Amico's New York Pizza

My family is originally from Long Island and we get this pizza every chance we get. Amicos is the pizza I remember from home. Headed back to NY this week and gonna see how my memory compares. Photo from a couple weeks ago with the family there at Amicos - just plain cheese is perfect - less is more. But they also have great garlic knots - free at the table.

A Slice of Life at Amico's New York Pizza - A Tale of Culinary Highs and Lows Venturing into the heart of local flavor, my wife and I followed a tip from a town insider and landed at Amico's New York Pizza. The journey through their menu proved to be a rollercoaster of flavors and experiences. From the moment we stepped in, we were whisked into a warm embrace of hospitality, greeted by a charming server who danced through our conversation in fluent Spanish, making us feel right at home. The service was swift and sweet, setting the stage for what we hoped would be a feast to remember. Our appetizer, the garlic knots, promised delight but delivered disappointment, tasting like relics of a bygone microwave era, tough on the bite and shy on flavor. However, the culinary plot thickened with the arrival of our main courses. My Chicken Parmesan was a lackluster affair, a bland ensemble hastily thrown together, leaving my taste buds in a dreary waltz of mediocrity. In stark contrast, my wife's Penne a la Vodka with Italian sausage was a scene-stealer. Each forkful was a festival of flavors, so much so that I was tempted to pull an old-fashioned heist to make her plate my own. Alas, love prevailed over greed, and I contented myself with the generous tastes she shared. The backdrop of Amico's was an ode to casual dining - a lively pizzeria vibe that invited laughter and chatter, making it a perfect gathering spot for friends escaping the daily grind. While the pricing felt ambitious against the mixed culinary performance, the hefty portions provided some solace. All told, our evening at Amico's was a symphony of hits and misses. The radiant service and vibrant atmosphere were highlights, painting over the culinary blips. Should you find yourself meandering through their menu, do aim for the Penne a la Vodka--it's a star performance not to be missed.

What a great meal! We drove from Franklin to eat at Churchill's and it was closed. Decided to go across the street to Amico's and I am glad we did. The entire family LOVED it. Not a bad entry on the table. Thanks for the great service too!

Good food, good serviced. Small place, but it stays packed. They owners are great people. If you want good New York style pizza, this is place.

Great NY style pizza! The meat cravers came with a variety and ratio of meat. Cheese was very stringy. Garlic rolls were good, I would rave specifically about them. Pizza came out in good time. It actually beat our rolls! 😂 Service was prompt and delightful.

We called in for a takeout, was told it would be an hour. When I got the to pick it up I was about 10 minutes early. The place was packed the food smell was amazing. Checked in and paid told they were running a little behind. Got the Pie in about 15 minutes brought it home, we were extremely pleased how good it was. Growing up in the northeast we are accustom to excellent pizza. This was one as well ! Definitely will be going back to try some on the dishes.

Took a ride out to Nolensville to try Amico’s New York Pizza, it’s tucked in a plaza just North of the historic district. Jan met me at the door and got me seated, they were pretty busy with the Sunday lunch crowd. When she returned she brought a basket of what I will call their “heart attack rolls” (garlic bread) that soaks in their butter/olive oil “drizzle”. The bread is really good…crispy outside and light as air inside. I ordered a medium cheese pizza (14”) and it came out pretty quick. Would I consider this pizza “NY Style”? Absolutely! The crust is solid, crispy, and folds well without cracking. For me the mozzarella was a little chewy and I did add a splash of parmesan and a sprinkle of red pepper flakes for more flavor…but overall a solid pie. My server Jan was awesome…she took great care of me.

Being from New York myself, I had high expectations, and was mostly satisfied. The salad was great, the mozzarella wedges were on point, the pizza was great, and the wait staff excellent... so why only 4 stars??? The dough for the pizza and the complimentary garlic bread was on the sweet side, which is what knocked it down a little for my personal tastes (I would have given 4.5 stars if Google allowed half stars). I did enjoy everything, but really would have absolutely loved it more if the breads didn't have that sweet undertone.

Hands down the best NYC slice around. I get my pie light sauce and well done. These guys super nice and deliver solid pie every time. Love the meatballs and the Nonna's salad. Highly recommend.

This was our first time to Amico's and weren't incredibly impressed. The venue is incredibly small and not conducive to ordering to-go. If you do order to-go, there's nowhere for you to stand or sit without being in the way. If we do come back, it'll likely be an order we call in and pick up when we know it's ready. It was also quite warm inside (it was a cooler rainy day), which made me happy that we weren't dining in. The staff were kind, but I do think their prices are a bit on the higher side. Now for the pizza. We got a meat lovers pizza with onion and olives. The onions were sort of thrown on the pizza haphazardly, so you didn't get much onion aside from one slice. The same with the ham. The sauce is pretty good and the crust is nice a crispy, but soft on the inside.

This is so overdue... My husband and I spent a year coming to Amicos Sunday nights while we built our house. Now that we live here (3 years now) we've kept it a weekly visit... it NEVER gets old. Having moved here from Manhattan, I was worried I wouldn't find a phenomenal slice or solid buffalo wings. Amicos rivals any NY pizza joint and the wings are FANTASTIC!!! Don't snooze on the cannoli either. Husband begs for the meatball sub!! Apart from the food, the service is 10/10. Consistent staff who work as a TEAM to put hot, saucy, incredible food on the table FAST! Amicos is a 10/10

We ate lunch there this afternoon. Free garlic bread they gave out before the meal was perfection, great taste and baked just right. We ordered and split a XL pizza. Sauce was a little salt heavy but still pleasant. We had more than enough to take home. I can't actually wait to try the pizza tomorrow because we have found some NY style pizzas get better after they chill. Staff were great, and ambiance is typical which is nothing bad.

I really liked the pizza we got from here, it was loaded with toppings and tasted really good. We got the meat lovers pizza and it had a few different types of meat on it (pepperoni, sausage, ham, meatball) and we added on onion and olives. They definitely didn't skimp on any of the toppings and the big New York style slices had me full after two. It was a busy night and the staff was cranking out pizzas as fast as they could, but there's nowhere to stand/sit for takeout orders making it an uncomfortable experience. Next time we come in, we'll have to sit down because it looked like it would be an enjoyable experience.

Pizza is good, BUT expensive!! Be careful with "build your own".... Toppings are extremely expensive.... $3.50 EACH, regardless of pizza size.... So if you are ordering a 14" medium, you are getting screwed.

Food was ok They charge a 20% auto tip on tables of 5 or more, not cool Manager has severe anger issues, she doesn't take negative comments very well, likes to insult people, bad business, won't be back

We love amicos! This is our go to pizza spot in Nolensville. But there's not just great pizza, you have to try their grilled chicken Caesar salad and the vodka pasta with chicken. Both are so delicious. When you dine in, they also bring you complimentary savory garlic rolls with olive oil. They are my favorite!

It just occurred to me that, after all these years, I've never written a review for Amicos. We've been dining here for many years, and it never disappoints. Their Italian Stromboli is exceptional and has become our go-to favorite. While we've sampled various items from their diverse menu and found them all to be delicious, we always find ourselves returning to that Stromboli. The consistency in flavor and quality keeps us coming back time and time again. If you're looking for a place that delivers great food and an outstanding experience, Amicos is the place to be.

My husband and I just moved to the area and we wanted to try a new spot our first weekend here. All I have to say is we will 100% be back. The food, service, and atmosphere was just what we were looking for. Highly recommend!!! Caesar salad and pepperoni pizza were 12/10

This place is amazing! I'm from South Florida and I haven't found many restaurants in Middle TN that remind me of home but this one does! They gave us complimentary garlic knots which were spot in. Then we started with medium wings and they were the best I've had in a long time! We ate them so quickly that I forgot to snap a photo but I'd highly recommend them! We also ordered a large pizza, half cheese and half Hawaiian. It was fantastic! Cooked perfectly and so flavorful! Everyone was super friendly and our server Libby was awesome! The ambiance is calm and the staff all seem to work together well. The manager was bussing tables because the bus boy had called out. Such great team work! Come here now. Don't even think twice! Delicious!

I just got a pizza taste great but will not be coming back large pizza with two toppings for $30. Sorry I'm out. Thanks.

This is a review of a New York style pizza place from a native New Yorker. Not an "I'm from upstate" New Yorker; I'm from the City. I moved to middle TN in 2007. Since that time there have been more than a few pizza joints open that claim to be "NY Style". Some of them better than others, but none currently open as good as Amico's! They have been our family's go-to for the better part of a decade. You can't go wrong with a to-go order of pizza, pasta, or a sub. Dining in is reminiscent of the "pizza parlors" of my youth; it's a casual atmosphere, suitable for families and kids. Service is friendly, food comes quickly, and the bill is very wallet friendly. Highly recommended for NY style pizza, pasta, and subs in the "greater Nolo area" :-)

Fast service. I ordered for pickup and the food was ready in 15 minutes. However, the Pizza Caprese was soggy, presumably from the diced tomatoes. I was hoping for a more crisp and thin NY style pizza. The Italian sub was an okay sandwich, but I wish there was more meat.

Excellent pizza! Had the fresh tomato sauce pizza. Slices of mozzarella on bottom with sauce on top. The rolls they give you are sublime. Salads were tasty. Great casual neighborhood spot for great food.

What can improve at this place first the quality second the cost it is absolutely mid range. Pizza company is way, way to overpriced especially for the quality and amount of food you get. The sad thing about yelp. Is that most people on here think they know what they're talking about and they have actually no clue. If you wanna compare this pizza place to a standard like Domino's or Pizza Hut then yes I would give it above average, but if you're going to compare it to legitimate pizza parlors, for example anywhere in the Northeast New York, Connecticut, New Jersey, Massachusetts then you're looking at maybe a three or four out of 10. And to anyone who "" claims "they're from New York City or one of the boroughs and this restaurant is as good as those pizza places in the northeast then you are an absolute idiot or total trash and above all ignorant.

This is the best carry out pizza around Brentwood and Nolensville. The crust is crispy but not cardboard and the flavors are spot on. We got the large meat lovers and the cheesy crusty pizza and they were perfect.

Great place for pizza, a calzone and other Italian dishes! I was delivering a vehicle to a customer nearby and they invited me to join them for dinner. I ordered a Calzone and got all the ingredients of the Italian Stromboli. I've had my share of calzones, but this one was amazingly delicious! It was massive too! I also had some of their tasty sweet tea, which was one of the best I've tasted in Middle Tennessee. The ambiance is casual and good for groups. They were slammed with business, which may be typical for a Friday night, but that didn't slow down the service. I'll definitely be back, next time I'm in the area.

Busy place. Fast service. Good value. We ate outside. Food was flavorful and delicious. Pepperoni had some zip. Will be back to try other items.

When we went it was super busy (on a Thursday!) but they're pizza was good, and I loved the salad I ordered.

Amico's is a can't-miss restaurant in Nolensville. When I walked into the small pizza parlor for the first time, I had low expectations for pizza that claimed to be "NY Style". Now I'm on my 15th visit. The food was phenomenal. The pizza is unique from other locations within Nolensville, and everything seems to be in balance. The sauce; the cheese; the toppings; all in perfect equilibrium. The sandwiches are great, the pizza is amazing, and the service is very fast. I recommend Amico's to anybody who's tired of establishments trying to catch your eye with mediocre New York style pizza. Amico's will exceed your expectations.

Best ny styled pizza I've found in or around Nashville, the caprese pizza was a surprisingly delicious and unique pie... the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars was the ravioli was sub par.

Took a ride out to Nolensville to try Amico's New York Pizza, it's tucked in a plaza just North of the historic district. Jan met me at the door and got me seated, they were pretty busy with the Sunday lunch crowd. When she returned she brought a basket of what I will call their "heart attack rolls" (garlic bread) that soaks in their butter/olive oil "drizzle". The bread is really good...crispy outside and light as air inside. I ordered a medium cheese pizza (14") and it came out pretty quick. Would I consider this pizza "NY Style"? Absolutely! The crust is solid, crispy, and folds well without cracking. For me the mozzarella was a little chewy and I did add a splash of parmesan and a sprinkle of red pepper flakes for more flavor...but overall a solid pie. My server Jan was awesome...she took great care of me.

Our favorite place to go after church. We love the Nonna's salad and their pepperoni pizza.

Love this place, meatball parm is great, pizzas are great. Staff is great. Prices. Are ok.

I've been to Amico's a number of times. The prices keep going up food is the same. They change the calamari. Sometimes it's good sometimes it's not over priced for what they have services OK management is OK I wouldn't go back no more found too many other good places.

Great local restaurant with exceptional service. This is our family's go-to place. Pizza, calzones and pasta cooked to perfection. You can't go wrong.

Fresh tomato sauce pizza is delicious! Closest thing to NYC pizza around town. Service is outstanding as well - quick, friendly and outstanding. Love eating in the restaurant - great atmosphere with a good amount of sitting.

My son found this place on yelp. Glad we tried it. Service was fast and friendly. Mozzarella wedges were good and came out fast. Then the Fresh Tomato Sauce Pizza came out fast and was very good. Will definitely stop here again.

Use to be a great place, however they are just not as good as they use to be, and they are rude when you call them. Multiple times I called for delivery and they took over two hours. The last time they cursed us out when we asked a refund when they took over two & half hours.

We recently moved to Tennessee and one the search for GREAT food. Tucked away in Nolensville, we discútenos delicious gem. My husband ordered the meatball sandwich (ginormous), made with fresh baked French bread that was light and airy in the outside, perfectly crisp on the outside. I ordered eggplant Parmesan roll, that came with a side of fresher baked garlic rolls, doused with olive oil, minced garlic, and sprinkled with parsley. It also came with a side of spaghetti, made with an amazing marinara, made with San Marzo tomatoes, filled with a generous amount of ricotta cheese. Everything was beautifully seasoned and the generous portions make this place my new fave!!! P.S. the service... on point! Attentive and very informative.

My husband and I are shamelessly frequent patrons of Amicos. I lived In NYC for 7 years and they are indeed NY quality. They have the best spaghetti with meat sauce around. Their chicken Marsala is pretty excellent too, though I pretty much get their spaghetti every. Single. Time. The only thing that comes slightly close to their sauce is Rao's but I would take Amicos over Raos any day. My husband always gets their Fresh tomato sauce pizza, and it is also one of my favorites. Their bruschetta is on-point as well as their cannolis. I haven't tried much else off of the menu, because I love the above so much that it's hard to pick anything else. 100% NYC Italian authentic in TN.

Best pizza in Nolensville! The staff and pizza are perfect every time. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu!

There isn't anything not to like about this place. Service was A+, meatballs were pretty solid, salsa are enough trouble share, and the pizza is some of the best in Nashville. Really, just a solid place to take a family for lunch or dinner. If I had to give them one complaint... I wish more restaurants used/provided filtered water for their customers meals. The water source, has a pretty high chlorine smell//taste. Outside of that, great place.

Just moved to town and we're hoping to find a good local pizza place - and we were definitely happy with Amico's! The pizza was excellent. Great crust. We ordered ours well done, we like the pizza crispy. Also ordered a pepperoni Stromboli, which was phenomenal. People were very nice and food came quick. We ordered ours take out, and saw there was a cool little dine-in spot in the restaurant as well. Great location and nice setting. Will definitely be back.

We love this local Italian place. We've been several times and love it. My husband is from New Jersey and this is the only local pizza he will eat and actually enjoy. Parking is free outside in the lot. There are coupons available in mailers from time to time. Enjoy!

This is one of those 'I've been wanting to try this place' places. . Finally had an opportunity so we ordered some subs. It was hard to pass on the pizza but that will come next time. Oh, they sell by the slice too. Anyway, back to the story at hand. We called the order in and with great relief the person on the other end was polite and courteous (not something that happens all of the time). We placed an order for an Italian and Philly cheesesteak. A short time later we showed up and the subs were ready. Back home... I opened my box and was in shock. What a sub. Then I tried it. Plenty of meat and great bread. The Philly looked sweet as well. My son was good enough to let me try it. I'm glad he did. Both subs were delicious and will be in my future at some point. Did I mention the bread was great.

Food is consistently good...quick service & always fully staffed. Lunch specials are great & affordable.

Everything we ordered was very good! Would definitely eat here again. Pizza was tasty and Stromboli was delicious.

Awesome. A little pricey though. But best pizza and wings around Still need to make wings crispier though

First off I need to say our sever was very nice. I do want to make that clear. The atmosphere outside was decent. The outside seating area is on the sidewalk so any shoppers from the other stores walk right past you but the air was nice out last night so it didn't bother me. Food: I ordered water to drink and when i got it the water tasted like metal. It was not exactly drinkable so i then ordered tea. It also tasted like metal but not as much. I ordered Chicken Piccata and when the chicken came it was a decent portion size but was very much lacking in flavor. The only flavor i could taste was the slight lemon flavor from the sauce. It wasn't really worth the $20. The chicken came with a side of spaghetti. The noodles did not feel completely cooked. They were slightly crunchy and the sauce had very little flavor. The potion size was decent and not too little and not too much but was certainly not worth the $20 Lastly, the the rolls/bread that came out was far too hard and only tasted like garlic. it was so over powering that i could still taste the garlic the next day and I brushed my teeth, flossed and used mouth wash twice. I feel like I might be having garlic come out of my pours.

Decided to try a new Pizza place and we were not disappointed. It was ready quick and cooked just right! We look forward to trying different things off the menu also!

Extremely disappointing. We have been patronizing Amico's for over 3 years. They continue to raise their prices, have added a "convenience fee" for using a credit cards and as of yesterday, had the audacity to add an 18% gratuity to our bill(we are a family of 5). When we asked about the tip, the owner rudely told us all restaurants add gratuity to parties of 5. She was rude and dismissive of our complaint, saying, this is their policy. Overall, poor management, poor atmosphere. Would not recommend this place. Will happily enjoy Italian food at one of the many other options nearby.

Feeling like pizza on a Saturday night, so I recommended we try this spot to my husband. He loooooves him some pizza so loves trying new places. I got the meatball app and when we got home and I opened the package, I was so sad. Two tiny meatballs for $5? They tasted fine, but I would never order that again for the price, that's for sure. The pizza was good, a solid NY style slice. We live in Franklin and although the pizza was tasty, decided the drive was a little too far to choose this again over our favorite local spot.

Listen, I'm from NJ, we have amazing pizza so I'm picky. When I tell you this is great NY style pizza

This is perhaps the best Italian restaurant in the area We have had the Stromboli pizza pasta and the meatball sub is fantastic We take family from out out of town here all the time and they all love it Highly recommend this place

Great service!!!! They are our go to pizza and Italian spot. Real New Yorkers there!!! Great calzones! Italian salad. Really fast service too.

We have been trying different restaurants in Nolensville recently after I work there. We were wanting pizza so decided to try Amico's New York pizza. We went for lunch. We like thin crust pizza so we ordered the 18 inch pizza with a combination of toppings. Service was quick and polite and the restaurant was clean. When the pizza came out it looked delicious the slices were large. We enjoyed the pizza so much that we returned a few days later to try their pasta and sandwiches it was later in the day but we were greeted quickly and service again was quick and polite. We enjoyed the spaghetti and the Italian sandwich. Top rate.

Best pizza ever! Highly impressed. Great taste and ready in a timely manner. Highly reccomend.