Art P.
Yelp
DISCLAIMER: This is a review that was stuck in drafts for a few months, but my experience is still useful.
I found myself in the area, hungry, late (for COVID times) and found some amazing reviews for Afghan Bistro. After quickly skimming reviews and photos, my hopes were high. After a bit of scrambling to choose the items for an order in the quickly closing 30min window before closing, I called in to place the order.
I asked first if it was too late to order as I didn't expect them to have to go to extra effort, and they said it was no problem at all...that I could order anything on the menu. So, I first attempted to order their highly recommended special at the time (I don't recall what it was specifically), but they said they were out. Then I went with the second most recommended, and they said they were out. So, I decided to go with one of my favorites, Mantu (spicy beef dunplings).
I am very familiar with Afghan cuisine, and what I received was clearly not what I ordered...nor did I recognize what it was, so I assume it was some non-standard special dish. It was well-prepared lamb tenderloin, on a very small bed of rice and julienned carrots with meat sauce on the side and a sliver of store-bought naan (surprised that it wasn't fresh naan). I suppose it may have been a variant of Qabuli Palao, but it wasn't what I ordered...nor was it recognizably traditional Qabuli Palao - which is one my favorite dishes.
While what I received was delicious, it was not what I ordered. It was also way more expensive than expected given the portion sizes and the restaurant location...and posted menu price. I believe that my order was the last order sent to the kitchen - which they said would not be a problem - so I'm not sure how I got a completely different dish than I ordered. Other than that, the restaurant was homey and warm, and the servers were very friendly.
I doubt that I will return because I can get Afghan dishes that are just as delicious (with larger portions) closer to home for less - where I know what I am getting - but it was worth a try. For those who are on the fence, it's worth the effort as long as you make sure that your order is correct.
Since this was a last minute, to-go order, I had no recourse but to take what was given as they were closing...but I imagine the sit-down experience may be much better. I hold no ill will against them, as it was probably a simple mix up, but I couldn't give 5 stars for a wrong order.
Stay safe, and keep yelping!
P.S. - Thank you to the business for reading and responding to my review. More businesses should pay as much attention! When I am back in your area, I will take you up on your invitation to try again!