James L.
Yelp
TLDR: Deserved more of a 3.5 star rating, but slightly rounding down for overall experience.
As other reviewers have noted, definitely use your GPS navigating your way to Aldo's Italian Kitchen, because this place is located in a nondescript office park, within walking distance of a Springhill Suites hotel. As my party of three were making our way through the labyrinth like parking lot, we kept saying aloud, "hmm...are we driving in the correct direction?" Trust the GPS, and turn right when you see the hotel, travel straight for another 2-3 minutes, and you'll see Aldo's up some steps on the right.
TIP: There is plenty of covered parking across from Aldo's entrance, but according the restaurant staff, if you park where signs indicate you should not, your car will get towed.
The most apropos description of Aldo's decor (both interior and exterior) is "quaint." On more temperate evenings, there is a nice patio for al fresco dining (although the only view is of a parking lot). Walking in, there is a total neighborhood favorite vibe of old fashioned Italian joint, with wooden low tables and chairs, and green tablecloths.
And that "neighborhood favorite" vibe is well earned, since even on a Tuesday at 5:45pm, the place was packed. I could tell there were lots of long time customers who knew the servers by name, and even we were roundly serenaded with smiles and "hellos" upon walking in.
The other very noticeable thing as you walk in, are the dominant aromas of garlic, butter, and olive oil. The proprietors of Aldo's understand the power of olfactory stimulation, since my appetite was super charged as soon as I sat down. The menu is a greatest hits of Italian fare such as typical appetizers of bruschetta and fried calamari. There are a selection of "gourmet individual" sized pizzas, and other well known dishes such as lasagna, chicken parm, and linguine with clams, to round out the menu.
The meal starts off with a round of complimentary garlic bread...which was delicious! Large pieces of Italian bread are given a generous shmear of butter, minced garlic + garlic powder, and then toasted to the point where there is a slight char. Eat piece has a satisfying crunch. Keep in mind, only the first round is free...then after that you need to order the appetizer size.
For our entrees, we stuck with the traditional choices of lasagna, Frutti di Mare al Bianco Vino, and the Chicken Marsala. My friend has an allergy to mollusks, so our friendly server gladly substituted those for a few extra shrimps. I tried some of her dish, and we both agreed that the kitchen had the proper cook on the proteins, especially the salmon since it wasn't dry but flavorful and moist. The lasagna was a little less successful. The sauce was overly sweet, and the meat needed some additional seasoning. The mozzarella could've also used a few more minutes in the oven, since portions of it were not melted all the way.
My chicken marsala was also "okay." When it comes to pasta dishes, one of the cardinal sins is to NOT drain the noodles properly, since you never want the pasta water to dilute the sauce or make the noodles soggy. Unfortunately, this is exactly what happened with my dish. There was a noticeable pool of pasta water which just detracted from the otherwise tasty marsala wine sauce. The chicken was cooked well, but it was under seasoned. Honestly, all of our dishes required a few shakes from the table salt...
So IMHO, Aldo's is a quaint neighborhood Italian spot, but I'm not sure I agree with the current 4.5 star rating. One star for the friendly service; One star for the portion sizes (everyone had leftovers for the next day's lunch), and one star for the value.
Dinner for three adults - only entrees and a shared bottle of wine - with tax and tip came out to roughly $130. Not too bad in today's inflationary economy.