Caitlin W.
Yelp
Usually my reviews involve me expending a lot of words to explain why some weird, grungy little place I like is really, truly worth five stars IN MY HEART, but that won't be necessary here, because Arthur's is a place that should be pretty clearly recognizable as Good to any thinking person. I'd never been here pre-recent renovation and triumphant reopening, but its current incarnation reminds me of a lot of some of the beautiful NYC-expat-owned cafes down in Columbia County, with the 200-year-old hardwood floors matched with solid wood furniture and hand-lettered signage, the lovingly house-made pastries (they even bake their own English muffins for the delicious breakfast sandwiches), the locally-roasted coffee, and the bottles of Battenkill chocolate milk in the cooler.
This might sound like I'm saying that I think Arthur's is copying other places, but really I'm just excited that someone has expended as much obvious love and care (with everything from the shade of green paint on the walls to the brand of chocolate they use for the cookies) on a cafe in Schenectady as they do in towns that run on the money (and the preferences) of wealthy weekenders. The grocery selection of mostly staples is fairly limited but probably very welcome to the local residents, and there's also plenty of Rose Apothecary-style items (attractively-designed cloth bags full of lavender bath salts, designy boxes of matches, etc) for people looking for gifts. Also, I spied with my little eye on their website that they're working on being able to serve beer and wine soon as well. If anyone needs me, I'll be there hogging a table from open to close.