Anna V.
Yelp
I have really mixed feelings about this place. On the one hand, it has a primo collection of art and books about art (and books about unique, spectacular musicians). It is truly a jewel -- a one of a kind institution that offers rare and wonderful opportunities. (Not to mention that the director of their "A-list" program is cool, down to earth, and approachable.) So for that, I'd give 4 or 5 stars.
But my (very polite) email requesting more programming on weekends (due to the fact that I have to work) prompted a prissy, grouchy reply from the executive director -- who said that they have PLENTY of weekend programming, thankyouverymuch, and some of it is even in the evenings (who cares that I work until 6 and simply can't make a 6:30pm curtain time?) so if I don't attend their programs I'm clearly not worth accommodating. In my more charitable moments, I chalk this up to the director having a bad day, but I'd still like to give that attitude NEGATIVE stars.
Given all of that, I have to conclude that his place clearly has more potential than it is living up to. I know they have probably made their schedules with the independently wealthy and society wives in mind, but I'm neither of those things -- most people aren't. I know that keeping those traditional patrons is important, but there seems to be very little consideration of what the rest of us need. I'd like to think that my "non-traditional patron-ness" doesn't disqualify me from taking the Athenaeum's classes and attending their lectures. And they don't -- but for the few things that I do attend, I simply pay the non-member ticket price. But when they make so little effort to reach out to me or cater to my needs, I don't feel that paying the price (no matter how reasonable) to become a member is appropriate, either. I don't begrudge them their choices, but by the same token they shouldn't be surprised that their actions influence MY choices, too.
If you have the luxury of being able to make your own schedule, run, don't walk to the Athenaeum. If you're like most people who have to work, commute, and deal with the humdrummities of the work-a-day world, though, they just don't take you into account, so you might not have much opportunity to enjoy their world-class, unique, wonderful offerings (but by all means, seize whatever opportunities that you can!)
To sum up; I'm torn on how to rate this place -- it is both disappointing and fabulous at the same time. So I split the difference and gave it three stars. If they ever become more accessible (though perhaps their inaccessibility gives them some kind of moneyed cachet that they want to maintain?), they'll truly begin to sparkle. And perhaps there is hope -- the A-list is clearly a step in the right direction.