Melissa B.
Yelp
I had very high expectations, given the high reviews and amount of buzz.
When I arrived, just a few minutes after my 7:15 reservation, my friend was already waiting. She'd told me via text that they had no table ready for us yet. This happens, but with a reservation, it's annoying. Furthermore, the hostess was imprecise and said she didn't know when it'd be ready. What's the point of making a reservation then? One of the main things a restaurant should do is know how long table turnover takes at their particular location, even if not with perfect accuracy. TBH it reminded me of asking ComEd when power's back on. They can't tell you!
My friend and I sat at the bar and each had a drink, pretty annoyed already. Apparently she had waited for the bartender to acknowledge her for a while, though when he did, he was very nice. It wound up taking a half hour for our table. It was nice of the bartender to give us our glass of wine on the house! Just a shame we had to wait for 30 minutes for a table WITH a reservation.
The waiter was a bit standoffish and looked at me like I was an idiot when I asked why the restaurant week menu had the Wellington option online but not in person. He kept referring to the regular restaurant week menu, pointing to it. He ultimately told me the Wellington as an option would be honored, which was good.
The food was hardly impressive, though I wouldn't mind checking out more options. I had the restaurant week menu, and though this often involves restaurants cutting corners, it's extra appreciated when they don't. The mushroom soup I got had little flavor - some mushroom, definitely - and was insanely salty. It tasted like something you'd get in a buffet when the caterers know few people will want it anyway.
I was excited to try the beef Wellington because it's rarely offered at restaurants. This wasn't good, sadly. It was bland. The beef itself tasted weird - nothing wrong with it, per se, but it almost tasted gamey. The mushroom duxelles fared better, and the puff pastry was fine.
Their dessert was a tiny slice of coconut panna cotta. It was A-OK.
I am frustrated with this restaurant; it seems wildly overrated. I don't know how the people who work here truly care for their customers, with the notable exception of comping our wine. Waiting half an hour with a reservation and being served banquet-quality food that missed the mark will keep me trying other places before I come back.