Jenna D.
Yelp
I absolutely hate giving under 3-star reviews, but I was just so incredibly disappointed with this place. A friend was SO excited it was a legit restaurant and not in a gas station, the hype was probably too much.
Key points: Covered, dog-friendly patio. First come first served. Reservations are only for large parties. They are not serving brunch, despite it being on the website (and having the arguably more enticing menu). Service was fine, if not a bit aloof.
I went in already disappointed that there is no brunch. The lunch/dinner menu is kind of heavy, which is not great before a day of wine tasting. In an effort to get something light, I ordered the Caesar salad with brisket. For $19 I was expecting something a bit more....edible? It was so salty I couldn't eat it, nor could my dining partners. It was a regular Ceasar salad, but overdressed and with white (pickled) anchovies and not regular ones. It had cojita, which is more salt, and then the brisket itself was cubed and tossed, and the meat itself was really salty as well.
The three of them had gotten sandwiches (the Reuben was standout), so I ate fries instead. The sandwiches were not hot, more like lukewarm, and they were so greasy. Yes, smoked meat, yes I get it...but even the buns were greasy. I was also kind of surprised at the color of the brisket. It was a dull grey, an while it tasted....fine? it just wasn't what I was expecting.
I know people loved this place, I know it was a bit of a quirky institution in the past, but I could not in good faith recommend going here. It's really disappointing because it's unique for Walla Walla, but sadly it's just not my jam.