Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Pizza restaurant · Middlesex County

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Pizza restaurant · Middlesex County

1

219 N Main St Suit A-104, Natick, MA 01760

Photos

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings by null

Highlights

This modern spot in Natick serves up coal-fired pizzas, tasty wings, and hearty Italian dishes in a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder

219 N Main St Suit A-104, Natick, MA 01760 Get directions

acfp.com
@anthonyscoalfiredpizza

$20–30 · Menu

Information

Static Map

219 N Main St Suit A-104, Natick, MA 01760 Get directions

+1 774 290 5106
acfp.com
@anthonyscoalfiredpizza

$20–30 · Menu

Features

wifi
Tap to pay
reservations
payment credit card
outdoor seating

Last updated

Jul 13, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"is now open in Natick with an open kitchen and a menu of, well, coal-fired pizzas. In addition to pizza, the restaurant serves chicken wings, salads, meatballs, and more. Anthony's operates seven days a week for lunch and dinner, from 11:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and from 11:30 a.m. to 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday." - Dana Hatic

ReelHouse Opens in Quincy’s Marina Bay - Eater Boston
View Postcard for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Arrecis

Google
I wanted to really give this place the benefit of the doubt. Waiter was really nice and attentive. Environment was nice Food was terrible. Pizza didn’t have tomatoes sauce evenly distributed. Cheese was burnt mostly as you can see in picture. Honestly pizza didn’t have much flavor. Croutons on Caesar salad were stale. I would not go back.

Beaner 8127

Google
Amazing! Best pizza in Natick! Service is also the most friendly of any restaurant in town. The server offered my child a ball of pizza dough to play with before the food came out and they loved it! All they’ve been talking about now is how they want to go back and make pizzas! Meatballs and wings are outstanding as well. 100% will be going back.

Will Jaynes

Google
Great new place for lunch or dinner! Clean and classy decor and the staff makes you feel right at home. Philly Steak n' Cheese pizza is my favorite here. Everyone definitely has to try their wings as well. I will definitely be back, and would suggest this place to all family and friends.

Paul J. Manning

Google
What a great spot right nearby. The food is always really good and their meatballs are really something. Our server Kay was very nice and incredibly helpful. I can highly recommend Anthony’s.

Susan Santone

Google
First, I have to say that I have been to this restaurant before, but it was quite a while ago. The food was always great. What happened? We started out with a cup of pasta fagoli soup. It was barely warm and not very flavorful. And it had huge chunks of parsley as a garnish mixed in with a soup. That was so unnecessary. It was not worth $6 for a cup of soup. They gave us teaspoons to eat the soup. When we asked for soup spoons, the waitress told us that all of the soup spoons were dirty because no one had done the dishes. My friend got a starter order of the meatballs. She said they were OK. But more garnish. A wilted bunch of something or other sitting on the side of the meatballs, which were absolutely drowned in red sauce. I got a side starter of shrimp. They were okay; well cooked. But very small. You would think that an order like that would be at least a large shrimp and not small ones. Again with the garnish. A big blob of parsley. Lots of their bread which did not have very much flavor. And the sauce the shrimp was in was separating into an oily mess. So sad for a good restaurant to go so bad.

Tamera Thatcher

Google
I can’t say enough about how amazing Anthony’s is. For just how good the food and drinks are, this place should be packed every night. Nick the bartender made me the best espresso martini I’ve ever had. It had some tiramisu liqueur in it- my pizza was 10/10 as Anthony’s always is, and the manager Kristine was at the front of the restaurant as soon as I came in and greeted me with a warm welcome in the beginning. I left feeling like I’m friends with everyone who works here AND the customers too. 1000/10 would recommend town of Natick people!!!

S Bobby Gerjarusak

Google
Hi I rarely gave below a 4, and I hope to revisit again to reevaluate. We usually check before we go to a new place so we don't usually go to a place below a 4. Unfortunately our order was 10 min late (not big deal) and the pizza was badly burnt at the edges. It would have been at least a 4, but I had to reluctantly give this place a 3.

Nick DeRoo

Google
A 25 dollar margarita pizza that is very underwhelming. Crust is good but not enough cheese, not enough sauce and this is all the basil we got on the side, wilted not fresh.

David K.

Yelp
OK, we went back a second time, and we ordered totally different food. The chicken Coalfired sandwich was insane, beautiful and delicious, look at that picture! The cauliflower pizza was wonderful. What a beautiful work of art. The arugula salad was, also gorgeous and delicious, very nice for the summer. Brought a ton of food home, had delicious margaritas, great service from Scotty, I really can't say enough. Very generous, and we will definitely be back, most likely on Wednesday or Saturday! Thanks guys

Robert E.

Yelp
Every time I've been to this location, I have never been disappointed. The coal-fired pizza, atmosphere, and service are outstanding (10/10). It makes you feel like you're back at home or sitting on the patio waiting for your favorite pizza, enjoying your adult beverage.

D W.

Yelp
My god...support your restaurant with staffing. We tried to have dinner there tonight. Poor guy behind the bar is also waiting tables and attempting to host. Impossible task. WTF. You will go out of business, So Wake up. Pizza looked great. Cooks were busy filling to go orders. Unfortunately a lot of tables of customers sat empty hoping to eventually get food. Not staff's fault. Who is managing this business?. Its a saturday and people are walking away because we cant even submit a drink order. Im not even sure the very nice woman who sat us could speak much English. Give the guy behind the bar a raise and some help. Or stop wasting their efforts...they cannot keep up with your lack of support.

Sheila R.

Yelp
Me and my bestie cane for lunch Server was nice . Garlic knots are awesome the margaritas pizza was ok but the veggie pizza was good. Would come back

Michelle F.

Yelp
ANNNNNNNDDDD tonight you lost me forever. Whoever the woman is that tends bar should NOT be in customer service. What a shame. I really liked your pizza. Let me start by saying that I have been in customer service my whole life. I have NEVER been treated so rudely by restaurant staff EVER. In a nutshell, last time I was in she all but refused to wait on me. Although my take out order was wrong and I received no apology I tipped20 %.... as I always do. I went in tonight. She refused to wait on me at the bar and told me to go the take out window. She said she refused to wait on me. I know that you do not give a shit about me because you have a warm body to occupy that shift and really....what I say does not matter. Just know that I have owned a business in Metro West Boston for 23 years and people listen to me.

Nellie P.

Yelp
Just attempted to eat a 22$ Caprese pizza. Had to be the WORST pizza ever made. Note: we have had really good pizzas from this location previously. This failure was smothered in globs and globs of totally tasteless mozzarella accompanied by tasteless tomatoes. It's summer guys!!! Can't find a ripe tomato? Save yourself disappointment and go somewhere that knows how to cook. Even a pizza from the frozen food section at your grocery store would be better.

Len C.

Yelp
Anthony's lost me as a loyal customer last night. I won't be back. First, the pizza is excellent. I'll miss it. But the service is horrendous. I went to pick up takeout, so I sat to order a beer. It took 15 minutes to get the server to even look toward me. I understand they are understaffed, so I was nothing but nice when I finally waved her down (literally with both hands gesticulating over my head.) I tell her I'd like to immediately cash out because I'm waiting for take out. The takeout comes to the bar within 3 minutes. All good. I then wait 15 more minutes to cash out. It was frustrating that two servers came behind the bar numerous times but never once looked left or right as both seemed challenged to work the computer. Again, I get it. They're in the weeds. I've been a server. Anyway, again after all this time I was forced to call them over several times, which I feel is kinda rude so I would rather have not done it. But it was clear I wasn't getting out of there without calling to them. And remember, I said when I got the beer, I wanted to pay for it immediately. Ok, so at this point, the second guy comes over and gives me the bill. Great. My plan was to sign it and give a tip. I understand is it's not their fault that they're understaffed. Here's were it goes sideways. Instead of just giving me the bill, and saying nothing, or even something like "sorry for the wait, we're understaffed," the guy insinuates that it's my fault that he ignored me because I was on the phone. I get it but I put that phone away into my pocket several times during the call to make sure if they looked at me they would come over. I kept eye contact on these guys constantly because I wanted to get out of there. They never looked. Not once. So to insinuate that somehow, as he put it, he was respecting my privacy, is just not true. And I remind you in this review and I was ready to give a tip even with the wait. As he angrily plops the bill in front of me, and reminds me that I shouldn't be talking on the phone, he walks away without leaving a pen. At this point, I haven't said anything to him. I simply say that I need a pen. Clearly he heard the frustration in my voice. Instead of giving me one, he says you don't need to sign it you can just go. Now I'm mad. I flipped the paper in the air over the bar, which I admit, was an asshole move and apologize for that. But he just hit a nerve that he could ignore someone and then tell them it was in my best interest. Please. I can't believe this guy had the nerve to blame this on me when total time elapsed from the time I walked in and sat down to this low point was more than 1/2 hour The woman says you don't need to do that sir, which again I admit, she's right. And then they both go into the most condescending "Have a nice night" routine like they are taking the high road. It took all my self control to not lay into them at that point time. I told him to get their act (actually another word that stays with an S and rhymes with "it") together, which was about as strong as I got. It wasn't a scene or anything. It was just so annoying to be on the receiving end of horrible service and then have these to give me that condescending routine. But wait it gets better. As I'm leaving, I'm steaming so I say, "can I talk to a manager?" The woman at the front was just a kid so I wasn't going to get into it with her. She doesn't deserve it. But one of the guys behind her, I don't know if he was a cook or what, says in one breath, "the manager is not in. have a nice night." Total blow off. And then the whole crew starts repeating "have a nice night, sir," as I'm walking out the door, which, in writing, I admit, doesn't sound bad, but they were chirping me, plain and simple. And why? Because I couldn't get anyone to pay attention to me to pay my bill. I guess my mistake was not being a forceful jerk to begin with, instead of trying to respect the fact that they were understaffed So there you have it. I'm not saying you shouldn't go there. I'm not saying this was some kind of a epic fail. It was just the total blow off and the acting like this whole thing was my fault that turned me off completely. To management, I say this: you and I know that the people who are working in a restaurant mostly don't care if they lose business. It's human nature. But I thought you'd like to know why I won't be back. There's plenty of places to get good pizza in this area . And I'm not looking to be treated like a king, I just don't want to be treated like a fool. Btw, the slow service at the bar is an ongoing issue. The attitude this time was the difference.

Frank L.

Yelp
I have been to several ACF pizza places over years and have been happy. This place was not only filthy, there were flies all over the bar top and food. The food was poorly made and the both pizzas were raw. The appear to be completely understaffed and miss managed. Do not go!!!

Brenda S.

Yelp
Nice place - really cold in there - i would give the Margarita pizza a 3.5 but the veggie pizza and garlic knots were delish!!! Only 1 waiter for bar and all tables but he tried his best!!! We would come back!!

Mark Q.

Yelp
I haven't had a chance to eat in yet but the take out is good. The pizzas are great and the wings are solid. I wish they had more choices for both.

Elaine A.

Yelp
I want to offer this review, at least in part to counter some of the recent 1-star reviews this place has received due to complaints about service. I've dined at this clean, friendly, and easygoing restaurant three times in the last six months, most recently on New Year's Eve and ALWAYS have had great service. On our most recent visit, we were greeted cheerfully, seated right away, and were given ice water and menus promptly. Our server was cheerful, attentive, and friendly, including with our grandkids, who were given crayons, activity placemats, and pizza dough to play with. Our server had two other large groups to take care of at the same time (one with 8 diners, and the other 14) and she handled us all like a pro. The pizza and wings were perfectly made and delicious as always, and the cannoli desserts were very tasty (although a bit small in size, but that is on the company that runs all the Anthony's restaurants, as I believe it, not each local outlet, supplies the desserts and possibly other ingredients). The kids' drinks came with straws and lids to reduce spilling, which was very appreciated. The guys making pizzas are always friendly to the kids, who like to climb up on the nearby stools to watch with varying degrees of fascination while their and others' pizzas get made. The restrooms are spacious and super clean. Of course this restaurant might be a bit short-staffed at times, but so is just about every restaurant these days. A bit of patience and a smile go a long way at this place, at most other restaurants, and in the world at-large. Oh, and here's a pro tip: Large cheese pizzas are only $10 each on Wednesdays (all day). Dine in only. Anthony's is our go-to pizza place in Natick. We will definitely be back.

David W.

Yelp
Dirty barstools, nasty counter and filthy manners. We left disgusted. Avoid. Poor service and lack of professionalism, it wasn't even busy - and now know why. 'Bartender' had long curly hair, didn't stay long enough to catch her name. Train your staff or close.

Shannon R.

Yelp
Bartender was very rude and had an attitude. It felt like she didn't want to be there. For example she slammed our drinks down. This was June 18th 2022. We were going to order food but her attitude was so bad that we left. Also, she was yelling at the new bartender trainee and wasn't coaching correctly. It seems like a toxic work environment at the bar. Mind you it wasn't even crowded.

Genevieve B.

Yelp
Some of the best pizza i've had in the area. the crust is on the thicker end, especially for coal fired pizza. i was expecting more of a new haven style, but it was thicker and one or two slices will definitely fill the average person. the under-carry was top notch and flavors of the cheese and sauce were amazing. The wings also fell off the bone and the buffalo flavor has a bit of spice but nothing that has you wishing you had a glass of milk. definitely recommend and pizzas are $10 on wednesdays (plus toppings)!

Anna F.

Yelp
We had a great delivery from here. Make your own with pepperoni, Italian sausage (with anis), sweet peppers, and long spicy peppers. The long peppers on top were amazing- blistered and spicy. The flavors were so good, and you could tell they were using quality ingredients.

Samantha T.

Yelp
I love Anthony's, and go to the one in Westwood whenever I get the chance. We came by the Natick location because we were doing errands close by. The welcome was warm (as were the farewells), and the pizza was exactly as we expected (love it). My cocktail was OK, not great. My husband ordered a beer that was on the board, but they brought him something else and just said, "Oh we don't have that one. The board is outdated." They didn't offer to swap it out or anything. But what really turned me off and will make me NEVER go back is that the restaurant was dirty. We were seated at a corner table and there was some trim about an inch wide that ran the length of the wall next to and behind us. It was COVERED with dust. Not just a day or two's worth. It hadn't been wiped down in a long while. Totally disgusting, especially in a restaurant. That's the sort of thing that's so easy to get right, but it would appear that the management of this location, while very friendly, is quite lazy.

Steve A.

Yelp
The service here is so bad. I'll never be back. Waited 40 minutes and they still hadn't even put in one of our 2 pizzas. They forgot. Then when I asked for my money back they seem liked thy didn't know what to do. I asked for a manager and they didn't have one. WTF? I explained I had to leave and couldn't wait any longer. Nothing done. I raised hell and told them to keep the money I paid for the pizzas. Which they gladly did. No apologies. It was my fault. How did we treat you wrong they said? Are you serious. Clueless. I was a district manager of 45 retail stores in this would've have never happened under my watch. Really deplorable. The management responses with nice flowery responses that don't mean anything because they don't do anything about it.

Kian N.

Yelp
Best in class customer service at this location. the General Manager Bryan was just about to close shop this Wednesday but knew still opened his doors to serve me some hot wings. You can tell the staff is customer focused and I will certainly be back with friends after the great experience I had. Thanks again Bryan!

Tom M.

Yelp
If I could give them a zero I would. One of the worst experience I've ever had. I thought I would order a sandwich online ,pick it up and eat it watching the Patriots game. So I went there to pick it up. It wasn't ready which was fine. As I was sitting there waiting for it. , I noticed a women manager having an argument with a guy who was making the pizzas. He got angry and threw the pizza shovel on the floor and walked away. He came back and put it back up on the counter without even cleaning it after it has been on the dirty floor, I spoke to the woman who may have been the manager and told her what happened and she just shrugged it off. Are you kidding me? What about all the germs it could've picked up from being on the floor. It's just disgusting.Because of her attitude I asked for my money refunded .She said she would have to do it online and will do it later. I said I would like to do it now ..,she refused to. I said I would like her to do it now again and she basically told me to leave several times dismissing me with a wave of her hand . Is this how you treat your customer who had a legitimate complaint? I have never had such bad customer service in my life ... someone needs to train them about customer service or fire them.

Daniel A.

Yelp
I enjoyed it a lot. I don't get the negative reviews on the service. As a NY transplant it's the only comparable traditional pie in Natick compared to back home. Service was top notch. Anthony's and Square MFCG are the top 2 choices for pizza in Natick IMO until I'm priced otherwise. Looking forward to returning.

Cynthia C.

Yelp
A friend and I got take out from ACFP Natick. I got the original wings and a margarita pizza. I don't know what else to say but the pizza was awful. You don't put Parmesan on a margarita pizza and there was one tiny little basil leaf which was almost rotten. And the pizza was torn apart in the box. The wings were dried out. They used to be one of the best in town but apparently they're skimming on ingredients, presentation and food. Never again.

Andrew K.

Yelp
I like thinner crust pizza made in coal ovens and this just hits the spot. Their selection definitely has me wanting to try more. They have a reward system and the service was good :)

Peter W.

Yelp
We've been here a few times and really enjoy the food, service, and management. There is a great view of the open kitchen from almost every seat in the main dining room. When the weather is nice they have more seating in the porch area. There is a good size full bar in between the two areas. The pizza's are great as expected and there is a good variety of toppings. The chicken wings are unique with sauteed onions and bread. Some entrees are good, others are ok. It seems like they've changed the menu several times. The unsweetened ice tea is a bit weak in flavor. The cheesecake was good.

Doggypatchable ..

Yelp
I went for luncH on Tuesday February 4 th before a appointment, and I had the Fagioli Italian soup , it was only a cup , but I almost cried , it was amazing . I thought they had my father cooking in the kitchen , but he passed about 40 yeaRs ago February 14 th . Any it was a true original Fagioli soup , not Olive Garden which doesn't make it right. I have tried many at different restaurants and either they don't make it right or it to watery , this was truly Sicilian . Peggy our waitress was wonderful she was sso happy to hear that I loved the soup and to how I raved about it .and yes their pizza is to die for as well and salads too. I will definitely go back for more , I found my happy place .Thank you Anthony's for bringing back some wonderful memories of suuch cHildhood soup that my dad made , it was perfect.do no t change a thing .

Julie B.

Yelp
This review is long overdue. Just great! Love the pizza and salads! Yum! The crispy flavor packed pizzas will keep me and my family coming back for more, hands down! Also the service has always been excellent. Special thank you to my last awesome bartender Mo! You are a lovely person and you rock! And Justin, the manager, really knows how to keep his customers happy. Thank you for the great service!!!

Bruce S.

Yelp
Chain yes, but it's still one of my favorites. Not a bad thing on the menu, especially the wings and Margarita pizza. Happy hour specials till 6!

John I.

Yelp
I ordered take out for pick up at 6:10pm, their suggested time. The order was actually ready at 7pm!!! Hope you have a lot of extra time. They definitely are feeling the difficulty in finding employees. The cooks are completely overwhelmed!! And, because of this huge backup, my request for NO hot peppers in my meatball sandwich was ignored. Waste of money!!

Brittany T.

Yelp
So happy Anthony's came to our area - their wings and cauliflower pizza are unmatched!! We've been three times since they opened and have had great service and food every time. I love the fact that you can taste how fresh their ingredients are - it really makes their food stand out from a lot of other pizza places. They also have what they call "theater" seats where you can sit and watch the cooks toss pizzas and the huge coal fired oven. Anthony's will be a mainstay in our rotation :-)

Cassandra P.

Yelp
Really enjoyed this place! The pizza is awesome and so are the wings. Everything is made in the coal fire oven. The staff is friendly and efficient, the atmosphere is nice there is a view of the ovens so you can watch your pizzas being made. Reasonable priced. Good lunch or dinner place!

M S.

Yelp
The waitress was nice. That is all I can say which is positive. Supper expensive ($7 for two ice teas). Ordered chicken wings and they were burnt and dry. They took one of the orders off the bill so 2 ice teas and 5 wings cost $15. Would have gone back to try the pizza but not at those prices. But to end on a positive note, the waitress was nice.

rosann s.

Yelp
Love, love, love this place!!!! We went to the Newton location for the first time in February and had the Roasted Cauliflower Pizza. Delicious!! I like the well done crust, which is their thing, and the mix of cauliflower, garlic, olive oil and cheese was perfection. So, we signed up for their club. We live in Framingham, and we're excited that a new location was opening in Natick. As members of the club we had signed up for in Newton, my husband received an email for us to attend their soft opening, where the food was free and the money from the drinks donated to ALS. We went with my mother-in-law and a friend. We had the meat ball appetizer, arugula salad, wings and the cauliflower pizza again. Everyone was so nice. The food was wonderful, in fact, I think the cauliflower pizza was even better than in Newton!! The Staff was being trained, and they were very open about that. Our waiter, his trainer and the Manager spent a good amount of time with us, making us feel welcome. The service was very good and the soft opening ran very smoothly, in my opinion. We returned again this week, on a Tuesday. We ordered the spring salad and a pizza with pepperoni and sausage. Once again, delicious! It was pretty busy as well, which was nice to see on a Tuesday. While we had a different server, the Manager, trainer and server from the soft opening remembered us and made us feel welcome again. I am so happy this place opened so close. It will be a go to place for us!!

Lori D.

Yelp
First time here. We sat at the outside part of the bar. Here in the afternoon, atmosphere was good. Looks like a good bar selection, although we did not partake. Service was good. They acknowledged it was our first time here and offered to let us taste the signature wings. We tried both kinds and they were really good. We ordered the ones with the spicy dry rub. They were delicious. My main course was an Italian Spring Salad when chicken. It was not great. The greens, veggies and dressing were fresh and tasty but the chicken was cold and rubbery. I suspect it was cooked yesterday or before and it's kept cold for salads. I prefer freshly prepared hot chicken, sliced and placed on top of my salad. Hubby had a chicken sandwich on focaccia. It looked delicious and he said it was good. We will be back. Looking forward to trying the pizzas and meatballs.

Bryan H.

Yelp
Said it was going to be 40 minutes for pick up. Still currently waiting at Anthony's right now - 70 minutes and counting. It's not even that busy. They have given us a card for free wings now every time for being late, but this is inexcusable. Every time it's "sorry here's free wings". There's no reason why they should be causing customers to wait this long. Update: still waiting. Now waiting 90 minutes for 2 pizzas a salad and 5 wings. Tons of open seats. It's not even full here. So there was some word of a fire drill that occurred prior to us coming (they've been late w our order before but I believe them). However, they did not prioritize take out orders and the manager made a poor decision to not call folks and tell them there would be a delay. Nor did they stop taking orders so they could catch up. This is poor decision making done by their manager. They could have notified their customers but they didn't. I will recommend other establishments to my friends and family in the area.

Nicholas B.

Yelp
*Readers Note* took a pizza for Take-Out did not dine. Also went on Marathon Monday at around 5:00pm so peak was not evident. Also to give leeway when due; This was a Grand Opening day** Pizza. Many styles, coal, brick, pan, clay and classic conventional. Coal Fired is unique as it seems to heat the air around the pizza creating a sort of "light airy crust with a somewhat salty wooden taste" at least thats my take. Now Anthony's does a similiar job but more of a "if you ever wondered what it would be like to chew on a Tempur-pedic foam mattress" like density. Be prepared to chew and I say chew 8-14 times. They also have decided to do what I like to describe "The Picasso Affect" with there tomato sauce. They dont spread sauce and then lay down cheese-what happens is they 'dab chunky italian plum tomato sauce and then fill in the gaps with a thin layer of mozzarella cheese. The cheese has an intense flavor that adds a moderate level of saltiness to the pizza. You will also find that unless you are absolutely famished that you leave crust. I do not like to waste but I found myself after the 4th slice leaving about 2inches of the crust uneaten. I rate pizzerias based on their Cheese you see, if you can't make a decent cheese pizza well.. Your specialty entrees and premium pizzas better be the real deal. Anthonys Coal Fired Pizzeria's Cheese to me is a 3/5 Stars because I respect the fresh ingredients; However the Pizza was 18.00 dollars (got the large to adequately portion and review) and a 30 minute ride home left it decently cold and if you didn't know I just bought it a "left out since midday type structure " So why the 4 star review? your probably thinking I just don't want to be that guy to bash a place that just opened right? No I am giving a 4 star review because I did not experience the whole package. But what I did experience was not "so incredible I had to call my mom right away" The Restaurant is small in comparison to most restaurants I have been to. They probably could seat about 60 people MAX. They have a full bar that has an enormous bay window that can fully open to the great outdoors. They have seating around their prep area that would be great for kids to sit and watch. There is a outside area that can fit probably an additional 10-15 people that is setup as a fully functional balcony. The atmosphere is not quiet but not overly loud even at full house I imagine due to the high warehouse-like ceilings. Parking is generous but for new folks and a friendly reminder to others their is only 1 way in and out of the plaza so if your trying to grab and go on a busy night or busy Saturday afternoon you will hit some decent lag. I would Like to update this review once I have revisited which should signal you all at the time of this I do recommend this location the staff was good and from what I observed the management is fully competent and leads their staff to success. Thank you and I hope deep down I find a worthy Cheese pizza here. Someday perhaps.

M E.

Yelp
Love this place! We have been a few times now and it's great. It's also right in our neighborhood and easy to get to. Although you can get 49 cent delivery from UberEats so sometimes we order take out but it's more fun to go in the restaurant. It's a great atmosphere and great friendly people. Give this place a chance you won't regret it. The chicken wings are amazing and the Meatball and ricotta pie is out of this world. My only complaint is that when we order take out and order a huge order of wings we never get enough blue cheese dressing. But we took care of that by having one stashed in the fridge.

Rob N.

Yelp
Ok, so no mouth watering photos here, but just an honest review of an existing Anthony's fan (previous great experiences on North Shore). Straight away, I will tell you this was a takeout order at 5 pm during the opening week, so my rating is adjusted accordingly for both the not busy atmosphere and the opening week jitters. No issues whatsoever with the online ordering system (I thought) and I ordered meatballs in red sauce with ricotta, 20 count wings (herb rubbed and cooked in the same oven as the pizza) and a half cheese-half pepperoni/mushroom pizza. Arrived at the restaurant on time and was greeted by two charming employees who seemed eager to help. Once I stated I was there to pick up a takeout order, I was shifted to an awkwardly confused cashier who needed guidance to help package our food and needed to be told several times that I had prepaid. Got the food home only to discover that we were the recipients of a completely cheeseless pepperoni and mushroom pizza. At least the meatballs and wings did not disappoint. We'll be back before long for we're in the neighborhood, but will be expecting more!

Vanessa K.

Yelp
My husband and I have an awesome experience every time! The staff is amazing, especially the manager! They are extremely attentive to all our needs and goes above and beyond to make us happy! The last time we got complimentary wings (delicious btw) and we ordered them this time around! Today, we got complimentary dessert! Can't say enough about this place. We'll be back soon! 100% recommend.

Kelsey W.

Yelp
Awesome experience for dinner tonight!! The vibe was on point and the Food was amazing! We got the salad, a pepperoni pizza and the carnivori pizza. All were exceptional! Best part was the service- our waitress Viona was a doll, and the manager Justin went out of his way to make sure we enjoyed our meal and experience. We will absolutely be back for dine in and take our service!!

Gombkötő I.

Yelp
Hi I come Anthony's 3 or more time a week. They are very friendly I am I love the pizza here. Food come out fast and good. Plus they have the best bar tender ever her name is Abby. She nice and sweet.

Linda C.

Yelp
My husband and I went in on a Saturday and got the wings. Half dry rub and half garlic romano. Both were delicious but the standout was definitely the dry rub wings. Cooked perfectly with the most delicious dry rub we have ever had. A little spicy but not too much. The service was great and the cooks gave us some of the dry rub to go as we liked it so much.

mark f.

Yelp
This place just opened and I came by after work on a Monday afternoon. Bar set up is really cool. Nice big bar with Indoor/outdoor patio thing going on. The pizza was very good. Had the wings too and really enjoyed their original take on them. Bartender was funny and cool. This place is just getting its legs under it and they're already doing a nice job. Looking forward to a date night here this summer.

William V.

Yelp
Pizza was nothing special got chance to try wings they not hot enough!! Bartender was nice , but other staff were very young and no real personality . I know it new but you can see it needs leadership it's somewhere I'd like to succeed sometime it takes awhile to find the right mix .

Michael F.

Yelp
The worst customer experience. Hopefully this location will go out of business just like the Newton location recently did. There are so many other pizza options in the area that treat their customers better.

Ally W.

Yelp
Well the customer service was awful! Bartender was rude from the start. Good food is what gets people to come the first time but nice service is what gets people to come back again. In my case I didn't even want to stay for food so I can't even review that ! Disappointing experience

Shannon M.

Yelp
The bar tender tried to embarrass me in front of the bar saying my ID was fake when I also had proof of my passport and credit cards. Horrible service and pizza was equally bad

Gary S.

Yelp
Great pizza definitely worth the price. Cooked perfect both times I have been in here. The staff was friendly. The hostess welcomed us as soon as we walked in the door and sat us outside as it was a beautiful day. I believe her name was Emma. Like the outside bar addition too. I don't remember that being there when they first opened buy I might have missed it. Love the open kitchen look and outside patio.

Geoff Z.

Yelp
I've been here two times recently and the pizza is definitely the best in the area. A little bit pricey but definitely good. Only thing disappointing is I've tried to get the egg plant twice and it was sold out both times hoping I'll get to give it a try soon.

Steve B.

Yelp
Stopped by for a bite in the middle of the day. I have been looking forward to trying Anthony's for a long time and heard nothing but good things about them on the radio,. Walked in asked the girl girl behind the counter where to sit she pointed at the bar . No bartender for about 5 minutes , finally comes behind the bar and pours HIMSELF a coke. Finally asks me if I want something he got me menu , and a glass of water . Disappears ! Another person comes behind the bar waits on a guy who just walked in. Then gets my order after the new guy . The new guy gets his appetizer, then his meal . It's now been close to 25 minutes . Finally I see my plate slowly coming out the kitchen with a waitress and the bartender points down to new guy and she gives the plate to him. I sit for a couple more minutes to see if anything is going to happen and I finally give up and leave Nobody says a word as I leave. I work in the vicinity in a 100 plus employee place and also handle the catering for special events at our establishment DO NOT BOTHER GOING NEAR THIS PLACE !

David W.

Yelp
Nice atmosphere, good food, a little pricey. Pizza was very good, but not phenomenal as I had hoped. It's still chain food. The wings were unique and I highly recommend trying them as an appetizer. Service was friendly and the place was clean. Ample parking and there are other businesses located in this strip mall that can be accessed via the Route 27 interchange with Route 9/Worcester Rd.