Phillip L.
Yelp
We have been making staycations in the Carmel/Monterey area for many years...and whenever we walked by A W Shucks, it was always packed with patrons. On our recent trip to the area, we decided to give this restaurant a try by waiting for a table...they do not take reservations. The wait for a table wasn't long even though the restaurant was busy. One of our disappointments was the ambiance. More "pub-style" than we had hoped for. The other disappointment was the cost. On the positive side...our Server, Rebecca, was friendly and attentive throughout our meal. We ordered the following: Drink: Irish Coffee (4/5...good taste but not as "rich" as we prefer), Appetizers: Oyster "Shuckaffeler" (5/5...really yummy but for a dozen, a bit expensive). Main(s): Oyster Po' Boy (5/5), Prime Rib French Dip (5/5)...both sandwiches were good, but again, we felt that the prices were high. Our bill for the items ordered and listed above totaled $115.00 without the tip. Coming in, we were hungry...leaving, we were satisfied with everything except the cost. Rationalizing...yes, it's Carmel, everything here comes with a "higher" price tag. Yet there are other "favorite" eateries in town and the surrounding area...where spending this kind of money renders a true 5 Star experience. On this occasion, in this Yelper's opinion...A W Shucks Cocktail & Oyster Bar earned this "recommend" (if you're up for a very casual and decent, yet expensive meal) 4 Star review.