All Too Well - Loop

This place is insanely good might just have the best sandwiches I’ve ever tasted in my entire life, been here twice tried their sandwich called Tatanika which is a buffalo chicken sandwich with smoked Gouda cheese, hot honey mayo, slaw and parmesan ranch chips and omggg that sandwich is a real life movieeee!!! I’ve also tried the Sebastian and that’s a smoked turkey sandwich and that’s absolutely superb 10/10 This place is located in a food hall amongst various other restaurants and none of them taste anywhere close to as good as All Too Well. I wish they were open longer because their hours are short but damn their sandwiches are a hot commodity because they’re just a nuke of a bomb. Very well priced and staff is cool if you happen to come here and check them out then also be sure to stop by the bar right in front and give the bartender Karina a shoutout because she put me on to this hidden gem here and she’s also an absolutely amazing bartender that will ensure your having a good time while out and about!!!!! 10/10 everyone let’s go!

Awesome sandwich - I stopped by at lunch when I was craving something with a panini crunch and wanted to get out of the loop lunchtime rut (potbellies and overpriced salads on repeat). Super excited to find a spot with creative and well crafted sandwich options to add to my lunch rotation! I went for the Bombay Chulet and it was SO good. Perfect mix of savory spices / sauces and a hint of sweetness from the fig jam. Absolute perfection with the crispiest crust. The sirens call of Stracciatella on a crispy panini cannot be ignored... 10/10. It was pretty busy right around the lunch rush (12:15ish) but they moved super quickly with in person and takeout orders (waited like 5 min tops), so kudos to the staff for managing through food hall chaos. Sandwich held up well for the trek back to the office. Sure, in the abstract it is a little pricey for a sandwich (chips should prob be included IMO because they're basically air)... but the prices are ABSOLUTELY comparable with other lunch options in the Loop. Dare I say a much better value for the $$?? Its clear that the ingredients are top notch/locally sourced, and probably way more expensive than whatever is going into my $16 Big Corporate Salad Company order. Excited to come back and try more options on the menu!

A sandwich, chips, and a can of water was $25 before tip. 😨 The food was good, but not $16 per sandwich good! I would expect to see that in a full-service restaurant, but counter service? $3 for a can of water‽ And for a small bag of chips‽ I'm trying to understand where the expense is coming from. Is the owner buying their chips and drinks at full retail and then marking them up? Absurd prices for mid quality.

Tried the vegetarian sandwich. The beet pesto was so good and the bread was fantastic. Really comfortable and clean food hall, too.

Excellent sandwich. Quite big, so half came back with us. Good selection of fillings

Mouthwatering sandwich, eye-watering prices. The bombay chalet was one of the best sandwiches I’ve had tho so worth it.

Delicious gourmet sandwiches! I tried the Bombay Chulet & it was AMAZING. Would highly recommend.

Hours not correct. Not open at 11:55am Saturday. Walked over for nothing.

I love food halls and this one in Chicago has a ton of great, varied eats! I tried All Too Well (not affiliated with Taylor Swift) and I need to come back! Friendly staff and the sandwiches are made right in front of you! This charming sandwich shop is convenient to the Monroe Station on the red line and is in the heart of the loop. I ordered the Bombay Chulet, which I was told is a fan favorite. The bread was crispy, crunch, and soft. All in one bite! The turkey was juicy, the arugula was fresh, and the spicy fig jam was delectable! The textures and flavors were all there! Now, I say I must come back because of this punch card! I had a hard time choosing my sandwich here because they all looked very interesting and delightful! This isn't your typical sandwich shop! I'll be back because of the punch card, got to try them all!

I went to the food hall with coworkers and everyone ended up ordering All Too Well. Everyone got a different sandwich and loved it. The sandwiches are super unique with things like spicy fig jam, shaved lamb, and pickled raisins. The bread was extremely fresh and the perfect level of crispy on the outside but fluffy on the inside. The sandwiches are made to order and are relatively quick. The one downside is how expensive the sandwiches are. Mine ended up coming out to about $18 after tax.

We love the LP location so we were happy to see a location in the loop. The sandwiches are $16 and chips are $3 but we love the Oh Yeah! so much that it was worth coming in from the Chicago cold to enjoy a warm sandwich. Service was fast and friendly!

An already great food hall with unique options finally gets All Too Well. A delightful shop that has the greatest sandwich in the history of the universe lovingly known as ... I Make You Lamb. I will go to the mat to defend that statement. It must be experienced.