Catherine B.
Yelp
TLDR: a small gourmet shop in Liberty Public Market offering delectable in-house olive oils and balsamic vinegars in dozens of flavors!
Baker & Olive is a must-try in the SD area if you like unique oils and vinegars that you can use for dressings, sauces, pastas, baking, etc. They have a wide assortment of flavors, the option to sample as many as you like, and sales on select bottles during holidays (might be year-round).
For the variety of options, convenience of location (there's so many other food, beer, and souvenir vendors in the market), and uniqueness, I found the pricing very reasonable at $9 for 3.4 oz, $14.99 for a 6.76 oz, and $19.99 for 12.7 oz. I picked up three small bottles and I rate them in order:
- Espresso balsamic vinegar: coffee flavor mellows out the sharpness of the vinegar for a smoother, richer finish
- Peach white balsamic: I do have a preference for white balsamics and this one incorporates the sweetness of a juicy peach well
- Fig balsamic: sweetness of the fig also mellows out the vinegar but I couldn't taste the fig note as well as the other two
That said, the flavors are subtle, meaning all the balsamic vinegars do still taste as they should - tangy, sharp, and acidic. By the time I was done choosing, I was probably half blood, half oil/vinegar, but no regrets LOL. I am happily making good use of the three I brought home, and the next time I am in SD, I will 100% be back to buy gifts for friends and more for my fam as well.
+ also would like to note that some reviews complain of the lack of service, but tbh as a major introvert, I appreciated being left alone to try all the flavors I wanted at my own leisure without someone constantly breathing over my shoulder (so you do you dude!)