Sarah W.
Yelp
Josh at 5Church told us about this speakeasy pizza joint earlier in the day, so we made it a point to pop in for a late night bite, especially after being quite disappointed by Burwell's around the corner.
Josh is from New Jersey/New York area, as am I. My future husband and I know good pizza, so when Josh said this was some of the best pizza he's had since coming down South from up North, we had to test his theory. He was right, it was pretty darn good.
We got a special pie mind you (not one straight off the menu but a different one offered on this particular night that came as a recommendation from the bartender). While we didn't test out the plain slice, I would still give this pizza a solid 6.2 on the Barstool pizza review El Pres scale. That's not bad for Charleston!!
Also, I just f*cking love Speakeasy vibes, so I think the ambience here really spoke to me more than anything. Future husband and I sat at the bar. I love sitting at bars with him because we both love to chat with other people, aka the bartenders, just as much as we like to chat with each other. Loves a good banter over pizza and drinks ya know?
I am on a tequila kick so I had the bartender whip me up some sort of version of a super sweet marg. Could've done without some of the added ingredients because I am not big on sugary drinks, but it hit the spot with the complement of the pie, me thinks.
We each had two slices at Bakers Bar and then called an Uber home. As per usual, when Joey says it's time to go home, I go harder, so I had him leave me out a third slice before he tucked the other leftover slices away into our hotel mini fridge. I am not big on leftovers so I needed to finish my overindulging night done right. I passed out after that third slice but definitely went to bed happy.
Good pizza makes me happy! I woke up in the middle of the night to post this review and am feeling only slightly regretful that I ate all that pizza & drank all dem drinks. I'm a really healthy person usually and this trip to Charleston has me behaving in quite the opposite manner from my usual tendencies, so that's the only reason why I feel slightly regretful. You only live once, so go enjoy the pizza and have a 3rd slice naked in your hotel bed if it's speaking to you.