Elizabeth Y.
Yelp
Wow, I can't believe I came to Athan's for four years but never tried their croissants. I came back after a year (due to not needing to be in Brookline for a while) and tried an almond croissant because of all of the rave Yelp reviews.
The croissant was amazing! And at a great price too! I didn't realize that Athan's made basically all of their products, including the baked goods and the chocolates that I've bought--I only found out this past visit from the friendly girl working at the counter. I would definitely get the almond croissant again--it was super flaky and had the right ratio of flaky layers:soft interior, and the almond filling was creamy and delicious!
I also love their chocolates--they make great gifts, and I'm not even sure how many of the little ballotin boxes I've given as gifts over the years. (They wind up pretty reasonably priced and are cutely packaged with a sticker and ribbon.) I also have gotten chocolates "a la carte" for snacking, and they're always great and fun to share. They have a color-coding system for the wrappers, which I learned over my many visits (shiny gold=dark chocolate, matte gold=milk chocolate, other colors=usually fruit/floral I think?) I love these chocolates because of their realistic size (perfect for sharing), smooth, high-quality chocolate, and delicious fillings! One of my favorites was rose loukoum (not positive about spelling), which was a chocolate with a fruity-floral chewy-ish jelly. I also love their chocolates with alcoholic fillings, although the alcoholic flavor is pretty strong, in case you don't like that.
This last time, the chocolate table was looking sparse (due to some staffing issues), but I picked up one of the alcoholic milk chocolates and a dark chocolate mint cup. I was worried they might be stale because of potentially low turnover during covid times, but they were delicious and as fresh as the ones I remembered in the past. Hopefully they will bring back more of the other chocolates soon :)