Aurelio's Pizza

I tried this place and was not disappointed!!! Such amazing flavor and the crust is so crispy and light. Wonderful chewy cheese, tasty sauce and great prices. I will be back!!

Great tasting pizza. Can't go wrong with Aurelios pizza. Ordered pepperoni, tomato, and mushroom, small pizza. Just enough for the two of us.

The pizza was way overpriced for what I got and it was small. The toppings was Cincy just did not do what I needed to do. I won’t be back. I won’t recommend it as a Google reviewer this place is a rip off. Sadly, if you want better pizza bigger portions go down the road. Domino’s has better pizza than they deal.

Love this place. Order carry out today. Posting current menu with prices. The other is 3 years old now.

First Time Experience: At 5pm on a Thursday, and was greeted after a few minutes and promptly told to seat ourselves. It wasn't busy and the server was able to bring our drinks and take our order in a timely manner. She was kind and still unable to meet our requests. We ordered a 15" Thin Crust "The Works" pizza with 2 modifications. 1 change in topping is allowed, and the second was approx $3. An 18" was served to us and we informed the server that we ordered a 15". She did not lower our bill. Half the pizza was not fully cooked and I could not eat the cheese half cooked. The sausage is spicy as is the marinara sauce. My sensitive system couldn't eat more than a tiny piece to try it. The pizza is way too expensive. $48. The cheese curds are good and are $10. I would only go back for the cheese curds.

My pizza I had delivered last night was absolutely delicious!!! Hot, full of flavor, and plenty of cheese and toppings all the way to the edges! Aurelios has the best pizza by far in LaPorte, IN! Well worth the price! Thank you!!!

I hadn’t eaten or ordered an Aurelio’s pizza in a couple of years due to a poor pizza the last time I ordered. I thought I would try again and ordered online for pick- up. Instructions were a 40 minute wait and provided me with a pick- up time. Nothing unusual or special on the pizza. A thin crust with basic ingredients. Pricing outrageous! $37 for a large sausage, cheese,pepperoni & onion. Picked it up on time. Box was barely warm and when I got home which is 7 minutes away the pizza was room temperature and appeared overcooked, dry and tasteless. Even when I heated in microwave it stillI was not juicy or better. Other crust options are deep dish or stuffed crust. Neither appealed to me so I ordered thin. This pizza was not appetizing to look at or eat. I will not return again. Years ago this was one of my favorite pizza places and it has gone downhill over the years. Disappointing. Ended up throwing out most of the pizza. Usually freeze for future meals. Not this time!

Even after 45 years Aurelio's remains the best pizza ever. We make it a point to grab a pie (or 4) whenever we get back to town.