Patrick Mills
Google
I don’t like to leave negative reviews, but my stay at Axel South Beach was one of the worst hotel experiences I’ve ever had, and I feel it’s important to share. I came to get away from the cold of NYC for a few days of sun and relaxation, but what should have been a stress-free escape ended up being more stressful than living in NYC in the winter.
When I first arrived, I was "upgraded" to a corner room, which was spacious, so that seemed like a good start. But when I got back later that evening, the room was incredibly hot on an 80°F day. I tried adjusting the thermostat, but I kept getting an error message. I figured I could open the window to cool things down, but it was screwed shut. To top it off, there was no handle on the shower, so I couldn’t even use it.
I tried calling reception, but the phone just kept going to a busy signal (seemingly on purpose, because he was the only staff on the entire property). Eventually, I went down to reception in person. The receptionist was friendly and apologetic, but he told me that my room (217) was marked as "out of service" and, since the hotel was full, there was no other room available. So, I had to spend the night in a hot, uncomfortable room with no shower, a broken TV, broken phone, and no AC. On top of that, housekeeping knocked on my door at 8 AM, even though I had the privacy notice on my door. It was a pretty frustrating experience, especially for the price.
On the second day, an unapologetic reception moved me to another room, which had working AC, TV, and a phone, but NO hot water. After not being able to shower the day before, I had to settle for a cold shower. I also spent some time by the pool with a friend, but unfortunately, it was pretty dirty and had a strange smells, and just not well maintained. We didn’t feel comfortable relaxing there. The one bright spot was the pool waiter, who was friendly, prompt, and really made us feel welcomed, but we left after one drink.
I ended up cutting my stay short, and at $200/night plus a $44 resort fee (which only covered two small bottles of water and a pool that no one wanted to use), it just didn’t feel worth it. I’ve stayed at Axel Hotels in other cities—Barcelona, Buenos Aires, Maspalomas, and Berlin—and always had a great experience, so I was really disappointed by this one. The hotel felt dirty and neglected, and it's clear they’re under-staffed. The management could definitely use some improvement.
It's a shame because this hotel has a lot of potential. I would’ve loved to embrace the Axel brand, but unfortunately, I ended up switching to The Royal Palm (right next door), which is a much better experience, even though it cost a bit more. All in all, I feel like I scammed out of $500 for two pretty rough nights. It’s frustrating to leave a place feeling more stressed than when you arrived. I really hope the hotel takes the feedback seriously, because with some attention to detail and better management, it could be a great spot.