Audrey's Fine Baked Goods

We are still blown away by our wedding cake from Audrey’s Bakery! It was everything we dreamed of — vintage, elegant, and absolutely stunning. People rarely go out of their way to compliment a wedding cake, but ours was getting praise all night long. Guests couldn’t stop talking about how beautiful it looked and how amazing it tasted. Every flavor was a hit! Audrey’s truly went above and beyond and made us the most perfect cake — it was such a special (and delicious) part of our day. I can't wait edit this review with photos.

We tasted cakes from three different bakeries while choosing our wedding cake, and after our planner recommended Audrey’s, we quickly understood why. Their cakes were by far our favorite — fresh, flavorful, and beautifully made. Audrey’s was also so reliable and easy to work with. Delivery showed up exactly on time, everything was set perfectly, and the cake looked gorgeous on display. We wanted something that felt special but didn’t break the bank, and Audrey’s was the perfect fit — budget-friendly without ever compromising on quality or taste. We chose two flavors: vanilla with fresh strawberry and whipped cream, and chocolate with cream cheese filling. Both were absolutely delicious, and our guests raved about how good the cake was. A beautiful, tasty, and stress-free experience from start to finish — we couldn’t recommend Audrey’s more!

We used Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods for our cake, the recommended vendor through Land’s End. Since I’m not a big cake person, we decided to keep it simple with a small, vintage-inspired heart cake just for the cake-cutting ceremony. Katie completely understood our vision and executed it beautifully — the design was elegant, charming, and exactly what we had in mind! Even though cake wasn’t a big priority for us, the one they created was absolutely delicious and exceeded our expectations. It was the perfect sweet touch to our day, and we’re so grateful for their creativity and professionalism. Highly recommend!

My family and I have used Audrey’s for years and have also recommended it to my friend for their wedding and engagement party. They do not disappoint and truly make your cake dreams come true. Not only do the decorations on the cake look amazing but it tastes even better. I will always come back to this bakery (even though I am not local)

Audrey’s made my wedding cake for 100 people and it exceeded expectations! Found them on theknot.com and they were communicative and easy to work with from beginning. We live in bklyn, so we never went for a tasting, just took a chance. I’m so happy we did. Our cake was gorgeous and delicious and prices so reasonable.

We ordered a birthday cake for our grandson. The presentation was nice, and the service we received was great. Unfortunately, the taste of the cake was very disappointing-it simply did not meet our expectations. Horrible! While we appreciated the efforts in presentation, the flavor fell short, and we will not order from this bakery again.

Another smash hit by Aundrey’s in sayville! They did my baby shower desserts and gender reveal baked goods. And now they made my sons smash cake for his 1st birthday. It was delicious and gorgeous. Such a big hit and my son loved it ! Will always go the Audreys for all our baked goods.

Worked with Audrey’s on our wedding cake and were extremely happy! The cake was delicious and working with Katie was easy!! Would definitely recommend for weddings and everyday baked goods!

What an adorable little bakery Audrey's Fine Baked Goods is in West Sayville. I had a craving for a special cupcake today, and Audrey's delivered exactly what I needed. The service was friendly and welcoming, and the sweet smells coming from the back were absolutely delightful. I chose the chocolate chip cupcake with marshmallow frosting and a cherry on top. The frosting was light, fluffy, and just the right amount of sweet -- but the cake itself was the true star. Moist, rich, and utterly heavenly, I could've easily devoured a baker's dozen. A must-visit spot for any sweet tooth.

Always always a great stop for some quick treats but always our go to for cakes. There is nothing better than Audrey's cakes. They have made us desert and special cakes for special events. They are always easy to contact and quick service.

Excellent black and white cookies! Audrey's has a great selection of familiar favorites and new items to try.

We originally ordered our wedding cake elsewhere as it was included in the venue package, but that bakery has gone downhill. I asked Audrey's to make our second anniversary cake and they did a fantastic job. The strawberries and whipped cream filling is so fresh and the chocolate fudge is delicious. They did everything I asked and more!! We'll be getting our anniversary cake from here going forward.

It just isn't the same Audrey's we all loved. Thanksgiving pies were terrible tasting and actually half the size of the pie pan. The middle only has filling that was dry and tasteless. Got a chocolate chip cake, an all time favorite month prior, had maybe three chocolate chips! And tasteless. A true disappointment! No longer my go to Bakery. Have to find another

Love this bakery! They consistently come through with wonderful options even for those with allergies. I'm gluten free and their cake was delicious. My only gripe is I suppose they have become very popular, moreso than can meet demand. Twice this past year I called for a very small cake (enough to feed 6-8 people) 1 week ahead and was told they were sold out. The second time I was told they were selling out a month or more ahead for simple birthday cake requests. As a result I haven't been here as recently as I would like. I hope that next time I need a cake though I can call it in early enough.

Unfortunately Audrey's has disappointed us a few times recently. Came here for some Irish soda bread early on St. Patrick's Day and while I appreciated the options to have it either with or without raisins and with or without caraway seeds, I was disappointed we couldn't get it iced. I also needed a rye bread and there was none to be had. The only option was a plain white loaf. The staff can also be quite cross when trying to place a custom birthday cake order. We miss the leaf cookies too, they only offer them sugar free nowadays. I hope this downward trend doesn't continue since we did love this place.

Audrey's Fine Baked Goods was used by our venue for our wedding cake. Not only was our cake delicious, but it looked amazing too. We had a vision for a beach themed cake and Audrey's delivered. We got so many compliments on the taste and look. The best part too: actual icing was used instead of fondant.

5/5 for service, flavor and design. I ordered my daughter's cake from Audrey's for her first birthday and they EXCEEDED expectations. The cake design came out beautiful - exactly how I envisioned and it was delicious. We received compliments from all of our gues

Had Audrey's make my wedding cake - it was literally the best cake ever and had a bunch of folks coming to me saying so. Now we go back once a year to essentially recreate the same flavors just on a small scale and they've delivered in both quality and speed and have pretty comparable prices for a simple custom cake. So for cake - definitely recommend. Is definitely like to stop by for random cookie orders at some point because they do have a counter with baked good you can pick up right there.

Love this bakery! The brownies, rainbow cookies, turnovers are all fantastic. Quality bakery

Saw some pictures on Facebook of some of there amazing cakes, so I decided to try that myself. I showed him a picture of a cake with flowers on it, and they did an amazing job. Everyone at the bridal shower was amazed on the beauty of this flower cake, and the way it tasted. If you're having a special occasion I highly recommend this bakery

So much of the wedding was important to me- the cake was not one of those things lol. Our cake was included with our venue. We had the option of Audreys or Rolling Pin. We had been at showcases at our venue and in general, just liked Audreys better. We gave both a shot with the tastings, because why not they're free. Rolling pin gave you only 3 options and had to pick a filling with a specific cake flavor so we paid to paid others so we could have other combos. They gave it in a pick up box and you just take it home. Overall their cake was dry and the fillings had weird aftertaste. Audreys made the cake tasting a whole experience. They have a small table for you to sit at, they go through all the cake appearance options, and gave us a whole platter to try all the different combinations. It was such a good experience we ended up spending extra on the cake to get the flavors we wanted. The cake came out amazing! Also we froze it and had it on our 1 year- it was so good even a year later!

Oh my gosh.. I'm in heaven with this delicious Rainbow Cookie cupcake it tasted just like it and was even better. Will be returning.

Audrey's takes the cake!!! Here's why... Over the years I have ordered many many cakes from Audrey's for several different occasions. They make a delicious cake, moist and fluffy, tasty and fresh. I have personally had their vanilla, devils food, red velvet, lemon and hazelnut sponge. All so good! I get fun filling combinations with different cakes and they are always so incredible. Cannoli, chocolate mouse, puddings and fruit filling are all my favorite! I can't decide! Also, a must have is their fresh made coffee. I love to grab a cup when I'm ordering my cakes. And try a pastry with it! Or their cinnamon sugar raspberry doughnuts! Or anything!! It's all so good! I will remain a loyal and returning customer, hope you all try!

Audrey's bakery makes the wedding cakes for Flowerfield, which is where we were married and everyone was obsessed with our wedding cake. So I decided who better to make our son's birthday cake. It was so adorable our son absolutely loved his Elmo cake. It was equally delicious. Well worth the drive to west Sayville

My family has been coming to Audrey's for years now. Hands down BEST carrot cake around! The baked goods are not only delicious, but they also look like artwork. The cakes, pastries, and other items always look and taste perfect. The assorted mini pastries are so unique. I always come here to buy my bread when I'm making spinach dip which requires a bread bowl. They have a nice selection of breads and they're always fresh. Because of this bakery, I get disappointed by all other carrot cakes. The service is always friendly. Located on Montauk hwy in West Sayville, this place is across from the golf course. There's limited parking in the front of the building, but plenty of spots on the side & back of the bakery. If you want to get some baked goods that not only look pretty but also taste fabulous, come here!

Tried to place an order for baked goods to be delivered after a funeral, two days in advance, was advised it's a holiday week and they are at their capacity. If 2 pounds of cookies and two dozen cupcakes, bring you over capacity with two day notice why stay in business. This is the second time I've had bad customer service from this bakery. Someone needs to give them some competition.

Delicious cakes and cookies. Very affordable. Nice staff. I recommend the chocolate mouse cake. Best I've ever had

We just did a wedding cake tasting here! And let me tell you, if you are considering Audrey's for your wedding cake, stop thinking. I will write an update once we get our wedding cake but the tasting experience was amazing! It was honestly so tough to choose because every flavor and filling was delicious. We tried the red velvet, vanilla, and carrot cake. The cake itself was super moist. The red velvet and cannoli cream combination was out of this world! Red velvet and cream cheese was a close second. The cookies and cream mousse, strawberry mousse, and white chocolate mousse were all fantastic. The carrot cake was also delicious (has raisins). We were able to do the tasting in their store and talk to Rachel about what combinations went well together. We were so pleased with her, as she presented all of the options. We had a choice between Rolling Pin and Audrey's for our venue and Audrey's cake and fillings were undeniably our top choice!!! We are so excited about our cake!

We just got married on a Thursday April 14th 2022 (the day before our 10 year anniversary) at The Vineyards at Aquebogue. The Vineyards allows you to choose between Audrey's and The Rolling Pin. We did cake tastings at both but Audrey's takes the best (not overly sweet) and was in person. The Rolling Pin seemed more in personal (take the cupcakes home) and was overly sweet and I love sweets! Our cake came out sooo great and flawless looking! We were bummed though a as we had to pay extra for cannoli filling with chocolate chips and most of our guests out of about 125 did not get any chips in their cannoli cake filling and we had left overs which noticed the sage thing. We did call them today and they offered to send us a gift card for a free anniversary cake. It was a kind was of trying to fix things but unfortunately that didn't change what 'em happened.

Normally have good things to say about Audrey's but this was super disappointing and embarrassing. The writing looks rushed and just horrible. Also spelt the word gorgeous wrong! Probably won't be recommending Audrey's anymore.

They always have the best baked goods and the brownies are always excellent! They offer a wide array of great and tasty baked goods!

I ordered the red velvet cake with buttercream frosting and cream cheese filling. It was super moist and the cream cheese was to die for.... it had an orange zest taste. Anyways Audreys far exceeded my expectations. Order your next cake from here.... it will not disappoint.

I love this Bakery! The mini pastries are amazing and delicious. I much prefer that I can but a variety of items rather than a few larger ones.

Best in the area! Delish and great variety I highly recommend great cookie's pastries and more

We had our wedding cake and groom's cake from this wonderful bakery! The wedding cake was simple; vanilla cake with chocolate mousse and vanllla pudding. It was amazing. Our wedding was on March 30 and we can still eat this delicious cake. Not too moist, not too dry. Got a groom's wrrestling cake,marzipan or rainbow cookie cake. This was the real deal. Not a Stop and Shop cake at all. Delicious! From now on we are driving from Westbury to West Sayville for all of our bakery items.. Well worth it!

Whenever I am in town visiting family, I make it a point to stop and pick up a cake from Audrey's. It's always a hit and there are never any leftovers! The cakes are so delicious! We recently picked up a cake for my grandma's 90th birthday. I was glad we were able to grab one despite covid. Audrey's has been come a staple for our family. We picked up a strawberry shortcake cake and it was so good! Thank you Audrey's!

You are the best creating cakes that make me happy... this time was for my baby 1/2 Birthday... I highly recommend this bakery... Thank you

I've had many different desserts from here and all of them seemed old. Looked great but that's as far as it goes

Very good bakery that always had a wide selection of pastries. Silk and satin are usually a hit with my family as well as the cappuccino cups and cannolis.

Best bakery !!They were so accommodating when I needed a cake at the last minute and it was absolutely delicious. Pricing is good they're not looking to rip you off and they're serving quality Baked goods. Highly recommend

Audrey's made our wedding cake and it was perfect! It was everything we wanted and more. Brianna was so amazing and helpful throughout the entire process. Lauren as well was a big help. Friendly staff. We got to try so many delicious different flavors and combinations that it was so difficult to decide. They even set us up with a sample mini cupcake tasting tray. They were all so incredibly good. We decided on a 4 tier lemon cake with fresh blueberries and a whipped cream center. Outside was a beautiful simple white buttercream wavy design to go with our waterfront wedding theme. Our coral cake topper was so unique and fit perfectly with the cake's look. All our guests said how light, refreshing, and fluffy the cake was. We were really happy with it. Excellent customer service and everything we tried at the bakery was fresh and super tasty!

All of a sudden this bakery can't accommodate anything ! Spoke with Katie when I called THE NEXT DAY to make my payment for a cake they could no longer accommodate. Lost a customer

I got my sons smash cake and also 2nd birthday cake from Audrey's. Both cakes were absolutely amazing! The French cream filling with fresh blueberries is so good! Everyone said the blueberries were SOO fresh! We'll be back again!

I want to like this bakery. I want SO MUCH to like this bakery since my sister-in-law and mother-in-law love it. However, I just can't. The cakes are affordable for a bakery, and the selection is pretty decent. The cake itself is denser than most and very, very moist ... but I just can't get past the frosting. It's heavy, and leaves an oily feel in my mouth. Whether it's the whipped cream or buttercream, there's just a residual layer of solid GREASE that sits at the roof of my mouth and back of my throat. The finish just isn't clean and leaves my tongue feeling dirty and weighted down. The decorations/designs on their pre-made cakes are unimpressive as well. They're just really simple or even elementary. I bought a Thanksgiving cake from there before, and the turkey design looked like a gloopy brown penis. Which was fine and funny, since it was just for fun and not for a party or family meal, but it should have been on CakeWrecks.com. I mean, the cakes are pretty good while you're eating them. They're really not bad -- moist, like I'd mentioned, and they slice cleanly and feel decent chewing. I just can't get over the oily finish in the frosting, because I feel like the last bite should be the best.

Audrey's Bakery did an AMAZING job on my cake for my dental school graduation. They were so great and worked with us to make sure we got exactly what we wanted! The cake was absolutely beautiful and it was so delicious too!

This place listens and responds Their goods are tasty and reasonably priced and.....it is edible artwork I've never been disappointed.

The Quick: That dark chocolate mouse cake is what any Choco lover craves. Great variety to satisfy any sweet tooth. The Details: When it comes to sweets, this places knows what it's doing. The chocolate mousse cake is literally what dreams are made of, while the fruit custard pies are delicious and perfectly bite sized. They also make custom cakes for weddings and special occasions that are beautiful and delicious. An overall great spot pick up something to bring to the party, or to grab desert because you're worth it. The Damage: Reasonable dessert spot.

Audrey's made the surprise groom's cake for my October 2012 wedding. I had hired a home-based baker back in November 2011 to make the groom's cake, but she ended up moving out of state in summer 2012 and so was unable to do it for me. None of the bakers she recommended to take her place were professional enough for my standards (one wanted me to drive to her bakery in Farmingdale on the afternoon of my wedding to pick up the cake myself, another told me that she guessed she could print out the e-mail I sent her and mail it to me to sign as a "contract type of thing" - um, what?!). I was left to scramble to find a replacement, searching the internet for a new baker, from Los Angeles, having never lived in Long Island or even been to a bakery there. Our day of coordinator came to my rescue and told me she'd heard good things about Audrey's. I started corresponding with Nancy in their office via e-mail and immediately experienced the quality of service and competency that had been missing from all my other experiences. Initially I was going to go with another bakery due to price (Audrey's was quoting me twice what I had agreed to pay the home-based baker, which does make sense because they are a commercial operation and have higher costs than someone baking a couple of cakes a month alone at her house), but when that bakery flaked on getting back to me with a contract, I went running back to Audrey's. I have to commend them for their professionalism and excellent service standards. Our groom's cake was a NY Islanders-themed cake for which I specified many design ideas - including a modeled hockey puck and stick, and writing on the cake board. It turned out perfectly (see the photo I added for the cake in all its glory at our reception). It was better than I envisioned. Inside was yellow cake with cannoli cream filling (to differentiate it from our chocolate and chocolate mousse wedding cake), and it was delicious! People were raving over how beautiful and fun it was. We couldn't take the leftovers back to Los Angeles, so all my inlaws' neighbors and co-workers got a great treat. I would definitely recommend Audrey's to anyone looking for a specialty or novelty cake, like a groom's cake, or anything with fondant work. I was so pleased.

Audrey's Fine Baked Goods are just that, Great cakes ordered on various occasions! Go check them out

Audrey's made our beautiful wedding cake. The cake was breath taking and looked exactly like the picture I gave them. The cake was moist and the filling was not too sweet (we went with a chocolate and vanilla cake with white chocolate mousse). Even after a year the cake tasted so good, my hubs wanted to eat the whole top but I thought it wouldnt be a good idea.

I am seeing an ongoing theme within the last few months and now I am not surprised of my own situation and latest encounter. I have been a customer of Audrey's for the past 20 years and have spent thousands on pastries and cakes through the years. I went in to order a 1/4 sheet birthday cake last Wednesday for Saturday. I was told they can not accommodate. No let me ask, just no you can only have an 8 inch pre-made. I left disgusted and disappointed. I then called Stanley's bakery and was told not a problem, I asked do I have to come down, Nope. Cake was ready on Saturday, and I was happily greeted and treated like they appreciate my business. Cake was terrific BTW. I emailed one of the contacts I had previously ordered an elaborate Audrey's Cake from expressing my disappointment asking to pass the message on to the powers that be. I never received a response. No apologies or even an excuse. Nada. Audrey's just lost a long term customer and Stanley's just earned one. I will travel the extra 10 minutes to order from them. Will I order bread from them (if they have) on my way home. Maybe. However they will never receive another Cake or pastries order from me

The staff are Creative, polite and professional. I ordered two cakes for my moms retirement/surprise birthday party, I found the ideas on Pinterest. The cakes came out beautiful and they really made the pictures come to life, they were amazing and a huge hit. All the staff there were so great throughout this whole experience, even the delivery man was all smiles and so nice. They were beautiful and delicious. We got so many compliments from our guests, they were just the perfect amount of sweetness. I highly recommend Audrey's to everyone!

I cannot even begin to tell you how impressed I am with Audrey's Bakery! I called on a last minute whim on a Wednesday to order a birthday cake for 25-30 people for my baby's 1st birthday party that Sunday. The woman I spoke to (Karen) was so friendly and accommodating. We emailed back and forth once about the design option ( we went with a buttercream icing with fondant stars and edible glitter- the cake was yellow cannoli filling) Not only was the cake nothing short of gorgeous, it tasted delicious. I was totally impressed, and everyone at our party raved. I will absolutely be using the bakery for all of our parties and events going forward, I thrilled.

I never write reviews but felt I had to for this place. My wedding venue came with a cake from this bakery, it was delicious then. They gave us the top part to freeze for the one year anniversary tradition. I wasn't looking forward to eating cake after a year but it was still the best tasting cake! I was surprised it was still so fluffy and flavorful. It was that great I had to come write this review.

I found Audrey's via Google and they did not disappoint at all. From the first email to the last bite of cake! I sent them some pictures and as you can see their attention to detail is just flawless! I added the plastic Mario topper but their little fondant characters were spot on. The inside of the cake was whipped cream and strawberry. Both we so fresh and tasty. I did a simple yellow cake which was moist and delicious. Everyone at the party was in awe over this masterpiece. Thank you! I have recommended it to everyone!

Katie was amazing to work with for our wedding cake. Due to Covid-19 we needed to change a million times and she emailed fast and always with great ideas! Highly recommend audreys for your wedding cake!

We ordered our wedding cake from audreys. They were so nice at the consultation. Very helpful and everything was absolutely delicious. Every wedding I've ever been to I skip the cake because it is never anything special. This cake was to die for! Our first bite I looked at my husband and said "wow this is amazing". Exactly how we ordered it and beautiful!