Nicole M.
Yelp
I can see why people like Amy's ice cream so much! I came here for the first time last night with some friends that live out of town. We all really enjoyed the ice cream and shakes, there are so many options to choose from, many toppings, and they are very vegan friendly too, super inclusive.
Overall, ice cream, we loved! It was a lot more on the sweeter side. For me, I got the strawberry ice cream mixed together with the sweet cream one and it was super delicious, and with a waffle bowl. It was more than I had expected it to be, but a good problem to have if you're a sweet tooth like me
I was pretty disappointed in the waffle bowl. It was way too sweet and didn't taste good. I actually didn't eat it. It was kind of stale and slightly bendy (not because of the ice cream though), it tasted like an artificial a slightly underdone sugar cookie...
They open quite late! With how popular this place is, it makes sense to have more seating but there weren't a tone of places to sit, by the looks of it. We did sit outside, which wasn't terrible but periodically had some bad sewage smell.
However, ambiance was great, the staff were pretty great and helpful too! They were friendly and guided my friends and I well. My friends also really really enjoyed their ice creams and shakes too. Would recommend to people! Although, may not be my go-to first choice.