W C.
Yelp
Our mission to try toasted ravioli led us to Anthonino's, where we also thought that we were getting St. Louis-style pizza, but it actually turned out to be just pizza. In whichever case, we had a great experience here, mostly due to the fact that we ended up chatting for a while with these two very nice local women while we were all waiting for our respective tables. We learned a lot about the city from them! BTW you can get drinks at the bar while you wait; they had a nice version of an aperol spritz and there's a lager collaboration with Urban Chestnut Brewing Company.
We had already picked out our dishes while we were waiting and started with the crispy artichokes, toasted ravioli, and kale caesar salad. Everything was pretty good! We especially appreciated the artichokes because they were the bottoms, so even if they were not fresh (which they probably weren't), it was a nice switch from the hearts. They were cooked well and came with an interesting lemony sauce. The ravioli were...definitely different! It's kind of like eating a dry meat-filled cracker, so they've definitely got a crisp to them. We really did not enjoy the red sauce they were served with because it was quite metallic-tasting. The kale caesar was OK but it had too many breadcrumbs and too much dressing.
As we get to the pizza portion of the evening, we no have to mention our waiter, whose ultimate goal seemed to be to engage our table as little as possible. After "the Sicilian" pizza came out and he graced us with a "how is everything?", we mentioned that the pizza was really greasy (because it was), and he started soliloquizing how it was really "salt water" from the pepperoni and not oil (which it empirically was), that they learned about during their training, etc., etc. Lolzzzz! Well, never hear that one before. No matter, it was still really good.
Bottom line, this was the typical "Hill" St. Louis experience that we were looking for, and it delivered. Four stars, but really wondering what our thoughts would be had we not met those wonderful folks before the meal who put us in such good spirits. It's true what they say about Midwesteners!