Linda J.
Yelp
I am baffled by all of the positive reviews of this restaurant. My co-workers and I have worked near this restaurant for over 20 years and in the past have dined in with mixed results, sometimes the food was decent and other times, not so much. However, each and every carry-out order we have placed has been a disaster. I have been the main recipient of the carry-out food as my co-worker would sometimes take clients to the Auburn Cafe and bring lunch back for me.
I have never been impressed with the food as most of it is bland and flavorless, the food portions are minimal and the quality is some of the worst I've ever had at a Greek or Coney Island type restaurant. Therefore, my co-worker has pretty much stopped taking clients to the Auburn Cafe so we haven't experienced the food in many years.
Today, we decided to get carry-out for lunch, and after viewing the rave online reviews, we thought we'd give the Auburn Cafe another try, hoping the Cafe lived up to all of the hype this time.
BIG MISTAKE!!!
While the online menu offered a small but varied enough menu to pique our interests, the prices were way out of line for a restaurant of this type. However, we were hungry, and the restaurant is so close we took a gamble and ordered a steak greek salad for me and a gyro and side of rice for my friend. (As a side note, the "combos" come with lemon potatoes, and they don't let you substitute with rice, fries or a small salad. The person who answered the phone suggested we just order the gyro and then get a side of rice, which actually brings the price of the "combo" up from $10 to almost $12, which is a great way for them to earn an extra $2 for a swap that wouldn't have cost them a dime.)
The Greek salad came in a small styrofoam carry-out container and was literally only 1/2 filled with lettuce, topped with a minimal amount of feta, a couple of slices of tomato and cucumbers, onions, and a very small, tough, flavorless, and underseasoned piece of low-quality steak. To add insult to injury, the ranch dressing I ordered consisted of two packets of Marzetti's overly processed gunk. I expected a cup of freshly mixed ranch dressing, which is what I've always received whenever I've ordered a salad at this type of restaurant and was sorely disappointed with pre-packaged dressing.
For this low-quality salad, I paid $12.95 + tax, which was about $8 too much. So, for a small gyro sandwich, a small salad, 1.5 cups of plain white rice, and a 1/4 cup of tomato sauce (for the rice) we paid almost $28. Outrageous!
I don't mind paying premium prices for good quality and tasty food, but this garbage was not worth the styrofoam it was packaged in. Needless to say, this will be the last time we ever order from the Auburn Cafe.