Babbo’s Pizza

My son and I ate here for the first time, this afternoon. It was a FANTASTIC experience! Easy and quick to order with TONS of Yummy selection. Portion sizes were generous and food was REALLY GOOD. Inexpensive for the quality of food and professional staff. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!

This place has the best pizza I've had in PA the cheese was flavorful the peperoni had some kick to it and they use good quality sliced sausage not that crumbled crap there crust had a perfectly burnished undercarriage and a nice crispy Crack to it not floppy great pie and a must try if your in the area

*BE CAREFUL* I had a very bad experience here. ☠️FOOD POISONING☠️ Food was old. Pretty sure it was from the old crusty hot sauce on their pizza. Fries were drowned in grease. Overall TERRIBLE experience had me and my fiancé SICK for days. I had to go to the hospital and get an I.V. Had me on the floor curled up. I was throwing up and pooping at the same time. I will never go back. Everytime I see or smell pizza it makes me feel sick. Ruined my life. Pizza will never be the same again. TERRIBLE customer service they took 4 people before they would even serve me.

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Babbo’s Pizza on a Monday looking for a place to take my parents out and being new to the area. I must say I was pleasantly surprised. Not only did I enjoy their delectable Grandma pizza, but I also had the best cheesesteak hoagie I have EVER tasted. No joke. Really enjoyed the sauce and a small was more than enough for 3 people. Definitely will be returning and highly recommend.

Good pizza, crust is a bit thicker than other shops in the area. Really like there Sicilian pie also

For a north new jersean this is barely frozen pizza.tasteless cardboardy soft crust ketchupy sauce with no herbs at all and mozzarella that just turned into a thick block of cheese when slightly cooled.not even a smile from the counter after leaving rest of $20 as tip...about 4 bucks.only saving grace?I'll never be back in Elizabethtown again to be so disappointed.

Food was good and was prepared quickly for pickup. There are tables if you want to eat there, and the service is just as good as it is for pickup. Ate there this time. Same good food prepared in a reasonable amount of time.

I’m from out of town watching my 2 little granddaughters while their mommy and daddy are in the hospital having their baby sister.So First time ordering here. I needed something quick for the kiddos and myself without lugging them all around. ( I’m getting old haha)I ordered on line, delivered through door dash and it’s Friday night! Kiddos got chicken tenders and fries and I got the tortellini in vodka sauce with grilled chicken and spinach!! Absolutely perfect experience! The food was awesome! Delivered within a half hour super hot!!! I wish I lived closer!!!!! Thank you for a fantastic experience!!!!

The staff was very nice and helpful. Ordered cheese pizza very bland, no flavor greasy. I can make better pizza in my home oven.

Tasty but messy ToGo ! Wanted a pepperoni pizza, tried their HotHoney, which was absolutely TASTY and cheesy and the honey was a great addition. My family and I also enjoyed the garlic knots - COVERED in jarlic and cheese, had a nice crunch/browning on them, we also BYO buffalo chicken pizza and that was tasty. Was my first time going there , and saw they had a drive thru window for pickup. How convenient ! Never had there experience. The service from the fella at the window was nice and got questions answered. Was advised by him not to utilize/rely on the "busy days" of window pickup cuz of how busy it is, although people go to pick up pizzas, some go and place orders for a pizza and sit in line and wait, messing up the queue. Good heads up! HOWEVER. ABSOLUTE MESS. Was soooo greasy. I am lucky I have black leather interior in my car, however I can only imagine the frustration and mess the grease caused when picking up the pizza and transporting it home. Absolute POOL of grease in my car seat leeched from the box and collected on the seat. Just imagining the grease getting on upholstery or beige carpet.. ugh. lol

Huge thank you to Babbo's Pizza that fed three of our club soccer teams and their families while we at the annual Hershey Cup this year! I called a week early to discuss and they assured me it would be no problem. Ordering 22 pizzas, 18 tenders and fried, and 29 salads I assuming something wouldn't be right and wow I was wrong! They nailed the order and the fabulous staff helped me load my car so nothing would slide or spill. Everyone enjoyed the food, nothing was missed and not a single complaint. We look forward to going back next year :-)

Amazing Food. EVERY TIME! Eat here every week or two. Great staff. Fresh ingredients. Tastes like NY pizza that I miss so much.

Delicious pizza. Both the white and grandma are excellent ( if you like garlic ). The tiramisu has a great flavor. Staff are friendly and the dining area is clean.

We wanted pizza for our last meal before going back home! You can order on line and pick up later! You will receive an email giving you the time to pick up! Really easy and convenient! This place is busy! People are really nice and work hard! The food : we ordered 2 pizzas and one soup. The pizzas are really good ! The soup was from a can. It was ok. They have 3 daily soup options and I would have preferred only one choice that was homemade! When I was picking up my order, I saw salad and calzones that looked yummy! Price: very affordable and big portions so keep it in mind when ordering

I had been to Babbo's once at their Mt Joy location and was planning to go tonight but then I found out they closed. Instead, they moved to Elizabethtown and changed the name a bit, focusing on pizza and sandwiches. When we walked in the door, I saw the sign saying, "Order at the counter." I wasn't expecting that and kind of disappointed. To be honest, when I go out for dinner, I like to be lazy. No work involved. Lunchtime is fine for counter service but dinner? So, we all looked over the menu and placed our orders. We received a pager and went to sit down. The dining room(s) is really large. The lighting is awful though. Bad fluorescent lights. The food came and I enjoyed my Sausage Parmesan Sub. Good flavor, nice soft bread (maybe a tiny bit too soggy in some parts). I shared an order of fries with my youngest and the crinkle cut were perfect. The rest of my party felt the food was decent but doubt we'll come back. I have other pizza joint options closer to my place and Sal's does table service. Sorry Babbo but I wish you well.

Delicious pizza and friendly staff. I thought i was lost at first bc the one entrance looks like a liquor store but then i realized theres another entrance. Small italian legit pizza place.

Not impressed at all. Ordered the burger combo. The fries were cold and stale ,the burger was cold and I just ordered it twenty minutes before I picked it up at the pickup window! Nothing was fresh made at all!

On our quest to find a great pizza place in town, last night we tried Babbo's Pizza. We ordered a large Sicilian with pepperoni, a large rancho chicken cheesesteak, and an order of sweet chili boneless wings. The portions were very large which was a great quality. The first thing we tried were the wings. They were really great. I would come back here and order those wings again, they were that good. The sweet chili sauce was a perfect blend of sweet and heat, and the wings were crispy and delicious. The Sicilian pizza was just okay. Like I said before, the portions were huge and the price point was right. The pizza was lacking something in flavor - maybe needed more sauce. The pepperoni flavor/quality wasn't anything to write home about. My fiancé said his chicken cheesesteak was very sloppy and messy to eat, but the flavors were good. He would be open to ordering another sandwich there, to try out. Overall, our experience wasn't fantastic, but we agreed we would probably go back and give it another shot in the future. The woman at the takeout window was very friendly when we picked up our order, which is always important to me.

All of their food is pretty good. Nothing amazing, not a overly big fan of their pizza but its decent. The difficulty they have is getting orders correct which they tend to miss a lot.

This is usually our go to for pizza in Etown. Staff is friendly and food is always out quickly. Love the drive up window too so I don't have to lug my kids in to pick up our order.

frozen food, gross chicken, and brown lettuce that's clearly been sitting for a while. don't bother!