Regina R.
Yelp
UPDATE on 4/19/23: Athena is changing locations and is closed until the new space is ready. It'll stay in Rogers Park, but might not be open until Sept or Oct 2023.
This is my home away from home. Great selection of games, good sandwiches and other snacks, delicious milkshakes and coffee drinks, and most importantly, an owner and staff who are hands-on. They sometimes play games with guests, lead a Saturday game event, and are there for any questions or requests that might come up (some game places are like the wild west with hands-off staff). Plus the people who go there are friendly and open to having you join their game or they're happy to join yours if you're looking for players. I love Athena.