Gina Henderson-Rogers
Google
Added to Google Maps since they weren't on here in spite of having been open for decades.
This is a classic American family-owned hardware store. Helpful and conveniently located. They have paint, door and window hardware, plumbing and tiling supplies, more nuts and bolts than you can shake a wrench at, historic home specific products, (and much more) and additionally have a small engine repairperson on staff. I've also heard they'll be reopening their plant nursery soon!
Instead of shopping the big box stores, consider paying these folks (your neighbors!) a visit for your next home improvement project.