITH TWO SIDES: From the list of sides on their menu, I chose the Rice Pilaf and Mac-N-Cheese.
This was another lunch time addition. The flounder filet was nicely blackened, tender, delicious, and came in a portion size that was just right for my lunch time appetite. The rice pilaf was piping hot and flavorful. My Rating: 5 Stars.
Their Mac-N-Cheese deserves a special mention. Made with penne pasta and a combination of cream cheese, white cheddar, and other cheeses, it delivered a cozy and delicious depth of flavor with a silky smooth texture that was beautifully balanced.
I might add that their Mac-N-Cheese came in 2nd Place in a Virginian-Pilot blind taste test back in 2009. I am giving this one a separate rating: 5 Stars.
HOMEMADE BREAD PUDDING: This is their signature dessert and comes with a delicious Bourbon Caramel Sauce.
It had been years since I had a bread pudding I really liked, and I found this one to be profoundly delicious. The sauce was beyond awesome, and I could even smell the bourbon when it was brought to my table. My Rating: 5 Stars.
A.W. Shucks recently received several votes on a Facebook food page as the best local spot for fresh oysters. Unfortunately, I am allergic to oysters and cannot vouch for them personally.
Monday night is their All You Can Eat Crab Legs night, starting at 4 pm. Wednesday night is their night for Prime Rib, which sells out fast.
One thing I would love to see is an occasional whole fish dish as a fresh catch special. But that's not their style, and I respect that. Their fresh fish specials are all served as filets.
When I crunch the food rating numbers during my recent lunch time visits, I come up with a composite rating of 4.83 stars, which rounds easily and upward to a renewal of its 5-star rating.
I will be stopping in more often as I become reacquainted with this fond old restaurant friend.