Dani Robinson
Google
Writing this review before I forget because this place deserves it!
For what this restaurant sets out to be, it completely delivers and earns a five stars in its category. Honestly, I almost skipped it after reading Reddit comments criticizing food on “The Hill” for not being “authentic Italian.” I'm from Chicago, where there's no shortage of good restaurants, and I often let that kind of chatter sway me.
But here’s the thing: I wasn’t looking for authentic Italian. I wanted homemade, cozy, Italian-American — and Anthonino’s absolutely delivered on every level. Yes, this kind of food has been around for a long time. There’s a reason for that…
The caprese was genuinely one of the best I’ve ever had. The tomatoes were fresh, and the balsamic was delightful. I almost went for my usual favorite, spaghetti and meatballs, but the server recommended the tortellini with vodka sauce, and I’m glad I listened. It was excellent — albeit very rich.
If I could give 4.5 stars, I would, only because the tortellini came out literally three minutes after the caprese — not much of a pause to allow me to enjoy my app. But again, this place isn’t advertising a fine dining experience, and the prices reflect that. Plus, the pasta was homemade, so how can I really complain?
To top it off, I took the tiramisu to go and — OMG — it was so good.
I had three Negronis (don’t judge!), a starter, and a main course — all for around $75. That’s a steal in my opinion. So, if you’re looking for a friendly, low-key vibe with solid, satisfying food, definitely give this place a try.
If I’m ever back in St. Louis, I’ll be back for sure. Thanks for a great meal!