Alexander's Steakhouse Peoria

Great steakhouse to give a try. The salad bar was unique and reminded me of the days before Covid, but had limited options. The ribeye was full of flavor and juicy and cooked perfectly (you can also grill it yourself). I do wish there were more side options. Staff was attentive to our needs, but don’t take their pens! Tablecloths reminded of something at my aunt or grandmother’s house. We sat next to a high traffic area which was less than desirable. If you are in Peoria make sure to give them a try. I will definitely comeback.

Salad bar is very good, all the usual foods on a salad bar. We had ribeye steak, bake potato, and salmon, sweet potato fries. Everything was very good!

Alexander’s Steakhouse in Peoria Illinois is an “old”fashioned steakhouse that is a weird cross between a senior citizen buffet style restaurant and a fine dining steakhouse. The wine bins had really solid wines, but the establishment still uses plastic tablecloths, paper napkins and is about as dated in appearance as you can get; the carpet was old, dirty and had years in it. The wait staff was courteous and attentive, but a request for a cocktail while acknowledged when made was forgotten about for 20 minutes until a second request was made. The food was lackluster at best: the medium rare steak was medium and dry—therefore it was tough—and $38 for an add on 6oz lobster tail was outrageous. Moreover, the steak was over seasoned, and the sautéed peppers & onions accompaniment an odd pairing with a NY Strip. All-in-all the meal wad off! Alexander’s Steakhouse in Peoria, Illinois, is an odd mix of old-school steakhouse and senior center buffet. While the wine selection was surprisingly solid, the setting felt tired—plastic tablecloths, paper napkins, and worn, dirty carpeting, dragged the experience down. Service was polite and attentive, but inconsistent. A cocktail order was acknowledged but forgotten for nearly 20 minutes until I reminded them. (The chocolate martini was the best part of my dining escaped). Unfortunately, the food didn’t redeem the experience: it was lackluster at best. My medium-rare steak arrived medium, and it was quite dry. The $38 upcharge for a small 4oz lobster tail was absurd. The steak itself was over-seasoned, and pairing it with sautéed peppers and onions felt mismatched for a NY Strip. Overall, the meal missed the mark. A steakhouse simply cannot fail to properly cook a steak!

Absolutely Amazing!! The first time we decided to cook our own steaks. It was fun, however, it was very warm near the grill. Our second visit we decided to let the chef cook our steaks. Fantastically delicious!!! The food, drinks and service are top notch!! Highly Highly Recommend!!

The best way to experience Alexander’s in my opinion is to choose a delicious cut of meat from the fridge, cook it yourself on their charcoal grill (with generous butter drippings and seasonings that they provide), and make yourself a few garlic butter pieces of Texas Toast. Pair it with their outstanding salad bar (the best in Peoria), and you’ve got a delicious complete meal! Also love their sweet potato fries, kebab, and teriyaki chicken!

Good steak house, nice atmosphere. You can also go to the grill and cook your meat.

The Best and Cheapest place to take your kids for a meal, where you can also enjoy a great meal!! $10 kids steak meal with the salad bar!! My kids been asking to go here instead of McDonald's or anywhere else since she could speak 8 yrs ago, and this is where I bring her and her friends all the time! Even the ones who only want chicken fingers. It's $10 with the salad bar. You can't get that price or quality at any fast food like you do at Alexander's! Always a great experience and meal! You can't go wrong here! Favorite is the Teriyaki Fillet, but all of their steaks are Amazing!

It's fine I guess... its a ok steakhouse its in a terrible neighborhood. I've had alot better for ALOT cheaper but the service was great. It has a weird gimmick where you can cook your own steak..? if i wanted to cook i would stay home.. I probably will never go back. Really disappointed with steak