Amalfi Coastal Kitchen & Cocktails

Food was really delicious but little overpriced. fried calamari, zucchini chips (don't miss), mussels, whole bronzino, pasta all were delicious. Drinks were also good but when you charge $20 for a cocktail it shouldn't come in a plastic cup 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻 service was also great all the waiters and valet guys are working hard to make sure everyone is happy. If prices were fair and drink was served in a glass cup it would definitely be a 5⭐️

This is an amazing outdoor spot if the weather is cooperating with an unreal view of the bay. We had a party of 8 and all had a great experience. Everything from cocktails, appetizers, entrees, desert were delicious. I had their version of a spicy margarita which couldn’t have been better, and my dish was a crab pasta I was licking the plate clean. We don’t frequent the area much but if we were ever back I would make it a point to come here again. They also have valet parking which is a nice touch 👍

Beautiful restaurant!! Love all the attention to detail. The food is delicious - so many amazing choices on the menu! Can’t beat the atmosphere! Kids were free to play outside while the adults enjoyed delicious cocktails (Peach Please and Hot and Bothered were the favorites at our table!) They accommodated us with 15 people on their beautiful patio! 10/10 recommend visiting this summer!

Matt the waiter was a 10/10! He was personable and knowledgeable with the menu! Food and atmosphere.....such a vibe! We had the Tuna tacos and the octopus that was so tender! Zuchini flowers we could've done without as they lacked flavor. For our dinner entrees, my husband had the spicy shrimp pasta and I got the Lobster Francese special! Both were delicious!! We hung out afterwards to listen to a great band and it got so much busier as the night went on. We can't wait to go back. I hope that lobster franchese is on the menu again!!

Dinner at Amalfi Hamptons felt like a little escape. Coastal, calm, and quietly luxurious. We started with the Sicilian Pizza Squares, with a choice of margherita or hot honey pepperoni ($21/$24). I chose the hot honey pepperoni. The sweetness of the honey came through more than the heat, but it was still flavorful and fun. 7.5 out of 10. The Chopped Salad ($22), made with iceberg, salami, mozzarella, chickpeas, roasted red peppers, and a red wine parmesan vinaigrette, was fresh, crisp, and satisfying. 8 out of 10. The Linguini Vongole ($38) was a standout. The cockles were fresh and tender. The sauce of garlic, chili, white wine, and parsley was incredible. Rich, buttery, briny, and beautifully balanced. 8.5 out of 10. The highlight of the night was the pistachio gelato. Smooth, nutty, and not too sweet. A true 10 out of 10. I would return just for that. Service was excellent. Warm, attentive, and thoughtful without being too present. The atmosphere was beautiful. Open-air dining with coastal elegance and a view that invites you to relax. Music played at the perfect volume, noticeable but never distracting. I ended the evening in stillness, letting the view and that last bite of gelato speak for themselves.

Excellent Mediterranean fresh food ,service was great, beautiful atmosphere, inside is a little small for the amount people but comfortable, more room to seat outside. Really nice place to visit with your loved one, family, or friends . Highly recommend.

The view is stunning, and the cocktails are genuinely well-crafted — but that’s where the praise ends. The food was shockingly subpar for the price. Bland, poorly presented, and lacking the quality you’d expect from a place charging this much. It felt like an afterthought, not the main event. To make matters worse, the service was flat and disinterested. Our server barely cracked a smile and made us feel like we were inconveniencing them just by being there. When you’re paying premium prices, you’d expect at least some warmth or hospitality — not to be met with apathy. Come for a drink and the view, but eat elsewhere. This place is style over substance in the worst way.

Normally, I don't leave reviews, positive or negative, but the god-awfulness of the service here seriously shocked me, and I can't emphasize enough how bad it was. The location of this restaurant is gorgeous and very convenient. For the most part, the food was alright aside from the cold pasta and extremely strange and actually unappetizing strawberry and cream "cake". My real issue with this place lies with the service we received. Not one of their staff seemed to care about our existence within their establishment, and they showed this time and time again. I've NEVER had this happen to me, but I told the waiter we needed extra time for ordering main courses, but put the appetizer order in. He left for so long that the appetizer came out before we had a chance to order mains, leaving us with giant clunky menus at a small 2-person table. After we finished our appetizers, the waitstaff took our forks away and failed to replace them until I flagged one of them down and asked. That meant that when the main came out, it sat on the table for about 5 minutes and cooled off significantly. There was also no steak knife for the skirt steak (and the steak was NOT tender enough to go without.) We opted for tap water, but likely would've went with bottled had we known that no one would EVER refill our (teeny tiny) glasses, despite staff making constant laps around our section. I would have to say this is the worst service I have ever received at a restaurant. Many would say that "for the price" this service is god awful, but I wouldn't even expect to be treated like this at a Chili's. Also weird and unnecessary "plate sharing" charge, which I don't know if this is the norm in this area but odd nonetheless.

Grabbed lunch today with my wife and mom. Great views of the water. Great location. Heaters were situated for outdoor seating. We sampled some of the lunch specials and had a square Nona's pizza for the table. Lunch options included chicken Caesar wrap. Chicken parm BLT and chopped burger. All lunches were served with delicious skinny fries. We had espresso and cappuccino after lunch. Service was friendly and we had plenty of time to enjoy our meal. Amalfi was filling up nicely as we paid the check. I definitely recommend a visit and look forward to returning to sample dinner.

One of the best sunsets and happy hours in all of the Hamptons are both right here at Amalfi. Stopped in with my mom on a Thursday around 4 pm to take advantage of Amalfi's happy hour and to catch the sunset, and it did not disappoint. In addition to discounted cocktails, beers and wines, almost all of their appetizers are extremely discounted, plus $1.50 Peconic bay oysters. We kicked things off with a round of blackberry sours which were just the right balance of sweet and tart. The oysters we had were fresh and well sized. We moved on to the saganaki which arrives on fire. It was a cool presentation, but a little sweeter than I was expecting (that lavender honey drizzle really comes through). The fried calamari with bacon and pepperoncini was also tasty, but I did miss the traditional marinara sauce it usually comes with (though the addition of bacon and pepperoncini were a fun twist). Service was fast and friendly, Star took great care of us. We took our last round of drinks outside to enjoy the sunset before it got too chilly out. Pro tip: If you're coming for happy hour at the bar, there are only six seats which fill up quickly, so be punctual!

I wish I could give this resteraunt a billion stars! I had the pleasure of hosting my daughter's engagement party at this beautiful restaurant. The atmosphere, the service, the food, the décor, the focus on details right down to the décor themed deserts along with and above all the warmth and caring in truly making my event spectacular was a mission accomplished by the owners Sal and Nina of this fine establishment. As a detail-oriented perfectionist, I could not have asked to work with finer individuals in planning my event. They always made themselves available to discuss the details and the plan for perfect execution, along with anything else we needed, even though it was in the heat of a busy beautiful summer of their first few months of opening this business. They worked flawlessly with my vendors on perfect execution of the day. My guests are still raving about the food, the presentation as well as the service of the impeccable staff and the flow of the entire evening. One of my guests wants to now have their wedding there and I can't even keep up with how many have said they can't wait to go back for dinner. I couldn't be more pleased with the outcome of this very special life event for my family. The evening was flawless...Simply The Best! Thank you Sal and Nina, you are amazing! Marie and Nathan Goldstein

Could not have imagined a more perf, summer Italian dinner and it was a dreamy Hamptons experience. I loved everything -- from the calamari and zucchini fries appetizers to my lobster pasta. Scarfed it all down...Chef's kiss. We dined inside. Reservations are a must. It got fairly packed as it was also the second week of its opening when we went. After our dinner, we got to order drinks and dessert and take it out to the lawn which had tables and seating areas facing nice views of the Hampton bay.

Amalfi has one of the best views out of all the restaurants in Suffolk county. I went there on a Sunday evening in November and it was very quiet and peaceful. The food was delicious and the service was very good. Definitely on the pricier side but worth it.

Great atmosphere with a beautiful outdoor area on the water. Pros: view, great servers, crispy sushi rice (get this! The rice was cooked perfectly and fish was fresh!) artichoke hearts, DJ played a killer set outside Cons: hostess did not acknowledge us and as she started to, she took a phone call. Would not recommend the steak but this could get better over time. Menu could better describe the dishes. A few kinks to work out but they will get there! Classic hamptons spot on the water. We didn't have the ice cream cookie sandwich dessert but it looked great! Pro tip: it can get chilly sitting outside so take a long sleeve.

Been there twice for lunch. Food was very good, but the service was a bit amateurish for the high prices. Ordered an appetizer, 3 sandwiches and drinks (nonalcoholic) and somehow left around $150 lighter in the wallet with tip. I do want to try dinner when they reopen in the spring. I'll update the review then...

OH MY GOD. A restaurant we all wanted and needed here in Hampton bays. The ambiance is amazing, over looking the bay, fire pits, hammocks, high end picnic tables. The sunset was amazing. Inside the restaurant was decorated beautifully. Beach meets elegance at its finest. The food was outstanding. What a great mix, from Greek style apps, sushi, shell fish to chicken parm pizza and the pasta was to die for. Perfect Hamptons meal, fresh fish to fresh made pasta! Service was great, Nina at the front was so sweet and accommodating. Our waitress gave us such good recommendations. Fun restaurant for all, went with 4 children, they had a great time. We will definitely be returning!!

Very accommodating. Coastal decor with light blue accents. Staff was dressed nicely. Good looking bar and table setting. Pretty views of the bay. Appetizers were delicious. Amalfi chips were the best fried Zucchini and eggplant I have ever had. Lightly breaded and fried golden brown. Artichoke are breaded in a butter sauce. Saganaki, think greek mozzarella sticks, paired perfectly with the watermelon, honey, and toasted almonds. Delicious and a nice presentation. For dinner, I had the Crab Mafaldine, Shredded crab over mafaldine pasta in a butter cream sauce. Paired perfectly with the Pieropan Soave Classico wine. Wife had Spicy Shrimp rigatoni. Spicy enough for taste but not spicy to hurt. Daughter had a Caesar salad, chopped with good helping of dressing. Really well put together. Service was good, staff was friendly. Table was crowded with glasses and plates. Wasn't cleared as much as I would like. Overall very good. Would give it a 4.5 if I could. How the average is a 3.4, idk why. Cheers

Ambiance and Food are impeccable. Gorgeous sunsets and delicious cocktails. Best new place in all of the Hamptons. Staff was so attentive and friendly

My mom and I had a great experience getting a late dinner and drinks at Amalfi Coastal Kitchen & Cocktails tonight! I'm a big spritz girl so I had to try the Hampton Spritz and also got a Classic Aperol Spritz. We shared the Crispy Calamari Casino and Salmon & Spicy Tuna Crispy Sushi Rice for our appetizers - both were so delicious! The Skirt Steak w/ charred broccolini & truffle fries was my dinner entree, good sized portions. Stellar service, Megan and Nadine are both super sweet, it's always a pleasure seeing them! It's a great location on the water with breathtaking views. The atmosphere and decor is a 10/10, no details were spared even the plates and cups were super cute. Both outdoor & indoor seating is available.

1 Star Review because 0 Stars isn't an option. Worst. Valet Attendant. In History. This is coming from someone who used to work as a valet manager with over 8+ years in the service industry. My wife has over 10+ years in service at high-dollar country clubs. We've seen phenomenal service. We've seen subpar service. This was abysmal. We were staying at the cottages located behind Amalfi. It was the night of our wedding. When we arrived in our Uber it was around 11PM in our wedding attire, we kindly asked the valet if he could help us find the cottages (the signage isn't very clear). He pointed behind some hedges and grunted in our direction "over there". Super helpful. Our incredibly helpful Uber driver drove where he was told, and instead we found a private driveway. So we tried again, this time, the Uber Driver and I park and get out of the car to try to figure this out. The Valet attendant, still being helpful, proceeds to argue with us -- causing my wife to step out into the rain in her wedding dress to figure out what is going on. The valet proceeds to call my wife "my guy". The exact sentence was "my guy, I don't know how to explain it to you -- I'm just the valet." I can perfectly understand that he doesn't work for the cottages. I can even understand if you don't know where it is. But to be rude to people who obviously just got married is pretty wild. It was Waffle House level service from a valet attendant working in Hampton Bays in the Hamptons of NY. Just, WOW. Our Uber driver saved the night by taking charge and found it for us. If it weren't for him, we'd still be standing in the rain trying to figure it out. Again -- this review has zero to do with Amalfi as a restaurant or a company and is 100% directed towards the staff that treated my wife like she was trash on her wedding day.

The view, the food, the drinks, the atmosphere... Amalfi had it all!! Such at great time.. great dinner... amazing music today. I loved this place and can't wait to go back

0/5 stars. I made a reservation here for a party a month in advance and they called me less than 5 days prior to the reservation cancelling for a "private event". We were traveling from out of state and I made sure I had a place booked with enough notice to plan everything and they didn't have the decency to let me know when I made the reservation that their restaurant would be closed making it extremely difficult to make alternative reservations and plans.

Sal You need to step it up in the kitchen. Ordered the mozz and tomato salad which was fine. However ordered the veal chop and skirt steak which were not good. Skirt steak could not be chewed bad piece of meat and the veal chop was supposed to be milanese. However it must have been thrown in a pan with cold oil as all the breading was full of grease. Drinks were good but food needs to be better if you are going to be successful. Waitress and Z very good.

Our waitress Brianna was wonderful! So sweet! The food was excellent! And Vincent was wonderful! Great staff great food great location! Good luck! May you spend many seasons here!

Great food great ambience great service, beautiful people. We had baked clams grilled octopus calamari salmon and cocktails

Food was fantastic. We had the artichokes to start, then the swordfish puttanesca, whole branzino (filleted) and the chicken parm pizza. Swordfish won the evening, but each was excellent!

Excellent service for a party of six. We sat on the porch overlooking the beautiful sunset on the bay. Everyone had positive review of their meal. I had a very good mousaka.?, although a little dry and the portions weren't overwhelming. So I would give this restaurant a try.

Great ambiance. I have to say outside bar states prices but charges more than what is shown. Food is mediocre at best and greatly overpriced. The waiter had absolutely no personality and when it was time for the check he placed it on table and just left without a "thank you" or "have a nice night." Would t ever bother to come here again. Not worth it at all. Because of the great outdoors and the beautiful water and lounge chairs I give it 2 stars. Wouldn't recommend

Service. 2 hrs waiting for food. The management did not take any action to make our experience better and made no effort to correct the problem. I will probably not come back. Normally would not go on this and complain but feel that owners should know.

The manager was extremely rude. We waited for our food for two hours and then it came raw and instead of being apologetic the manager was plain rude with excuses. Food came out cold.

What a treat! It's the full Hamptons ambience without the price. We shared appetizers and drank cocktails for the perfect happy hour experience. I love that they take reservations. Definitely family friendly for little ones, but refined and chic enough for a bachelorette party's weekend brunch! I can see this place becoming a star for the local cuisine scene.

My husband and I had a wonderful dinner here. We ordered a bunch of appetizers so we could try everything and it was all amazing. The restaurant is beautiful and makes you feel like you're on vacation, and our server was so sweet. We will be coming back!

food was excellent...great views and totally enjoyed the sunset. However, the music on Sunday was extremely loud inappropriate for this venue. looking forward to going back with a different style of music.

My friend and I had 8pm reservations last Friday night. We didn't get seated till 9pm a whole hour later. They were seating people before us that I later reservations tho. It seemed very u organize. When we finally got seated we ordered our apps and dinner, we had about 4 different servers, the apps took forever to come out and our dinner did too plus the food was cold. No one said sorry or even put an app on the house for making us wait so long. Very unhappy with this place and will never go back.