Alfredo’s Pizza

Had to try it, because of the Office! Had a half sheet of the deep dish and it was great! The crust was perfectly crispy and the cheese was a blend of white American and mozzarella, which actually made the cheese creamy! Very unique, I've never had a pizza with cheese like that before! The service was amazing. Our server made the recommendations to us. She told us she was raised here and made a recommendation based on her local experience! After eating, we returned to our hotel and asked them for the best pizza in the area and they made the recommendation of Alfredos!

They need to include their martini menu on the tables to speed up the ordering process or at least include one online for reference. Cesar salad was good. Calamari were a bit overcooked but flavor wise, good. If you don’t like spicy, I wouldn’t recommend. Chicken Alfredo was good too. The chicken in it was visually unappealing but was very juicy and well seasoned. Service was just too slow. Was there almost 2 hours. The pomegranate Cosmo tasted mostly like pomegranate juice. The sour apple martini was good. They’re reasonably priced too

Great atmosphere, amazing food and outstanding customer service. We had long Island iced tea, steak calzone, blackened salmon and what was calamari as a appetizer.

The 2nd stop on the Pizza Trail was Alfredo's Pizza Cafe that was made famous in the TV show "Office". Kit decided to have the Old Forge White Cut, while mine were Old Forge Red Cut with Pepperoni and the other Red Cut had Sausage... Kit enjoyed here Cut and I found my Cuts to be overwhelmed by the cheese, could not really taste the sauce or the meat toppings. That could be due to a light touch of sauce and the very thin slices of the meat placed on top. When I pulled a slice off to taste by itself, it could be tasted. Possibly if the slices of meat were thicker and the sauce was thicker or more of, the individual flavors would be noticed.

We are MASSIVE the office fans and we travelled all the way from north of England to NYC, and we could not miss on a chance to try “ the good pizza”. Kevin was right it IS THE GOOD PIZZA! Vibe was very nice staff were SO lovely and the food was amazing and so reasonably priced! Thank you for being part of our bucket list experience

This pizzeria offers not only great pizza but also a fantastic atmosphere, making it a must-visit, especially for fans of "The Office." The ambiance captures the essence of the show, adding a unique touch to the dining experience. Additionally, the cleanliness and layout of the bathrooms are outstanding, providing a top-notch experience that scores a perfect 10/10. Whether you're a fan of the series or just in the mood for excellent pizza, this spot is definitely worth a visit.

Enjoyed our visit, crucial stop for office fans. Pizza was pretty good, enjoyed adding the exact toppings we wanted. Service was really good. For office fans making the pilgrimage, they sell themed items and pizza boxes matching the ones from the show. Really friendly folks!

The pan pizza's FIRST bite was fantastic. While the cheese was still hot and gooey. But before the end of the first slice it had cooled enough that the "goo" had started to congeal and honestly, it tasted like there was a layer of America cheese in the middle of the pizza, which was both gross and unwelcome. I will say that the dough/crust was outstanding. Nice and crispy and hearty. The thin round pizza was just okay. Nothing to complain about but nothing to get excited about either. We didn't mind because we mostly just came because it was featured on the office. Our server must have been having an off night. She wasn't necessarily unpleasant, but she wasn't tremendously friendly and she must have walked by us 8 times after our drinks and plates were empty and we were clearly ready to leave.